[Ir-l] Is Distributed Computing A Crime?
Robin Gaskell
rgaskell at zeta.org.au
Fri Dec 28 09:18:08 GMT 2001
At 09:45 PM 12/27/01 +0000, you wrote:
>http://www.securityfocus.com/news/300
>
>
>Is Distributed Computing A Crime?
>
>A computer network administrator faces multiple felony charges and >years
in a Georgia prison for allegedly installing Distributed.net >clients
without permission. .....
*
* So, NEVER go to Georgia, and never install software in a system before
you get permission first!
Did they throw the book at this guy, or what!?
Does the punishment fit the crime? 120 years is a long time!!!
OK now, what was it he did that really upset them so much?
> ..... computer theft and trespassing charges that carry a >potential
total of 120 years in jail.
>
* Did he actually "steal" software, or was it the Public Domain?
And can he really be "tresspassing" if this was the system he was
administering? Maybe there is some other word, but hardly 'trespassing'.
>felony charges for allegedly downloading third-party software without
>permission.
* What does 'third party' mean in Georgia? Do they talk funny over there?
> ..... the non-profit
>organization distributed.net that allowed computer users to donate >their
unused processing power to test the RC5 encryption algorithm.
* Maybe this was the BIG ONE: the US government can't have people
developing encryption software that the government can't break.
> McOwen installed distributed.net clients at several of those
>locations while performing a Y2K upgrade on the machines in 1999.
>
* Sadly this was probably a NO-NO. But is it worth 120 years for
installing software that the school system had not authorised?
> ..... sending and receiving the
>distributed.net data -- about the equivalent of one email a day.
* Hey, this probably did amount to stealing a few cents of Net-time per
day.
> ..... In October, prosecutors from the
>Georgia state attorney general's office charged McOwen with eight
>violations of Georgia's tough computer crime law: one count of computer
>theft, and seven counts of computer trespass -- one for each of the
>school offices where McOwen downloaded the distributed.net client.
>
* Emigrate .. at least from Georgia, if not from the whole fifty-two.
Yes, I know the Yanks like the simplicity of Statute Law, because they can
use it to prosecute people, without actually having to think. But, somehow
the concept of "justice" has been completely lost.
>Each felony count carries a $50,000 fine and a 15-year possible prison
>term, for a 120 year maximum possible sentence. The indictment also >calls
for restitution equal to the amount of money paid to state >workers to
uninstall the programs from 500 PCs.
>
* Maybe they could have cut his sentence down by orders of magnitude, had
they let him work it out by doing 'community service,' uninstalling the
unauthorised program. Where do the Georgians get the rest of the money, if
the accused has only $5000 to his name?
>As the case nears trial, it's raising eyebrows among some legal and
>technology experts for the unusual application of an anti-hacking law >to
actions taken by a network's legitimate administrator
>
* Well, yes. But this is in America, land of the brave and the free!
I reckon we can just be glad we are living someplace else; or, of
course, if you are a US citicen, you do have our sincerest sympathy.
I will not hack into the system I administer. I will not hack into the
system I administer. I will not hack into the system I administer. I will
not hack into the system I administer. I will not hack into the system I
administer. I will not hack into the system I administer. I will not hack
into the system I administer. I will not hack into the system I
administer. I will not hack into the system I administer. I will not hack
into the system I administer. I will not hack into the system I administer.
Robin Gaskell
More information about the Ir-l
mailing list