Squatters rights withdrawn by European Court
Ecovillage Network UK
office at evnuk.org.uk
Mon Nov 21 18:21:58 GMT 2005
European Court of Human Rights makes landmark ruling to WITHDRAW Human
Rights of the individual in favour of Developers and Landlords.
Court overturns squatters' rights on land worth millions
· Strasbourg ruling favours development company
· Government told to negotiate compensation
Clare Dyer, legal editor
Monday November 21, 2005
Taxpayers face a compensation bill that could total millions of pounds
after a ruling that "squatters' rights" laws breached the human rights
of a property development firm.
The ruling last week from the European court of human rights in
Strasbourg is a rare example of a judgment upholding the human rights of
a company rather than an individual.
In what one lawyer described as "Britain's biggest land grab", JA Pye
(Oxford) Limited lost 23 hectares of prime land worth up to £21m to a
farmer who had used it for grazing for 12 years. Under the law of
"adverse possession", the House of Lords ruled in 2002 that the farmer,
Caroline Graham, was entitled to the land without paying a penny.
The Strasbourg judges ruled by four to three that the company's right to
enjoyment of its property was breached by Britain's failure to change
the law to protect landowners. They left it to the government to try to
negotiate compensation with the developers, failing which the case will
go back to Strasbourg for a ruling.
The government argued in court that public funds should not be used "to
indemnify a corporate property developer against the consequences of its
own incompetence". It said the company's loss should not be put at much
more than £1m, applying a discount for its failure over 12 years to
protect its title to the land.
Pye has obtained a valuation of £10m, taking into account the prospect
of planning permission for development. With permission the land could
be worth £21m. It also wants the government to pay the £1m costs it
incurred taking the case through the English and Strasbourg courts.
The Department for Constitutional Affairs said: "We're studying the
judgment and considering our next move."
The law lords ruled three years ago that the 23 hectares (about 57
acres) of agricultural land at Henwick Manor, Thatcham, near Newbury,
Berkshire, belonged to Ms Graham, who with her husband, Michael, had
used it as grazing land. Mr Graham died in a shooting accident in 1998
but Mrs Graham carried on his claim for the land.
The lords held that she was entitled to keep the land under the ancient
law of adverse possession - squatters' rights - which allow an occupier
to claim property as his own if he has occupied it without the owner's
permission for 12 years. The law, described by Pye as "legalised
robbery", was changed in 2002 but the change was not retrospective.
The Grahams occupied the land under a grazing agreement with Pye, but in
1984 the company refused a further agreement because it wanted to
develop the land. However, the Grahams continued to use the land and in
1997 Mr Graham registered cautions at the land registry claiming to have
acquired title by squatters' rights.
Legal action followed, which the Grahams initially won in the high
court. Pye got the ruling overturned by the court of appeal, but the
House of Lords ruled in the Grahams' favour, a decision Lord Bingham,
the senior law lord, said he had reached "with no enthusiasm".
The Strasbourg judges said the squatters' rights law might have been
justified before land was registered to avoid lengthy disputes over
ownership. But where land was registered, it was "difficult to see any
justification for a legal rule which led to such an unjust result".
The result for the company was "one of exceptional severity", the judges
added. The taking of property in the public interest without payment of
compensation was justified only in exceptional circumstances, they said.
Squatters' rights law ruled unfair
By Frances Gibb
Property owners are entitled to compensation for their losses
THE ancient legal principle of squatters’ rights has been dealt a blow
by a European ruling that people stripped of their properties under the
law of adverse possession should be paid compensation.
The European Court of Human Rights ruling could lead to the Government
paying out millions when owners lose their properties to others who have
had use of them over a period of years. Even though safeguards were
introduced under the Land Registration Act 2002 so that owners have to
be notified if a tenant wants to claim title, giving the owners a chance
to fight to keep their property, scores of claims are still being
brought under the old law of adverse possession.
The case was brought by property developers who lost a plot of land in
Berkshire worth at least £10 million to a family of farmers who acquired
squatters’ rights after being allowed to graze cattle there for more
than 12 years. The court ruled last week that the company, J. A. Pye
(Oxford) Ltd, should be compensated for the loss of its 23 hectares (56
Mark Loveday, a barrister specialising in property law, said: “This
ruling tears up 180 years of the law on adverse possession. It says that
there must be a right to compensation if people lose their property —
which was not the case under the old law. But there is still no right to
compensation under the new Land Registration Act 2002, so I think that
also may have to be looked at.”
Three years ago the House of Lords ruled that Caroline Graham and her
father Charles Denton had acquired title to the plot, which would be
worth up to £20 million with planning permission. The plot bordered
their farm at Henwick Manor, Thatcham, and the developers, J. A. Pye,
had let the family use it while it negotiated with local planners to
But the Strasbourg court ruled that the law of adverse possession that
had allowed the family to acquire the land violated article one,
protocol one, of the European Convention on Human Rights, which
safeguards a person’s right to property. It concluded that people could
not have their property taken away without due compensation, unless the
circumstances were exceptional.
