[Ir-l] [IR-L]: Re: Sticks and stones ......
Mclean, Don
Don.Mclean at southernwater.co.uk
Mon May 8 10:59:43 BST 2000
CYoung1097 at aol.com said:
"Let's look at the history of it - perhaps someone can name a protest that
actually achieved something significant against the will of the sitting
establishment."
After mass demonstrations the "Poll Tax" was changed. I accept that this
probably wasn't all that significant in the scheme of things - but was at
least a minor victory at the time, and showed that "ordinary" people could
get involved in "politics".
Other observations: previous opposition to the Poll Tax, as it was being
introduced to Scotland but before it was introduced in England, got very
little reponse; after bills came through people's doors that all changed. An
easy way to mobilise a lot of people is therefore to hit them directly in
the pocket - as the Government did then. This contrasts with the nil
response to the increase in VAT made to pay for the Poll Tax / Council Tax
transition - not reduced AFTER the Council Tax was introduced. Perhaps this
is because VAT isn't a single bill / something that people can identify
against easily, people are too busy / "disempowered", perhaps most people
only really care about what they get paid??
So as we all know, its difficult to organise mass protest at "diffuse"
threats. Even harder when, like this bill, some people think that these
powers should exist all the time, some people that they should be available
some of the time.
Enter John Valentine's question (04 May 2000 23:01) "Is all interception
always bad? Or is some interception sometimes permissible? Because the
answer defines the campaign."
To get that debate going, I'd go for "some interception is sometimes
permissible" - which isn't what hard-wiring public servers to MI5 would do.
At least if Court Order had to be obtained, as for "legal" bugging now. Yes,
I know that this is also abused, but it might allow a semblance of slightly
more public scrutiny than simply giving MI5 access to the lot with no
questions asked. Don
More information about the Ir-l
mailing list