[Ir-l] [IR-L]: Guardian editorial

Chris Bailey chrisbailey at gn.apc.org
Tue Jun 13 00:31:48 BST 2000


Kick this legislation out
It should be RIP for the Big Brother bill

Monday June 12, 2000
The Guardian

Tony Blair was given a mild drubbing by the Women's Institute last week. 
But that is nothing to what ought to happen this week as the RIP 
(regulation of investigatory powers) bill enters its committee stage in the 
Lords. People and industry are only just waking up to the enormity of what 
is proposed and their lordships would do us all a favour if they used their 
delaying powers to throw this disgraceful bill back to the Commons for a 
complete rewrite. The bill has only got as far as it has because no one 
believes that it means what it says. It does. If it becomes law every 
internet service provider will have to install a black box with a direct 
link to an MI5 building. That means they can monitor the patterns of all 
our emails (including who sent them), our visits to chat rooms and every 
website we click into. All that can be done continuously without a warrant. 
On production of a warrant, the authorities can force us to surrender any 
keys, simple or complicated, used to encrypt our emails, so they can read 
them.

Refusal could mean a prison sentence of two years . Drug smugglers and 
paedophiles will gladly settle for that rather than a much stiffer penalty 
for being found guilty. If ordinary citizens claim they have forgotten 
their password they will be presumed guilty by the courts unless they can 
prove their innocence.

It gets worse. If the authorities demand to see an encryption key so they 
can read your or your company's internet transactions and you tell your 
boss (or your spouse) then you are liable for imprisonment of five years 
for a criminal offence. The government says: "Trust us. We have to have 
these powers but we won't use them in a draconian way." The trouble is, no 
one trusts government any more. Safeguards for the citizen must be built 
into the legislation. In yesterday's Observer Tim Berners-Lee, the British 
inventor of the world wide web, warned that the bill gave government great 
power to abuse personal and commercial innovation. He said it would have 
been thrown out "in a second" in the US. This follows complaints by the 
Institute of Directors which is worried about the commercial data 
governments could collect without a warrant. This draconian bill will 
create a big double whammy. Civil liberties will be abused and industry 
will invest in friendlier places like Ireland instead. Is this the 
government that pledged to make the UK the best place in the world to do 
ecommerce?


© Copyright Guardian Media Group plc. 2000 






More information about the Ir-l mailing list