[Ir-l] Koch's e'hippies article is finally out
Paul Mobbs
mobbsey at gn.apc.org
Wed Aug 29 21:56:49 BST 2001
http://vmyths.com/rant.cfm?id=375&page=4
Rantings
Netwar! (part 3)
by Lewis Z. Koch
COMING TO A website near you!!! WHEN NETWARRIORS STRIKE!
AN ELECTROHIPPIES PRODUCTION
SEE CYBER SIT-INS!
KNOW THE HORROR OF DENIAL OF SERVICE!
TREMBLE IN FEAR AS E-COMMERCE CRUMBLES!
BE AFRAID. BE VERY AFRAID.
"My dad drove a lorry and my mum was a cleaner," said Paul Mobbs,
spokesperson and generally acknowledged leader of a small, but influential
group of Internet mavens who refer to themselves as Electrohippies. Others,
however, call them agitators, firebrands, terrorists, and criminals -- and
those are just the names we can print here.
Radical action on the Internet generally falls into two categories: (1) there
are true terrorists & criminals, and (2) there are what is called the
netwarriors... Mobbs still lives in his hometown of Banbury -- a town halfway
between London and Birmingham, perhaps most famous for the Mother Goose rhyme
which begins, "Ride a cock horse to Banbury Cross..." This once bucolic
village has been marred by a gentrification-driven, post World War II
population explosion of some 30,000 souls.
"We kept chickens and grew vegetables," says Mobbs of his childhood. "We
never ate in a service station, but instead cooked our own food on the
roadside. We collected mushrooms to eat in the fields, as well as berries in
the bushes to eat and make wine. We caught the odd rabbit."
Mobbs and I lunched in London while a typically British winter mix of snow
and rain drizzled from a heavy, gray sky. Mobbs is a burly man, and dressed
in his classic, wool cable-knit sweater and walking shorts, he looks more
like an Olympic hammer-toss medallist than a much-feared Net terrorist. As we
ate, he talked of his wife and two children, 3½ and 2, and his life as a
self-described poor kid who devoured books -- most of which were garnered,
from a " 'jumble sale' -- either school textbooks people didn't return or
books from clearance houses -- mostly classics. "I ended up reading books
with no pictures; geography, history politics, and philosophy."
All Roads Begin With Alinsky At age thirteen, Mobbs stumbled across Saul
Alinsky's rebel classics Reveille for Radicals and Rules for Radicals. In
Mobbs' words, Alinsky helped him "focus on positive and tangible benefits."
Alinsky, as Mobbs understood him (and correctly, I might add, as I personally
studied with Alinsky for several months in the early 1970s) had no use for
any action which is merely radical for radicalism's sake and fails to
concretely affect any real social change. As Mobbs himself puts it, "action
that simply feeds the need to feel concern without committing to
consequential change is mental masturbation" -- a short term exercise for
personal gratification.
It was a natural first step then, for young Mobbs to become active in the
lengthy and bitter British miners strike of 1984-85. From there it was an
easy segue to an ongoing and deeply felt environmental activism. "I've cost
polluting industries large sums of money, mostly as a result of the
expenditure they've had to undertake to rectify the damage I've helped
identify," Mobbs says. "In the year 2000, I ended up with two injunctions
against me because of my web-based support for two groups campaigning against
genetic engineering in agriculture."
Without Borders RADICAL ACTION ON the Internet generally falls into two
categories: (1) there are true terrorists & criminals (e.g. Osama Bin Laden,
money launderers, child pornographers), and (2) there are what is called the
netwarriors. They are the technologically empowered individuals and groups
engaging in net-based activities which are specifically coordinated to bring
about social change in the areas of human rights, the environment, and
economic equity.
The smallest minorities are no longer limited by their geographical
distribution. The Net can unite disparate groups who would not ordinarily
communicate. In the past, concerned individuals and radicals like Alinsky
were hindered by the physical, geographical and economic limitations which
inherently curtailed the ability of, for example, one small group or single
neighborhood to effect global change. It takes, after all, thousands or even
hundreds of thousands of people for protests such as marches and boycotts to
have a tangible effect. The Internet changed all that, providing a means for
sharing information and resources globally thus creating the kinds of
organizations Alinsky sought but was unable to realize in his lifetime.
