[Ir-l] [IR-L]: FLASH Release: Crunch RIP amendment to limit GAK defeated by one vote
Caspar Bowden
cb at fipr.org
Thu Jul 13 22:18:32 BST 2000
FIPR News Release - FOR IMMEDIATE USE 13/7/2000
===============================================
Second and final day of the House of Lords Report Stage debate
on the Regulation of Investigatory Powers Bill:
A joint Conservative and Liberal Democrat amendment to limit
Government-Access-to-Key powers in the RIP Bill was defeated in the House
of Lords on Thursday by 119 votes to 120. The amendment would have required
Secretary of State authorisation on each occasion a key (rather than
plaintext) was demanded, thus effectively checking the volume of access
requests.
Opposition amendments REJECTED:
===============================
*) the requirement to provide a person served with a decryption notice, with
the material he is supposed to decrypt (so that he may supply plaintext
instead of a key)
*) a procedure allowing a person served with a decryption notice to
demonstrate the correspondence between plaintext and ciphertext to a trusted
third party - thus obviating the need to surrender a key (if a session key
in unavailable)
*) Curbs on the "tipping-off" offence - which can impose a lifetime
prohibition on revealing the existence of a decryption notice, with a
penalty of five years imprisonment
*) clarification that the "economic well-being" clauses can only apply to
persons outside the United Kingdom. The government implicitly conceded that
they might apply to persons inside the United Kingdom in unspecified
circumstances.
*) explicit protections for legally privileged material
*) deletion of the "large number of persons in pursuit of a common purpose"
limb of the definition of the "serious crime" purpose for interception.
Government concessions:
=======================
*) The prosecution must now show that a person "knowingly" failed to comply
with a decryption notice (the "mens rea" test)
*) Notices demanding keys must be notified within seven days to the
Interception Commissioner
*) Seized keys to material obtained by means other than interception will
now get the same level of protection (classification 'SECRET') - the
government stated this was an "omission" from the draft Code of Practice
*) a loophole will be closed in the Tribunal procedure which would have
prevented an Appeal against breaches of the Human Rights Act except in
cases where key seizure *was* authorised by the Secretary of State
*) the authority serving a decryption notice must "take into account" the
extent and nature of *other* information protected by a key, before
demanding access to that key
*) Notices demanding keys (rather than plaintext) from the police, Customs &
Excise, or the armed forces, must now be authorised at the ranks of Chief
Constable, Commissioner, and brigadier respectively
- - - - - -
The Bill now goes to its Third Reading in the Lords on Wednesday. If
government chooses not to attempt to reverse Wednesday's defeat on
establishing a statutory Technical Approvals Board (which would vet
interception requirements imposed on ISPs), then the Bill only needs to
return to the Commons for approval and then Royal Assent to become law.
Caspar Bowden, director of Internet policy think-tanks FIPR commented:
"An unprecedented wave of public opprobrium has won significant concessions.
However if the UK becomes the only G7 economy with a GAK law, companies and
their customers will think long and hard before conducting secure e-commerce
in this country. There is still time to pause and reflect before enacting
legislation that may have irreversible consequences"
Notes for editors
-----------------
1. FIPR is an independent non-profit organisation that studies the
interaction between information technology and society, with special
reference to the Internet; we do not (directly or indirectly) represent the
interests of any trade-group. Our goal is to identify technical developments
with significant social impact, commission research into public policy
alternatives, and promote public understanding and dialogue between
technologists and policy-makers in the UK and Europe. The Board of Trustees
and Advisory Council (http://www.fipr.org/trac.html) comprise some of the
leading experts in the UK.
--
Caspar Bowden Tel: +44(0)20 7354 2333
Director, Foundation for Information Policy Research
RIP Information Centre at: www.fipr.org/rip#media
More information about the Ir-l
mailing list