[Ir-l] [IR-L]: Re: please explain non secret UK voting

Chris Bailey chrisbailey at gn.apc.org
Thu May 18 15:08:33 BST 2000


At 11:42 18/05/2000 +0100, Charles Young wrote:

>After the election,  the ballot papers are sorted out BY THE CANDIDATE.
>
>So,  it is easy to get the papers for the "Keep Britain Tidy Party"
>candidate,  and check the numbers on the reverse of each paper against the
>counterfoils.
>
>It is really slick when three people work together.
>#1  reads out the number on the back of the ballot paper.
>#2  looks up that numbered counterfoil, and calls out the Elector's ID number.
>#3  refers that number to the Electoral Roll, and calls out the voter's name
>and address,  probably marking a spare copy of the Electoral Roll.

Do you have any evidence of this ever happening, Charles? If not, I would 
suggest you stop making allegations you have no evidence for. I think you 
are way off topic again and that making unfounded claims like this simply 
discredits building serious opposition to the RIP Bill. If we are going to 
win support then accuracy of information is vital.

I frequently work as a Presiding Officer in elections. There are a series 
of strict rules which separate counterfoils from ballot papers. Although it 
is theoretically possible to trace who someone voted for this can only be 
done through a court order after clear evidence of fraud in an election has 
been presented.

If you have any evidence that such tracing of votes has taken place without 
a court order I suggest you produce it. It would certainly be a very 
serious matter indeed that would need to be taken up at the highest level. 
If you don't have any evidence then I suggest you stop keep raising this 
issue on this list, which you have done several times now.

Although we are still classified as "subjects" in Britain we have, through 
a long and often bitter fight, established some democratic rights. We need 
to use them and to defend them. You seem to be continually claiming that we 
have no rights to either use or defend. Why bother opposing the RIP Bill 
then? It is precisely in so far as we can show to people, who are not just 
sheep as you seem to think, that the RIP Bill represents a major attack on 
their democratic rights that we will be able to build an effective campaign 
against it.

>No.  Ken Bruce on Radio Two makes mention of it when he can, but otherwise we
>are all SO subject we just accept it, except me.  I get my ballot papers, ask
>if it's a secret ballot,  they say yes (they don't know it isn't) I say I
>don't think so,  I show them why it's not, and I leave the polling station
>with the paper(s) so that the offence of "personation" cannot take place by
>some bugger voting on my otherwise blank paper.

All Presiding Officers are thoroughly grounded in explaining this and 
certainly wouldn't need an explanation from you. We are, in fact, issued 
with a standard letter to show voters that explains the conditions under 
which a vote might be traced. I always get a couple of people who make me a 
lot of work by doing exactly the same as you. Seems pretty futile to me. 
Perhaps if you all got together and put up candidates pledged to remove the 
election procedure you are complaining about you might actually change 
something.

Chris Bailey








More information about the Ir-l mailing list