[Ir-l] [IR-L]: Re: RIP and the Human Rights Act

CYoung1097 at aol.com CYoung1097 at aol.com
Thu May 4 09:53:05 BST 2000


In a message dated 03/05/00 23:23:03 GMT Daylight Time, jv_sw17 at yahoo.co.uk 
writes:

> Of course it is possible to be totally cynical about the HRA, as Charles
>  Young is. It has taken the UK governments half a century to incorporate 
this
>  legislation, so it is fair to assume that they haven't done so willingly.
>  But it is (or will be, in October) important because the rights are stated
>  in words for the first time ever, and so provide a reference point for
>  argument which was never possible when rights were assumed.
>  

No-one is more pleased than I am that at long bitter last the establishment 
here has been forced to give in to this principle.  I am sceptical because I 
don't believe for one minute that they mean it,  and because of the vast 
array of exceptions and loopholes they have allowed themselves.  Basically,  
they have incorporated as many schemes and scams as renders the HRA as 
unrestrictive on THEIR activities as they could get away with, and then some. 
 We shall see in due course what the courts think of that.   Would that Lord 
Denning was still with us.



>  But perhaps the question we have to answer is - should eavesdropping on
>  emails be allowable under any circumstances? Or is privacy always 
paramount?
>  Should the police be able to eavesdrop on a (alleged) paedophile ring? or 
on
>  class A wholesalers? Or not?

These are mere excuses used to allow them the right to eavesdrop.  
The establishment doesn't give a damn if a few plebs or peasants take drugs, 
molest children or shoot at each other.  The only people affected by such 
activities are other plebs or peasants,  and there are millions of those.  
The losses are insignificant,  and it poses no threat to the security of the 
establishment.  What they want is permanent self-security,  and that is all 
they are interested in.  Armed with a totally compliant police service, and 
an array of "security services" that would do Stalin proud,  they are 
winning,  meantime. They have wrapped Jack(boot) Straw around their little 
fingers,  and hence the RIP bill is well on the way to becoming the law of 
the land.

Many other countries will follow Britain's lead in these matters.
Free country?  Free Speech?  
>  

Charles Young
Scotland  UK

CYoung1097 at aol.com





More information about the Ir-l mailing list