[Ir-l] Plugging security over privacy

Paul Mobbs mobbsey at gn.apc.org
Sun Dec 9 10:59:54 GMT 2001


-----BEGIN PGP SIGNED MESSAGE-----
Hash: SHA1

http://dailynews.yahoo.com/htx/cn/20011207/tc/plugging_security_over_privacy_1.html

Friday December 07 12:00 PM EST

Plugging security over privacy
By Tiffany Kary CNET News.com

As the tangle of privacy and security issues tightens in the aftermath of
 Sept. 11, Jack Palmer forges ahead by painting a kinder, gentler face on Big
 Brother.

Palmer is the CEO of ICaughtYou, a private Bonita Springs, Fla.-based company
 that allows corporations to monitor their employees' Internet usage. His
 company has been one of the unsuspecting beneficiaries of the terrorist
 attacks.

Even before Sept. 11, the downturn in the economy led to a heightened
 interest in worker productivity and in the products of ICaughtYou and
 competitors SurfControl and Websense.

Now, a new emphasis on national security has put corporate security in the
 spotlight and has led to a quadrupling of hits on the ICaughtYou Web site.

This isn't the first time ICaughtYou has benefited from tragedy. The company
 was born two years ago, when a tech guru for a government agency suspected
 his wife was cheating on him. He recruited fellow programmers from America
 Online and Coca-Cola to help him figure out a way to monitor her instant
 message sessions. The technology fulfilled its mission and became the core
 product of ICaughtYou.

Speaking to CNET News.com at Giga Information Group's Infosecurity 2001
 conference in New York, a jovial, talkative Palmer explained why his company
 has seen a huge increase in customers over the past two months--and why he
 believes Big Brother can be your friend.

Q: How is your brand of employee monitoring different from what's been done
 in the past by other companies?

If you look at SurfControl and Websense, what you see is anti-employee: "We
 don't trust you, and we know you're doing something wrong, and we're going
 to stop you." That's an incredibly negative approach that I think is very
 demeaning to the employee. I think most employees today really don't want to
 do anything wrong, but the expectation has never been set with them about
 what is inappropriate. Companies are just beginning to roll out Internet
 usage policies.

The approach we take is, "Let's provide management with information about how
 employees use the Internet so they can better manage employees."

We provide online, real-time reporting, by organization, location, department
 and individual user logged on to the network. And we present that
 information over the Internet to a manager in real-time graphs and charts,
 so they can see what Web sites have they been to, how long have they been
 there, what chat sessions are they doing with instant messaging, and what is
 the content of those chat sessions.

We provide a list of key words to filter chat sessions, but we also provide a
 really easy interface where a company can decide their own key words.

We're also working on an e-mail component of our product, which will be out
 in the first quarter of 2002.

There's so much data that's collected. How do you enable people to sort
 through that?

We use a very simple set of fields, and you can look at them over any slice
 of time: one hour, one day, one month, a year. We also offer a productivity
 calculator, so you can say the sales department on average makes $100 an
 hour--so if they were on these Web sites for X amount of time, it relates to
 this many dollars in the bottom line of lost productivity. We present all
 that info in dollar figures.

That helps employees to understand, no, you really shouldn't be spending 75
 minutes a day on eBay.

You know, there was a recent Gallup Poll run that showed that the average
 employee spends 75 minutes a day on nonwork-related Internet activity.
 Seventy-five minutes a day is six hours a week, and that's almost an entire
 day a week. Most managers would say that's probably not appropriate. But
 they've never told an employee that.

You've seen a huge pickup in interest since Sept. 11. What do you attribute
 that to?

Fear more than anything else. Strictly from a corporate perspective, there's
 fear of liability, and there's fear that there could be links to terrorist
 activity within their corporate walls.

There's also been so much talk about the federal government using this
 product called Carnivore, so all of a sudden, there was a lot of talk about
 Internet monitoring. And companies asked themselves, "Well, what are we
 doing?" The answer was, "We're not doing anything," and so the interest
 quadrupled.

After the passing of the USA Patriot Act, now the federal government
 presumably has the ability to go to a company and say, "This person is a
 suspect of terrorist activity. We want to see all of his Internet usage
 activity, and we want to see all of his e-mail." Companies are wondering how
 they're going to provide that data. Well, we can give them that slice of
 data.

In the week after Sept. 11, our Web site activity quadrupled, and (it) has
 increased every week since then. The number of incoming phone calls doubled
 the week after. And the number of companies that are actually (undergoing
 trials of) our product is exponentially growing. In early September, we were
 probably adding five to 10 new trials a week. Now we're adding 15 to 20 per
 day.

How many of those people have become paying customers?

Over 70 percent. We're seeing people that are using Websense and SurfControl
 switching to our product.

Why do you think that is?

Both of those products require a database--to sit on their hardware, in their
 data center--which means that their IT department has to manage it, watch
 it, and take care of it. It requires additional hardware. For example, a
 very well-known company with about 2,000 Internet-enabled employees had to
 add a processor to its NT server once every three months just to handle the
 Websense database. The database was just getting larger and larger. I was
 talking with the CIO of this company, and he was saying tha this is
 ridiculous; this is the perfect application to have run by an ASP. It's not
 mission critical, so let's get it out of our data center.

Also, everyone else in the market is trying to block and filter; they're
 trying to prevent employees from doing things. But there are 5 million new
 Web pages posted to the Internet every day. How in the world are you going
 to build a database that catches all 5 million of those new URLs every day?
 We think that's kind of a head-in-the-sand approach. So we're seeing a lot
 of their customers.

