[Ir-l] [IR-L]: moderated list: why +reasons

Barry barryf at softexport.com
Tue May 9 10:39:09 BST 2000


1. well meaning time wasters
2. NSA/CIA/MI5/Special Branch
3. over argumentative nit picking fools/opinionated fascists

ban them all off your lists because the net (parden the pun :-) result is
the same
ie: we don't get to use the list for what we want.
One wonders who sets up an unmoderated e-mail list about controversial
political and economic issues.
If I was the cops, it's what I'd do.
I am enjoying the real info on this list and don't want to unsubscribe.
It is not censorship for the moderator to delist or ban any of the above 3
categories.
So please do it or lets all switch to a new moderated list with the same
purpose as this one.
I have watched this this pattern of frustraion on loads of pro people +
planet + art + life /anti-globa lsuicide and corp power lists over and over
again.

Barry

-----Original Message-----
From: ir-l at gn.apc.org [mailto:ir-l at gn.apc.org]On Behalf Of Tony Gosling
Sent: Tuesday, May 09, 2000 2:39 AM
To: Multiple recipients of list
Subject: [IR-L]: face-to-face etc.


Very frustrating,

I have been writing to this anti-Miners/Thatcherite 'charles' direct (off
the list) and he's been replying via the list.  One can't do this by
accident, he's clearly stirring - with no respect for the purpose of the
list. I can hardly wait for his reply to this ;-)

I think it makes sense to ban anyone who persistantly posts off subject or
disinformation - I'm afraid open forum means MI5/CIA/NSA will be in there -
it's a crucial subject for the future & they know that. We can expect dirty
tricksters & political spoilers who I don't want to have to put up with,
please consider cutting out some of the noise.  I'd be interested to see
what other people think because a PC approach here could backfire by
driving already busy people off the list.

To make it easy to operate the list, & again cut the clutter, a brief
automatic bit at the bottom of each posting explaining how to subscribe,
unsubscribe and where the archive is would be v. useful if feasible.

Also ---

There are some v. switched on people on this list.  Might I suggest we
arrange a date to meet up in a month or two in London.  It would be an
attempt to break through that 'oh not another bloody email' syndrome and
bring more of a sense of reality to the list???  Even if only a few turn up
it would be useful to the cause.

The 'Golden Cafe' Internet cafe on Golden Square nr. Carnaby St. has a
sorted proprietor Sabine McNeill. Or our Patricia Hewitt/ISP friend might
book a room in the Palace of Westminster, or hey, Greennet might want to
host it?

So thoughts on banning.... and meeting face-to-face please.


Tony
www.bilderberg.org
www.videonetwork.org


At 21:02 8/5/00 +0100, you wrote:
>There's also quite a lot of 'noise' on the list. And by 'noise' i mean
>exchanges between a small number of subscribers on the list, in a style
>and tone that is both disrespectful of the 60 odd other people who are on
>the list and inappropriate in this space which is not a free-form
>debating arena -
>
>I also don't wish to un-subscribe anyone from this list - i have read
>through all of the posts of the last week - and in between the diatribes
>lie some good thinking and anlaysis.
>






More information about the Ir-l mailing list