[Ir-l] [IR-L]: ZDNetUK Article
Liz Probert
liz at gn.apc.org
Tue Jul 11 18:00:53 BST 2000
RIP: Government claims no mass
surveillance
Mon, 10 Jul 2000 16:04:20 GMT
Jane Wakefield
Poptel makes a stand against the invasion of email
confidentiality it believes the RIP Bill represents by stating
its intention to relocate abroad if the bill becomes law
The government moves to reassure ISPs that mass surveillance is
not on the RIP agenda as the bill suffers another setback this week.
It follows news that ISP Poptel intends to move abroad if the
government's snooping bill becomes law, claiming that it would not
be able to guarantee its clients -- which includes the TUC and trade
unions -- email confidentiality.
The government claims to be "disappointed" by the news. "We have
gone to great lengths to be inclusive and consult industry about the
bill," says a Home Office spokesman. "The powers within RIP are
directed at three specific areas: threat to national security, threat to
economic well being and serious and organised crime."
The definition of serious crime includes the phrase "those gathered
for a common purpose" which some civil liberties experts claim
would include anyone organising a demonstration or
anti-government protest. "That is not the case," reassures the Home
Office spokesman. "It means those gathered for a common purpose
to commit a serious crime and we are talking serious and
organised."
Poptel is the first service provider to take direct action against RIP.
"If the bill goes through we will be forced to consider moving
abroad," says Shaun Fensom, chair of Poptel. "We don't want to do
that but we owe it to our clients to have secure, confident
communications."
Despite government reassurances, civil liberty campaigners are still
concerned that organisations in dispute with the government could
be targeted under the government's definition of legitimate
surveillance.
"Anyone organising a demo is open to having their email read,"
asserts Chris Bailey, spokesman for the Association of Progressive
Communications. "It is particularly worrying for international
organisations who could have details passed over to regimes without
democratic rights for individuals."
One of the ISPs owned by APC, GreenNet, is also considering
moving abroad if RIP becomes law. Yaman Akdeniz, head of
Cyber Rights & Cyber Liberties thinks many more could follow.
"ISPs like AOL and CompuServe that are majority owned by a US
company could move and that would be very troubling," he says.
While Akdeniz sympathises with Poptel's plight, he is concerned that
it might make little difference. "I wonder how sensible it is. If it is
still going to be offering services to the UK the government can still
require them to install a black box," he says. "The real fight is in
Parliament, to get the bill right or throw it out."
More information about the Ir-l
mailing list