[Ir-l] [IR-L]: jamming echelon------not such a good idea?

spyder spyder at toxicpop.freeserve.co.uk
Tue May 16 09:49:27 BST 2000


this from the mayday list, seems logical to me, what do others think?
is there any kind of randomiser to be used to avoid this happening?

<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<snip>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>

I get tired of explaining this to people, and sorry if you've heard it 
before, but for the benefit of those who are still making the mistake.... 

Trying to "jam the airwaves" with keywords for which echelon is scanning 
is a BIG mistake. For one thing -- its like trying to jam Yahoo by asking 
it to do searches for you... but worse than that.

The monitoring system works not by drawing the attention of a security 
service employee to the specific document containing the keyword, but by 
compiling a statistical map of where the said keywords repeatedly occur. 
By studying such frequency maps, and changes in it over time, and by 
trawling for certain combinations of keywords (much on the same 
principles as many Internet search engines) the agencies are able to 
detect the general flow of attention to certain subjects on a demographic 
basis. Properly analyzed on this basis, such statistics can tell 'Them' a 
lot more than you might imagine -- a lot of it of political rather than 
policing usefulness. 

This is not to say that they do not have the theoretical capacity to zoom 
in upon a specific email message and have a real live person actually 
read it, but this is very much an exception rather than the rule. How do 
I know this? Think about it for just one moment -- how many personnel 
would they have to employ to read every email, fax. phonecall containing 
a keyword if they read them purely as a random response to a certain 
string of letters or noises? A computer can filter an electronic signal 
but it cannot *understand* it, it cannot place you under arrest..... It 
can however easily (in particular - QUICKLY) match recurring strings, or 
ignore combinations of words which make no sense. THESE are the things 
which it is easy to program a computer to do....

Secondly. The deliberate transmission of keywords is actually 
COUNTER-PRODUCTIVE. Use that brain cell once more -- The agency wants to 
know the general virtual-location of radicals : Only radicals will make a 
habit of retransmitting such keywords in order to launch a 
"counter-attack on the agency", therefore these messages do exactly what 
the agency wants them to do -- track radicals... DOH! In fact -- if I had 
spent good money -- albeit taxpayers -- on developing such a system, I 
would help it along by circulating emails to radical groups suggesting 
they retransmit keywords to their friends and other electronic meeting 
places.... DOH 2.

Because such deliberate artificial and unnatural assemblages of keywords 
are PARTICULARLY easy to pull out of the statistical data, they can 
monitor their incidence on a statistical GEOGRAPHIC basis... ie the 
spread of such documents reveals to them *WHO ASSOCIATES WITH WHO*. This 
is the cream on the pint so far as the system is concerned -- being able 
to create maps of human relationships is just gold-dust when some 
real-world event sets them hunting for a specific individual..... Such 
supposed acts of self defence actually turn the needle in the haystack 
into "needle" in a search engine.... 

Moral -- if you act like a fucking machine you will lose to the machine 
every time...

You might care to bear that thought in mind next time you receive an 
email from some campaign or other (or ostensibly from some campaign or 
other?) asking you to "Forward this email to your MP or Congressman or 
Monsanto....." Such email chains are an absolute GIFT to the monitoring 
agencies...... (and you have to wonder...... but no they wouldnt surely?)

Thirdly, (and here's the irony of it all). Any radical considering 
blowing up Parliament or whatever is hardly dumb enough to discuss the 
manufacturing of the explosives over the Net. No one on this list or N30 
or J18 discussion lists was obliged to submit any evidence of their 
academic qualifications but no one was dumb enough to make plans to hit 
any particular institution or even to meet in some particular place over 
the List which any Tom Dick or James Bond might have been monitoring, 
(which of course they wouldn't need half a dozen satellites to have 
achieved since they could just SIGN ON the discussion list...). So is it 
likely that this is the technology they would use to target that kind of 
activity? The only anarchists they could identify by that method would be 
ones who are so devoid of gray matter that they would not be worth 
identifying in the first place.....

Which of course suggests a final characteristically miserable 
reflection.... What hope is there for any kind of political activity, 
what purpose is there for any kind of electronic or other association 
between radicals, if the general level of comprehension of how the world 
arounds them works is so poor? We're all computer users here....do we 
really understand so little about how they work? We are all anti State 
here, do we really study so little about the tactics and strategies of 
social control? We are all paranoid about political repression  here... 
does anyone comprehend the basic methodologies of mass manipulation? 

If we aren't prepared to think like soldiers, as if there were a war on 
an we are IN it, how do you suggest we are ever going to get a shot at 
winning it?

If the technical understanding of how the computerized world in which 
this List exists is so poor, what is the point of it? Its only effect is 
to send a big "I AM HERE" message to the wrong people.... Its a liability 
for anyone who means it for real....


kubhlai 

<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<snip>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>

xxspyder

----------------------------------------------
  (((( ` ` ` ` ` ` ` ` ` ` ` ` ` ` ` ` ` ` ` ` ` ` ` ` `
 o 0 O 
  (((( , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , ,
when spiders unite, they can tie down a lion. 
----------------------------------------------







More information about the Ir-l mailing list