[Ir-l] WIRED: ACLU: Law Needs 'Carnivore' Fix
Paul Mobbs
mobbsey at gn.apc.org
Tue Jul 18 00:05:55 BST 2000
WIRED: ACLU: Law Needs 'Carnivore' Fix
by Chris Oakes
3:00 a.m. Jul. 12, 2000 PDT
The American Civil Liberties Union, on Tuesday, urged Congress to amend
outdated electronic privacy laws following news of an FBI system capable of
large-scale email interception and analysis.
"There's no clear law that authorizes Carnivore," said ACLU associate
director Barry Steinhardt. "But the FBI and the Justice Department ... will
argue that there's no clear law that prohibits it. And Congress needs to
put some real limits on what law enforcement can do."
Steinhardt and other ACLU members sent a letter Tuesday evening to
Representative Charles T. Canady (R-Florida), chair of the Constitution
Subcommittee of the House Judiciary Committee.
The ACLU urged Canady's committee to prohibit Carnivore-type systems -- or
"dragnets," as Steinhardt called them -- that give law enforcement
officials access to large quantities of communications.
"It is a system for intercepting huge volumes of email and it's a system
that was never contemplated by Congress when it passed the Electronic
Communications Privacy Act" of 1986, Steinhardt said.
The Wall Street Journal reported details of Carnivore on Tuesday. The FBI
surveillance system, which the agency showed to members of the ISP industry
two weeks ago, works like a kind of Internet wiretap that tracks emails and
other electronic communications. Agents use it only after obtaining a court
order that allows them to intercept the communications of a criminal suspect.
The FBI would install the specialized computer on the networks of Internet
providers, where it "sniffs" out all mail and records sent to or from the
target of an investigation.
A spokeswoman at Canady's Washington office said the congressman could not
respond until he had reviewed the ACLU letter.
The 14-year-old Electronic Communications Privacy Act allows for real-time
interception of messages if there is a court order, similar to those used
for tapping a suspect's telephone line. Federal law also allows law
enforcement officials to obtain court orders for a "tap and trace." This
provision allows the FBI and other law enforcement agencies to obtain a
list of telephone numbers used by a suspect.
It is the transposition of these laws to the modern Net age that the ACLU
says leaves agencies like the FBI with too much leeway in its use of 21st
century digital technologies.
For example a tap-and-trace order might let the FBI demand, from a website,
the IP addresses of all Web users who accessed a particular page,
Steinhardt said. "Are they required to turn that over? That's far more than
who dialed what phone numbers."
Steinhardt said email searches must be more clearly restricted.
"We can't be in the position of making a leap of faith that law enforcement
will have access to all this information but only look at this very narrow
band of communications that they're entitled to," he said.
But an FBI spokesman said the notion that it would look at more emails than
the agency is entitled to under the law is a misunderstanding of the
system's purpose and operation.
"It limits the messages viewable by human eyes to those which are strictly
included in the court order," he said. "Unless Jill Smith's communications
are flagged, we don't see Sally's, Jane's, or anyone else's, we just see
Jill Smith's."
The concept that Carnivore searches through millions of emails per second
is misleading, the spokesman said on Tuesday. Reading from a prepared
statement, he said the system was "designed to be installed at the premises
of a typical ISP, which provides its customers with a dial up service to
the Internet." Because the volume of email flowing through such connections
is small and runs at slow speeds, the numbers are not in the millions of
emails per second, he said.
But the ACLU still isn't prepared to trust the FBI with access to such an
ongoing stream of email messages.
"We have too much history of law enforcement abuse to believe that when
they are well beyond anybody's scrutiny -- including in this case the
scrutiny of the ISPs -- that they will adhere to the letter, let alone to
the spirit, of the law," Steinhardt said.
Countering that point, the FBI spokesman said that even if the agency were
to overlook restrictions prohibiting such wide-scale review of email, the
task would be formidable.
"We haven't the time nor the inclination to randomly (search all messages
passing through the system)," the spokesman said. "'Hey, this looks
interesting,' 'Oh let's look at that,' 'Oh, look at that one' -- I mean,
come on -- give me a break."
In any case, he said, the FBI's use of the system is subject to intense
oversight by internal agency controls, the Department of Justice, and by
the court that issued the order. Penalties for misuse include the exclusion
of illegally obtained evidence in a trial, as well as criminal and civil
penalties.
But privacy advocates sided with the ACLU on Tuesday and believe that
Carnivore cannot be reliably operated under current law.
"Disclosures of this capability raise significant privacy issues, and call
into question the adequacy of existing federal wiretap laws," said David
Sobel, general counsel of the Electronic Privacy Information Center. "As
technology advances, the laws become more antiquated."
Sobel said it's imperative that Congress look at current law enforcement
investigative technologies and bring the applicable laws into compliance
with "current realities."
"None of the ISPs in WAISP has ever contacted me with questions about it,
and as long as the FBI showed up with a valid warrant, ISPs would comply,"
said Gary Gardener, executive director of the Washington Association of
Internet Service Providers (WAISP).
"It does raise disturbing questions about the info collected that is not
subject to the investigation at hand, but as long as the rules of evidence
are adhered to, and the court issues the proper warrant, (then) we'll have
to wait for Congress to resolve the issue."
The ACLU's Steinhardt doesn't expect immediate attention by Congress, but
does believe that Congress will eventually act.
"I do think over the long term that there's some reason to hope that the
Congress will in fact appreciate the need to amend existing law to cover
these new situations -- and that if we don't, we're going to allow the
technology to swallow up the Fourth Amendment and to render it
meaningless," he said.
-------------------
"We are not for names, nor men, nor titles of Government, nor are we for
this party nor against the other
but we are for justice and mercy and
truth and peace and true freedom, that these may be exalted in our nation,
and that goodness, righteousness, meekness, temperance, peace and unity
with God, and with one another, that these things may abound." (Edward
Burroughs, 1659 - from 'Quaker Faith and Practice')
THE FREE RANGE ACTIVISM NETWORK
Facilitators -
Paul Mobbs - mobbsey at gn.ac.org, tel./fax 01295 261864
Tim Shaw - timshaw at gn.apc.org, tel./fax 01558 685353
Website - http://www.gn.apc.org/pmhp/rangers/
--------------------
More information about the Ir-l
mailing list