How many customers do you have now?

Right now, we look at it more in number of people we're monitoring. Including
 active trials now, we're approaching 25,000 desktops--without active trials,
 about 7,500 desktops.

Do most of your customers disclose to their employees that they're being
 monitored, and what are the legal issues surrounding that?

Everybody is moving to full disclosure. We encourage it.

Every company has a right to monitor an employee while they're at work,
 whether it be phone or e-mail.

Do your clients usually monitor everyone at the company?

We've had executives that say, "I don't want myself to be monitored." CEOs
 are never going to be monitored.

When you call into a company, some people really don't want to talk to you,
 because they know they are going to be monitored. You have to make sure you
 get to the right person to talk to. Because a lot of people will say, "Oh,
 no way, I'm not letting you in this door."

Are there any statistics to indicate how many companies monitor their
 employees?

Only 30 percent of the Internet-enabled employees in America are monitored in
 any way today. And most of them are monitored through spot-checking.

Are there certain types of companies that are more likely to use this, such
 as financial firms?

Finance is a good audience. We're also seeing that health care and the
 pharmaceutical markets are interesting, because there's lots of confidential
 data.

Are most of your clients worried about employees leaking inside information
 or about productivity?

I think there's liability problems, productivity problems, and also a cost
 problem. The cost for bandwidth is growing and growing in corporate America.
 IT guys are going to CEOs on a regular basis and saying, "I've got to
 increase bandwidth." Let's look at why. Is the sales department spending all
 this time doing streaming video while at work? You can look at it from that
 cost perspective as well.

The debate between privacy advocates and those who want heightened security
 has been heating up since Sept. 11. Do you find you're getting more
 criticism, or are people more willing to be monitored in a corporate
 environment now? I've had a lot of business publications call me over the
 past two months wanting to know whether what we do is a violation of
 privacy--in monitoring Internet usage. My stance is, "What have you got to
 hide?"

But I think people are a lot more willing to give up some of what they would
 perceive to be freedom for protection. According to a recent Harris poll, 63
 percent of people approve of being monitored.

Frankly, we're at war in our own country. And we have terrorists that are
 living right here in the United States right now. The only people that have
 invaded America's privacy are the people who did this, that rammed the
 planes into the World Trade Center. And we need to think less about the ACLU
 and violation of privacy and our human rights and think more about how we
 can help our country continue to be free and enjoy what we've always had
 here.

Monitoring the use of the Internet I don't think is an invasion of privacy at
 all. The government has indicated that they want companies to work with them
 on helping to uncover potential terrorist suspects. The government is going
 to ask companies to come forward with this data. And I think companies are
 going to search for ways to help.

But how do you decide how closely to monitor an employee? How often an
 employee checks their e-mail isn't a security issue.

No, it isn't, but if an employee was going to the Web site that pointed them
 towards how to buy anthrax or how to build a bomb, that would be very
 applicable. It's up to a company management team to decide what is vital
 information and what isn't.

Employees can also get upset about other workers' behavior. We had
 conversations when we were starting the company and we were hiring people to
 come work for us. And we asked them how they felt about it, and a lot of
 them said, "I'd be pretty darn unhappy if I found out that the person
 sitting in the cube next to me was shopping online eight hours a day while I
 was doing my job." But do you know when you find out about it? When they
 quit. They say, you never did anything about this guy in the cube next t me.
 I'm leaving. And by then, you've lost a valuable asset.

How should companies decide where to draw the line with reprisals? Is it fair
 to punish an employee for shopping online when they work 12-hour days, or
 for chatting on instant messenger when they could just as well be talking
 with co-workers?

Well, that's why we look at content on chat. Because you're right, instant
 messaging is very much a productive business tool. Where it's unproductive
 is, we had a customer that had five people in their company, that for a
 solid week, were having eight-hour-a-day chat conversations with external
 friends.

It's all about the information. I think there are some positive ways to use
 this. An executive that I talked to said, "Jack, I have a couple of
 employees that work 12 hours a day, every day, Monday through Friday, and
 normally, they'll work four or five hours on the weekend from home. I am not
 going to punish them by monitoring their use of the Internet. If they want
 to refinance their house while at work, I have no problem with that.

I said, "Fantastic!" Why not look at Internet usage in a positive way and
 reward employees for using a tool in a way that helps move the business
 forward. It doesn't always have to be "ICaughtYou!" It can be, "Ah,
 ICaughtYou." 



- -------------------

"We are not for names, nor men, nor titles of Government, nor are we for
this party nor against the other but we are for justice and mercy and
truth and peace and true freedom, that these may be exalted in our nation,
and that goodness, righteousness, meekness, temperance, peace and unity
with God, and with one another, that these things may abound."
(Edward Burroughs, 1659 - from 'Quaker Faith and Practice')


Paul Mobbs, Mobbs' Environmental Investigations,
3 Grosvenor Road, Banbury OX16 5HN, England
tel./fax (+44/0)1295 261864

email - mobbsey at gn.apc.org
website - http://www.fraw.org.uk/mobbsey.html
public key - http://www.fraw.org.uk/keylist.html

-----BEGIN PGP SIGNATURE-----
Version: GnuPG v1.0.4 (GNU/Linux)
Comment: For info see http://www.gnupg.org

iD8DBQE8E0QutEaNwM05jx0RAoSsAJ9pHMjmpeMTpzaDPUgs8X0bsPHpeACfbgDg
Sw0c+L27Ep05SN+cLtCoFbM=
=Xcg6
-----END PGP SIGNATURE-----



More information about the Ir-l mailing list