Now, through the wonder of the World Wide Web, one small group or even a
single cyber-savvy individual can bring a multinational corporation to its
knees. (See Mafiaboy, as just the tip of the potential iceberg with clueless
politicians and cybercops at the helm of the Titanic-Internet.)
The nature of the Net, Mobbs says, means the smallest minorities are no
longer limited by their geographical distribution. The Net can unite
disparate groups who would not ordinarily communicate and even if they did,
they often wouldn't have the financial resources to sustain that
communication and work together. The Net also bypasses the use of
intimidation or official obfuscation. People can network, pressing for change
with point-to-point lobbying across many fronts.
Unlike many netwarriors, however, Mobbs does not see the Internet as a
quantum leap into a new social structure, but rather as a microcosm of the
existing one. "The Internet is within society," he says. "As a conceptual
entity, it must be a filtered reflection of the power structures, problems,
and progressive trends that exist within society as a whole."
Mobbs warms to this. "I know some hackers think this statement is rather
heretical. But anyone who believes the Internet is something separate and
sacrosanct from mainstream society, has, in my opinion, got some serious work
to do on their social skills. The Internet has, and always will be, subject
to the flaws and fluctuations of the real world. Net purists and corporate
Net-heads should not then disparage those who wish to use the Internet as a
means to bring progressive change to society."
You Ain't Seen Nothing Yet ALINSKY USED AND, some thought, abused the picket
line. Mobbs faces the same accusation when he and others like him throw up
electronic picket lines known as Denial of Service attacks.
We can all begin to seriously address the question of Whose Web is it Anyway?
When first exploring what the hardware and software would allow them to do,
the Electrohippies came up with a computer program called Floodnet -- a tool
allowing individuals to flood a website with demands to see it.
Imagine a neighborhood coffee shop which averages 500 customers a day. Now
imagine if 5,000,000 customers all decide they want their double-latte at
exactly the same time. That's basically how Floodnet works. It is a simple
equation, really: too much demand equals a website crash. A website crash
equals the digital equivalent of an uncrossable picket line, and that makes
for some very, very unhappy bigwigs indeed.
(Surprisingly, some thought to be among the most "radical" of "hackers"
despise the Floodnet tool. In another age and in another context, this is
exactly how the United Auto Workers and the Teamsters got living wages for
their workers. The only difference being that some UAW and Teamsters had to
die on the picket lines or the sit-ins before progress could be made.)
When they first conceived their campaign to crash the World Trade
Organizations web site, the Electrohippies expected around 40,000-50,000
requests for Floodnet. Instead, they received a half-million requests in just
over four days. The program has since been provided free of charge for use
against other targets -- and more tools are on the way. Many a large
corporate behemoth and governmental leviathans, it seems, may well be
unpleasantly surprised in the months and years to come by the innovation and
persistence of Mobbs and people like him.
For their part, large organizations essentially have two options for dealing
with Electrohippie-type insurgency. Option One -- they can fight an
unwinnable war, a techno-Vietnam; enacting totalitarian legislation and
arresting protesters, thus seriously compromising freedom of expression and
the right to redress grievances which we all hold dear. The Council of
Europe's CyberCrime Treaty is a perfect example. We have the situation of
Bulgaria and Germany, for example, defining what speech should be or not be
permitted!
Option Two is more complicated, but -- thankfully -- ultimately far more
constructive. Namely, we can all begin to seriously address the question of
Whose Web is it Anyway? We can find a place for dissent, even accommodate
dissent, and in so doing create corporations and government entities far more
responsive to the people they are supposed to be serving in the first place.
Perhaps we might start by revising an old Mother Goose rhyme:
Ride a cock horse
To Banbury Cross
And you'll find an Electrohippie
Who thinks people should be boss
--08/22/01
Related Links
Netwar! (part 1) -- http://vmyths.com/rant.cfm?id=343&page=4
Netwar (part 2) -- http://vmyths.com/rant.cfm?id=349&page=4
More information about the Ir-l
mailing list