[Ir-l] [IR-L]: ISP flees UK to evade e-mail snoops
Chris Bailey
chrisbailey at gn.apc.org
Mon Jul 10 15:22:57 BST 2000
> From Sunday Telegraph
>ISP flees UK to evade e-mail snoops
>By Mary Fagan
>
>POPTEL, the internet company used by Chris Smith, the culture, media and
>sport secretary, and by the Trades Union Congress, is threatening to move
>overseas if the Government presses ahead with controversial legislation to
>allow the security services to snoop on e-mails and other internet data.
>
>The company, which is also the internet service provider for local
>government and charities, believes the Regulation of Investigatory Powers
>Bill, now going through Parliament, may breach the European Convention on
>Human Rights.
>
>Shaun Fensom, founder and chairman of the non profit-making ISP, said: "We
>are concerned that under the proposed regulatory regime we will not be
>able to guarantee the integrity of communications for our clients,
>particularly the trade unions, non-governmental organisations and others
>who may legitimately come into conflict with the Government. Industry,
>civil liberties groups, trade unions and many others believe that this
>Bill is fatally flawed." If the Bill is not withdrawn and rethought, he
>added: "We will have no alternative but to actively look at moving at
>least some of our services overseas."
>
>The Government has already been forced to amend the proposed legislation
>after fierce objections in the House of Lords and opposition from civil
>liberties groups. The Bill has also caused uproar among internet
>companies, some of which claim that it will cost the industry hundreds of
>millions of pounds to install the electronic "black boxes" which allow
>e-mails to be spied on.
>
>A spokeswoman for the TUC said: "It would be quite easy for unions to hook
>up with an internet provider which can guarantee e-mail won't be
>intercepted." The Transport and General Workers Union said that if the
>TUC sourced its internet services outside the UK, it would follow. A
>spokesman said: "We would certainly want to be assured that in legitimate
>industrial disputes this would not infringe on the civil liberties of
>members of the union."
>
>Opponents of the Bill are concerned both about the interception of e-mails
>in principle and the proposal, now watered down, that forces companies to
>give police and customs officers the encryption keys for unscrambling
>encoded internet information unless they can prove they are unable to do
>so.
>
>Last week Esther Dyson, who heads the powerful Internet Corporation for
>Assigned Names and Numbers and advises President Clinton, likened the
>proposed legislation to a law forcing people to "keep their curtains up"
>so the police can look in.
>
>The Home Office said it is disappointed at Poptel's stance. A spokesman
>said:"The powers of interception are only directed at those suspected of
>involvement in a threat to national security, a threat to the economic
>well-being of the nation or involvement in serious organised crime."
More information about the Ir-l
mailing list