[Ir-l] Fwd: *ICN - Judges Furious Over Being Monitored

Paul Mobbs mobbsey at gn.apc.org
Sat Aug 11 20:09:19 BST 2001


Subject: *ICN - Judges Furious Over Being Monitored
Date: Thu, 09 Aug 2001 08:37:10 -0400
From: internetcrimenews <internetcrimenews at infowar.com>
http://www.zdnet.com/zdnn/stories/news/0,4586,2803076,00.html?chkpt=zdnnp1tp02


Judges furious over being monitored

By Ted Bridis and Glenn R. Simpson

The Wall Street Journal Online
August 9, 2001 5:28 AM PT


WASHINGTON -- Privacy advocates hope a simmering dispute within the federal 
judiciary over Internet use will spark changes to federal laws on employer 
monitoring of company networks. A group of senior West Coast judges, angry 
that their online activity is monitored by a federal agency here that 
administers the court system, have suggested the scrutiny may be illegal and 
for one week earlier this year disabled the monitoring system in protest.

Judge Alex Kozinski of San Francisco's U.S. Court of Appeals for the Ninth 
Circuit -- where the disabling took place -- has claimed in a memorandum that 
such oversight violates the federal wiretap statute.

But experts in workplace law say the legality of such monitoring is widely 
accepted. Broad surveillance by system administrators is explicitly permitted 
under the 1986 Electronic Communications Privacy Act and has been upheld by 
several courts, and Congress has rejected attempts to craft a new policy.

"This sounds like the judge had no clue how intrusive modern monitoring 
security is," said Stewart Baker of the Washington law firm Steptoe & 
Johnson, an expert on wiretap law.

Calls to Judge Kozinski and the Ninth Circuit's media representative weren't 
returned.


Pushing the lawmakers

The dispute could spur lawmakers to re-evaluate federal policy on monitoring, 
privacy advocates said.

"We may need to have people in a position of power affected by electronic 
monitoring before there is going to be an honest legislative evaluation of 
the current situation in the American workplace," said Jeremy Gruber, legal 
director at the National Workrights Institute in Princeton, N.J.

Under the 1986 law, a network operator can intercept or disclose a user's 
messages "in the normal course of his employment" to protect the rights and 
property of the network's owner -- even without giving a warning, though 
experts frequently advise companies to do so.

It isn't unusual for companies to monitor the online behavior of employees; a 
survey in July of 435 large U.S. companies by the American Management 
Association found more than 60% watched Internet connections. Most indicated 
they are worried about lawsuits, especially stemming from workers visiting 
pornographic Web sites or distributing sexually suggestive material, but many 
said they also check to detect network attacks by hackers.

Sen. Charles Schumer (D., N.Y.) and Rep. Bob Barr (R., Ga.) are expected to 
introduce legislation later this year that would limit employer surveillance. 
A similar bill sponsored by the two was voted down last year. The judiciary 
dispute was reported July 5 by the Houston Chronicle and was also the subject 
of an article Wednesday in the New York Times.

For the judges, the issue will be decided when the United States Judicial 
Conference meets on Sept. 11. The conference, which makes policy for the 
judiciary, "is actively studying the issue," conference spokesman David 
Sellers said. "There's really nothing to be said until the conference meets."




More information about the Ir-l mailing list