[Ir-l] [IR-L]: Re: RIP and the Human Rights Act
John Valentine
jv_sw17 at yahoo.co.uk
Wed May 3 17:44:20 BST 2000
Of course it is possible to be totally cynical about the HRA, as Charles
Young is. It has taken the UK governments half a century to incorporate this
legislation, so it is fair to assume that they haven't done so willingly.
But it is (or will be, in October) important because the rights are stated
in words for the first time ever, and so provide a reference point for
argument which was never possible when rights were assumed.
Certainly the HRA will change court practice. Training documents for judges
and magistrates say that they "will be required to interpret existing
legislation in a way that is compatible with the Convention rights." They
may "read in extra words, or even ignore words, if to do so would make the
legislation compatible with the Convention."
I think it will provide a springboard for challenge to a whole range of
repressive legislation, and has the potential to support appeals till the
cows come home.
But perhaps the question we have to answer is - should eavesdropping on
emails be allowable under any circumstances? Or is privacy always paramount?
Should the police be able to eavesdrop on a (alleged) paedophile ring? or on
class A wholesalers? Or not?
John Valentine
__________________________________________________
Do You Yahoo!?
Talk to your friends online with Yahoo! Messenger.
http://im.yahoo.com
More information about the Ir-l
mailing list