[Ir-l] [IR-L]: Re: RIP and the Human Rights Act

Chris Bailey chrisbailey at gn.apc.org
Sun May 14 16:42:36 BST 2000


At 10:20 05/05/2000 +0100, Robin Gaskell wrote:
>*   So, just what is going on in Britain:-
>    . There's the RIP Bill,
>    . You are bringing in A Human Right Act, and
>    . MI5 is building a multi-million, Internet-listening computer, to which
>all ISPs must be hard-wired.
>
>     I suspect that something really big is brewing.
>     Is it possible that all three events are inter-related in some larger
>agenda?
>
>Saluta,
>   Robin Gaskell

Hi Robin,

This is a good question that requires some thinking about. I would like to 
take a guess about what is involved here.

I don't think the Human Rights Act is so relevant except that its 
incorporation into British law in October probably explains some of the 
governments haste over the RIP Bill.

The "really big" thing involved in the present developments in Britain 
seems to me to be the coming together of ECHELON (MI5 and GCHQ) and the 
international police plans for surveillance of digital communication, 
developed since 1993 via the ILETS group and, within the European Union, 
through the Council for Justice and Home Affairs (CJHA), a body that is not 
democratically accountable within EU structures.

Duncan Campbell, the expert on ECHELON, warned GreenNet about a year ago 
that the police gaining access to ECHELON would mark a major turning point, 
and opposition to this should be in the forefront of our campaigning plans.

ECHELON has enormous surveillance capabilities, but is also very costly. 
Since the end of the cold war it has been trying to justify its existence. 
One way it has done this is by turning much of its activity to business 
spying on behalf of the countries involved in it. This is causing 
considerable friction within the EU at the moment as it gives unfair 
advantage to Britain and breaches the Single Market rules.

Another major way ECHELON could justify its existence would be for it to be 
used in law enforcement. This would be illegal under US law since the 
National Security Agency (NSA) (which operates ECHELON) is constitutionally 
barred from spying on US citizens.However, as people on this list have 
pointed out, there are no such constitutional safeguards in Britain.

A few weeks ago in Britain a murderer was convicted and sent to jail. One 
of the Sunday papers revealed that he had been traced and arrested in Spain 
though MI5/police co-operation. ECHELON had been used to keep track of his 
wife's phone calls and pinpoint where he was when she phoned him. This is 
the first case I know of in which ECHELON has been used for police purposes.

This fits with the Sunday Times report about "hard-wiring" ISPs into an MI5 
operated centre and also with Charles Clarke's statement last week that 
only some ISPs would be wired in this way. ECHELON has the capability to 
reconstruct individual emails from packets. The NSA operation works by 
tapping into just nine major internet exchange points. In Britain the same 
interception capabilities could probably be obtained by tapping into LINX, 
the main internet exchange point, and a few other places.

I want to discuss this with Duncan Campbell, but if I am guessing right 
here it puts a new significance to some parts of the RIP Bill that we 
hadn't taken too much notice of. These legalise various GCHQ operations. If 
we consider these together with the open ended provisions in the Bill for 
providing information to law enforcement bodies around the world this could 
mean ECHELON being used via Britain to provide information to police forces 
around the world, including some in extremely undemocratic countries.

This seems to me to have tremendous international implications. I would 
like to hold back from drafting the international statement on the RIP Bill 
that Karen (and Tomoya Inyaku, in Japan) has suggested we make until I have 
consulted Duncan Campbell.

Chris Bailey









More information about the Ir-l mailing list