[Ir-l] Austrailian Cybercrime bill 'draconian and dangerous'
Paul Mobbs
mobbsey at gn.apc.org
Tue Jul 17 19:34:39 BST 2001
Cybercrime bill 'draconian and dangerous'
BY SANDRA VAN DIJK 4 July, 2001 10:07 AUSTRALIA
[from a security list - no URL supplied]
The IT security industry has been scathing in its attacks this week on the
Cybercrime Bill 2001, labelling it "draconianand dangerous".
Under the bill, which proposes seven new computer offences carrying jail
terms of up to 10 years, it is illegal to possess hacker toolkits, scanners
and virus code.
These are 'tools of the trade' for security vendors to test systems placing
a burden on lawyers drafting ethical hacking agreements with corporations.
Bernard Hill, barrister and corporate services manager of Canberra-based
security consultancy 90East, said the act complicates the necessary testing
undertaken by the company which manages a number of Commonwealth agencies.
"It's a burden for lawyers drafting agreements with companies and will prove
very tricky legally to test denial-of-service attacks," Hill said.
Amendments to the bill will be debated when parliament sits again in August
and Hill said 90East is preparing a submission identifying these loopholes.
He agreed such tools and information are also required by systems
administrators to secure electronic infrastructure.
The proposed bill does allow the Defence Signals Directorate (DSD) and
Australian Security Intelligence Organisation(ASIS) to hack legally. It also
forces companies by law to reveal passwords, keys, codes, cryptographic and
steganographic methods used to protect information.
Hill said companies may be concerned about intellectual property being
compromised, but protecting the national information infrastructure is
critical.
"There have been allegations made about the Government's use of surveillance
networks, such as Echelon, and there being no checks and balances in place
when agencies are given such broad ranging powers. It is a vexed issue, but
the cyberterrorist threat at this time is too great to ignore," he said.
Describing the bill as "draconian"' Unisys e-security architecture director
Ajoy Ghosh said the new laws need to be enforceable. The bill will not
change the current situation where Australia's enforcement agencies have
scant resourcesto tackle investigations seriously, he added.
He said the solution is to empower the private sector, allowing it access to
information necessary to detect, identify and prosecute.
Many private security consultancies already investigate cybercrime but Ghosh
said they are hampered by current laws.
"For example, the inability to get access to ISP billing records; the
private sector could focus on opportunistic crimes while the public sector
concentrates on crimes of mass victimisation or those that threaten our
economic infrastructure," he said.
Internet Industry Association executive director Peter Coroneos supports the
proposed bill in principle but said it needs to find a balance between
privacy concerns and the need to prosecute illegal hacking activities.
A spokesperson for the Minister for Justice and Customers Senator Chris
Ellison was unavailable for comment but said ina statement: "The large
amount of data that can be stored on computer drives and disks and the
complex security measures, such as encryption and passwords, which can be
used to protect that information present particular problems for
investigators. The legislation will enable police powers to copy computer
data and examine computer equipment and disks off-site and enable them to
obtain assistance from computer owners."
More information about the Ir-l
mailing list