The court said that the relevant Acts of Parliament that had deprived
the property developers of their title to the registered land “imposed
an individual and excessive burden”.
The court reserved any decision on the amount of compensation — likely
to be between £5 million and £10 million — but indicated that in the
meantime agreement could be reached between the Government and the
Since the Lords ruling the Government has brought in the Land
Registration Act to change the law on adverse possession so that
squatters have to give notice before claiming title to registered
property; but Mr Lowe said that the problem could still arise with
unregistered land, as it was difficult to know who the owners were.
Mr Loveday said that people bringing claims of adverse possession were
doing so under the old law based on the rights they had acquired before
the 2002 Act came into force. The ruling would now be used to defend
those claims, he said; but if people still lost properties, the
Government could face more compensation claims.
LOW DOWN ON THE HIGH LIFE
A Georgian townhouse in Covent Garden worth £20 million was occupied by
squatters in 2002. The owners secured an eviction order.
A disused police station in Stepney, East London, which once held the
Kray twins, was taken over by squatters in 2004. A claim for trespass
was obtained and the police broke in.
Milly Martinson, 85, was locked out of her home by squatters after
leaving for several weeks to care for her sister. One of the intruders
was jailed for four months.
Eurotopia 2005: Guide to EuroEcovillages and Intentional Communities
Price £12.00 inside/£15.00 outside UK (inc. P&P)
UK Pounds Cheque/PO to 'Ecovillage Network UK' (see address below)
Our specialist contact point for the UK EcoVillage movement.
Register free on the UK PeopleFinder - http://www.peoplefinder.org.uk
ECOVILLAGE NETWORK UK (that's us!) - http://www.evnuk.org.uk
Populating the rhetoric of rural sustainability
Volunteers: Russ, Nikki, Tony, Pam, and Joyce
PO Box 1410, Bristol, BS99 3JP
Tel. 0117 373 0346
email: office at evnuk.org.uk
EVN-UK MAILING LIST: http://groups.yahoo.com/group/ecovillageuk
Subscribe (approx. 1 post/2wks.): ecovillageuk-subscribe at yahoogroups.com
CHAPTER 7 - http://www.tlio.org.uk/chapter7/
The UK's Sustainable Rural Planning Campaign & planning office of 'The
Land Is Ours'
'The Land' magazine - 16-20pp. bi-yearly details from
The Potato Store, Flaxdrayton Farm, South Petherton, Somerset, TA13
email: chapter7 at tlio.org.uk
Telephone: +44 (0)1460 249204
ECOVILLAGE GUIDE BOOKS - available (postage included) from
Mulberry House, 19 Maple Grove, Bath, BA2 3AF - 01225 484472
UK > 'Diggers and Dreamers' - Annual directory of UK Communities - £6.00
EUROPE > 'Eurotopia' - You can buy this from us (see above)!
COTTARS AND SQUATTERS > Reccommended: UK land rights history - £10.00
PERMACULTURE MAGAZINE - http://www.permaculture.co.uk/
Quarterly colour mag. for enquiring minds and original thinkers everywhere.
Hyden House Ltd, The Sustainability Centre, East Meon, Hampshire GU32
info at permaculture.co.uk
Tel. 01730 823311
DIGGERS AND DREAMERS - Searchable community database
Diggers & Dreamers, a UK guide to communal living for more than 10 years
c/o Edge of Time Ltd, BCM Edge, London, WC1N 3XX, UK
info at diggersanddreamers.org.uk
Tel. 07000 780536
WWOOF - http://www.wwoof.org/wuk0.html
Worldwide Opportunities on Organic Farms
Join WWOOF, do some work, stay for free. Membership includes directory
PO Box 2675, Lewes, Sussex, BN7 1RB
fran at wwoof.org
PERMACULTURE ASSOCIATION UK - http://www.permaculture.org.uk
Supports individuals, projects and groups working with permaculture in
Third Floor Studios, 6 Carr Mills, 322 Meanwood Road, Leeds, West
Yorkshire, LS7 2HY
office at permaculture.org.uk
Tel/Fax: 07041 390170 and 0113 262 1718
GROUNDSWELL - http://www.groundswell.org.uk
Promoting and developing self-help initiatives with the homeless
U.K. COHOUSING NETWORK - http://www.cohousing.co.uk/
Sharing expertise and experience amongst the U.K. cohousing groups.
FOREST SCHOOL CAMPS - http://www.fsc.org.uk/about.htm
Camps for kids to get back to nature with the minimum of authority.
EUROPEAN FUNDING -
GLOBAL ECOVILLAGE NETWORK, EUROPEAN OFFICES - http://www.gen-europe.org/
Rosa-Luxemburgstr. 89, D-14806 Belzig, Germany - info at gen-europe.org -
0049 33841 44766
Ecovillage Office, Findhorn, The Park, Forres, Moray, Scotland IV36 0TZ
- ecovillage at findhorn.org - +44 (0)1309 690154
Minutes of meetings
European email list - post <euevforum at lists.gen-europe.org> - contact
webmaster at gen-europe.org
Download free & easy to use PGP encryption at http://www.pgpi.com
More information about the Diggers350