[Ir-l] [IR-L]: TU concern on RIP "common purpose" clause

Chris Bailey chrisbailey at gn.apc.org
Sun Jul 9 02:58:14 BST 2000


This development follows from a recent meeting of organisations opposing 
the RIP Bill, where it was agreed to try to publicise the issue of the 
"common purpose" clause, particularly as it might affect trade unions (the 
clause originates from phonetapping the NUM in the miners strike). Sally 
Watson from silicon.com who wrote the article, was present at that meeting 
and discussed the issue with GreenNet at length the next day.

Simon Davies has done a good job getting these statements from the TUC and 
MSF, but, as he says in the article, there is little awareness amongst 
unions about the effects the bill could have on them. The "common purpose" 
clause is well hidden away near the end of the Bill. Those of us in unions 
should be raising this through their branches, sending resolutions to head 
offices, etc. Even if the Bill goes through shortly we should still keep 
building up all the pressure we can against its operation.

Chris Bailey

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Thursday 6th July 2000   0:30am

Trades Unions call for urgent Snooping Bill clarification

Two of the UK's trades unions are warning that the government's Regulation 
of Investigatory Powers (RIP) Bill is in urgent need of clarification.

The Trades Union Congress (TUC) and The Manufacturing Science and Finance 
union (MSF) both claim the legislation could leave their members' email 
communications vulnerable to unwarranted snooping.

Peter Skyte, head of the IT Professionals Association at the MSF, told 
silicon.com the Bill was ill-conceived. He said: "The Bill as currently 
drafted could enable the legitimate activities of trades union members and 
trades union representatives to be monitored. We don't see the need for that."

Sarah Veale, employment policy officer at the TUC, said the legislation 
could leave union members susceptible to undue suspicion. "It's going to be 
very difficult for us," Veale said. "The Bill has been rushed through - it 
needs a lot more thought."

The TUC represents over 70 unions in the UK, including UNISON, MSF and the 
Transport and General Workers Union. Veale said: "In a sense this is not 
new, unions have been spied on for a long time."

Veale added that if the Bill went through unchanged, unions would have to 
start being a lot more careful about their electronic communications. "The 
knock on affects could be huge," she said.

In particular, controversy surrounds one of the definitions of "serious 
crime" in Part V of the Bill, which refers to "conduct by a large number of 
persons in pursuit of a common purpose".

According to Michael Ryan, head of the telecommunications practice at law 
firm Arnold & Porter, it's a definition that has not been seriously 
addressed by the government. "The concept that the actions of a large 
number of people could trigger an investigation is unique to this Bill," he 
said.

"There is still a serious problem here that hasn't been addressed. It puts 
unique powers in the hands of persons well below the ministerial level," 
Ryan added.

According to Simon Davies, director of campaign group Privacy 
International, many UK unions believe the government's recent amendments 
have solved the Bill's problem. "The perception is that the fight has been 
won," he said. "But it's not over. There is the potential to reform this 
Bill, but it needs a bigger effort of cross-community response."

Skyte hopes the controversy surrounding the Bill will have a knock-on 
affect for employees who face surveillance in the workplace. "We welcome 
the fact that employers are now complaining about the ability of government 
agencies to monitor their activities - but we hope that those same 
employers will think again about monitoring the internet and email activity 
of their own employees," he said.

The government is due to release an amended draft of the Bill today, which 
will go into report stage in the House of Lords next week.

The Home Office was unavailable for comment.


For related news, see:
'Lords drop Snooping Bill's burden of proof'' www.silicon.com/a38354
'Snooping Bill goes back under the Lords' microscope' www.silicon.com/a38324
'Anti-RIP lobby wins changes to Snooping Bill' www.silicon.com/a38292
'Government muses ISP tax relief for 'Snooping Bill'' www.silicon.com/a38259


Sally Watson / Feedback

REGISTER FREE and you can personalise your news 





More information about the Ir-l mailing list