[Ir-l] [IR-L]: Re: Sticks and stones ......

CYoung1097 at aol.com CYoung1097 at aol.com
Tue May 9 00:26:59 BST 2000


In a message dated 08/05/00 11:16:53 GMT Daylight Time, 
Don.Mclean at southernwater.co.uk writes:

> I know that this is also abused, but it might allow a semblance of slightly
>  more public scrutiny than simply giving MI5 access to the lot with no
>  questions asked. Don


There is not, and never has been, any need for warrants under the 1985 act to 
intercept emails.  This is because the act refers to the interception of 
communications "whilst in the course of their transmission" .......  Now 
then,  with emails,  the moment you have cleared your "mailbox"  your emails 
are no longer "in the course of their tranmission",  and they can raid them 
freely.  They do. 

How may of you have a copy of the 1895 Act?
Want to read this .............. ?

Subj:   Re: CS: Misc-phone taps
Date:   18-07-1997
To: 73612.2132 at compuserve.com
In a message dated 18-07-1997  00:28:00, you write:
> And if this is done as a matter of routine, what other taps and bugs can be 
placed as nearly routine?
>  Xxxxxxx Xxxxxx
>  I find this hard to believe given the sheer volume of calls.  Under  what 
law is this authorised?
ANSWER:
Under the Interception of Communications Act 1985, that's what.   GCHQ have 
the automatic means to scan spoken and written messages at high speed looking 
and listening for seditious words such as pistol, rifle, Semtex, Queen,  
Prince Charles,  Camilla, bonking (as in the wife of the sovereign's heir), 
IRA, dynamite, ammonium nitrate, diesel, bullets,  and the like.  Now then, 
under the Telegraph Act of 1984,  it is a statutory offence to use the public 
phone system for any unlawful purpose. Same applies to snail-mail post.   The 
1985 Act craftily re-wrote the entire section 45 of the 1984 Telegraph Act, 
which then permitted the following to take place.

The phone company and the police have a duty to DETECT and prevent crime.  It 
is a crime to use the phone system for a criminal purpose.  So,  the phone 
company people can listen to any and all calls whenever they like, without a 
warrant, to ensure the crime of using the phone system for an illegal purpose 
isn't  taking place.  But, the snag is they might hear of the nature of the 
illegal purpose concerned, but divulging overheard matter is an offence.  Oh 
Dear, what shall we do?  

Intercepting calls is an offence against s.-1 of the 1985 Act  except (a) 
unless there's a warrant, (b) the intercepted party agreed to it (read your 
conditions for phone service)  or (c)  S.-3(a)  the communication is 
intercepted for purposes connected with the provision of postal or public 
communication services or with THE ENFORCEMENT OF ANY ENACTMENT relating to 
the use of those services.

This means that B-Telecom can tap your calls whenever they want to ensure you 
ain't using their wires for bad purposes. But they would be committing an 
offence if they TOLD ANYONE ELSE what they had overheard, so here comes the 
clever bit.  The very last part of the 1985 Act is schedule 2, headed SECTION 
SUBSTITUTED FOR SECTION 45 OF 1984 ACT.

One has to admire the person who drafted this gem.    The new s.45 of the 
1984 Telegraph act says 
" 45.-(1) A  person engaged in the running of a public telecommunication  
system who OTHERWISE THAN IN THE COURSE OF HIS DUTY   INTENTIONALLY discloses 
to any person
(a) the contents of any message ....blah blah:  or
(b) any information concerning the use made of the tele. services blah blah
shall be guilty of an offence.

I suggest you read that lot again, and carefully this time.  Don't look at 
what it treats as offensive, but consider what it permits.   Now read ss.(2) 
45.-(2) Subsection (1) above does NOT apply to -
(a) any disclosure which is made for the prevention or detection of crime or 
for the purposes of any criminal proceedings;

Gettit?  They can listen to the lot WITHOUT A WARRANT TO INTERCEPT by way of 
making sure no-one is using the phones  for any illegal purpose,  and then 
they can tell the system whatever they heard so long as they can claim the 
disclosure was made for the prevention or detection of crime.   ANYTHING to 
do with guns or shooting is potentially criminal,  and that is why all 
dealers' phones are tapped as  matter of routine.  And their emails

There were several more paragraphs but I will spare you those. 

Wow,  it's a great feeling to be living in a free country, the home of mother 
of parliaments, telling third world regimes how to behave.  It's little 
wonder those despots come to us for advice.  We know better than anyone how 
to suppress our plebs.  We've been doing it for centuries. 

CFY


Charles Young
Scotland  UK

CYoung1097 at aol.com





More information about the Ir-l mailing list