[Ir-l] "I'm a cybercriminal. So jail me."

Chris Bailey chrisbailey at gn.apc.org
Thu Jul 19 11:56:36 BST 2001


Le Monde diplomatique   July 2001


BACKDOOR MANOEUVRES
         I'm a cybercriminal. So jail me.


         by PHILIPPE UAEUQ

___________________________________________________________________________

An official report recently published in Washington lists a number of
"global threats to the security of the United States". These include
terrorism, trafficking in drugs, women and refugees, illegal transfers
of technology, financial fraud - and counterfeit and piracy (1). The
Council of Europe apparently holds a similar view. Its planned
convention on "cybercrime" (2), framed with the cooperation of observer
countries such as the US, Canada, Japan and South Africa, recently won
the support of its parliamentary Assembly.

If the convention is adopted (this would require five of the countries
involved in its drafting, including at least three member countries of
the Council of Europe, to agree to be bound by it), it will be the
world's first multilateral juridical instrument designed to deal with
criminal activities on global communications networks.

The purpose of the convention is threefold: to harmonise national laws
and criminal procedures in the area of cybercrime; to give the relevant
authorities access to connection data that may assist their inquiries
and provide evidence (3); and to develop mechanisms for international
juridical cooperation in the fight against cybercrime, particularly as
regards mutual assistance on penal matters.

The text is worrying in several respects. It contains measures that
would give governments access to personal data - and many observers see
this as a serious infringement of civil liberties. For instance, Stefano
Rodota, president of the European Commission's working group on data
protection, views the planned convention as a "juridical limiting of
fundamental rights and liberties" (4). It would allow the "competent
authorities" to set about collecting traffic-related data in real time
and would facilitate the interception of data relating to content by
forcing internet service providers to open their books.

Even more worrying, the convention stipulates that if a country feels
unable to authorise such data collection within its borders by reason of
its domestic juridical regime (for instance, because its laws are too
protective of public freedoms), that country could nevertheless allow
the collection or recording of data in real time by foreign service
providers. This is bound to lead to an all-round erosion of civil
liberties.

The convention also covers issues of counterfeit and piracy. In a speech
to the European parliament on 19 September last year, Kevin DiGregory, a
deputy assistant attorney-general at the US Department of Justice, drove
home the message: "An individual armed with nothing more than a computer
and a modem can victimise people, businesses, and governments anywhere
in the world without ever stepping outside his home." He went on to list
the possibilities: "from violent crime, to terrorism, to
drug-trafficking, to the distribution of child pornography, to identity
theft, theft of intellectual property, and attacks on e-commerce
merchants" (5). Listing them in this way insidiously leaves the
impression that the last three are also "crimes" - and therefore require
the same kinds of punishment and the same arsenal of police and
juridical means as the others.

With this push towards criminalisation, the international juridical
environment in regard to intellectual property is once again (6) about
to be changed, strengthening the rights of copyright owners at the
expense of users. If the convention is adopted, "pirates" - and all
their "accomplices" - will face the threat of imprisonment. That could
add up to a great many people. It will also open the way for the
extradition of offenders: even in the absence of extradition treaties
between individual countries it will serve as a legal basis for all
crimes in this area.

As the text currently stands, it is possible that a school student in
one country downloading music files from a server located in a second
country could be extradited - at the request of a third country - and
thrown into jail. A French citizen resident in the United Kingdom has
already spent several months in prison for having commercially hosted,
on a server run by an American company, pornographic images that were
legal in both France and the US but illegal in Britain (7). If and when
the convention is adopted, such legal scenarios will become commonplace.

ASSERTING USER INTERESTS

Why is the Council of Europe so eager to move on matters of intellectual
copyright? Hitherto this has been the domain of the World Intellectual
Property Organisation (Wipo), with the World Trade Organisation (WTO)
dealing with intellectual property issues that are trade-related
(Trips). These multilateral organisations have not so far moved to
criminalise infringements of intellectual property rights, preferring to
operate at the level of civil and commercial law. Hot on the heels of
controversy over the patenting of computer software, however, comes the
issue of patenting medicines - 39 pharmaceutical multinationals have
just abandoned a court case designed to block South Africa's laws on the
manufacture of generic anti-viral drugs. This has brought into the
public debate, which previously only extended to copyright holders, user
associations and issues of public interest versus sectoral interests,

This may possibly suggest that it is easier to get such measures passed
through the Council of Europe, where special-interest sectors
(publishers, communications consortia etc) are particularly well
defended, rather than through Wipo or even the WTO, where developing
countries are in a majority and more able to defend their interests. In
other words, a handful of developed countries seem to have found a way
of steam-rollering the rest of the world - which has strong reservations
about the way this legislation is developing - by pushing through
piecemeal a project that will serve the interests of certain categories
at the expense of fair access for all to information and knowledge.

The explanatory report accompanying the convention argues that a "joint
approach" is necessary because the cross-border nature of the crimes
committed with the help of the internet conflicts with the
territoriality of the nation state. But is such a joint approach
actually feasible at the present stage of the international debate on
cyberspace? Many key issues, such as privacy, regulation of competition,
freedom of expression and data protection, are still far from being
resolved.

For all its importance to the "knowledge economy", there is no universal
consensus on the question of intellectual property rights. On some
points there are key differences - for example, on the moral rights of
authors. Anglo-Saxon notions of copyright, which tend to privilege the
economic interests of producers, are at odds with the position under
French law. The Council has apparently taken this on board: in Article
10 it specifically precludes any extension of the concept of moral
rights as defined under the Berne Convention of the WIPO copyright
treaty.

Even more crucial is the issue of the correct balance between
information owners and information users. The Council of Europe's
proposed convention effectively closes the debate before it has even
begun, and risks prematurely imposing a particular view that happens to
tally closely with that of the industrial lobbies.

There was also a striking absence of consensus during Wipo's diplomatic
conference in December 1996, where a proposed treaty on databases was
discussed. This was based on the European position, which gave the
ownership of databases to the people compiling the data and not to those
producing them. This is particularly shocking when the producers in
question are public entities. In the end the proposal was withdrawn
because of opposition from developing countries, many of whom realised
that the resulting commercialisation of access to knowledge would be
against their interests (8).

A NEW URGENCY

When South African Aids sufferers began demanding fair access to
treatment, intellectual property rights suddenly emerged from the
backwaters of legal debate and assumed a fuller political and moral
dimension. As Mike Moore, head of the WTO, has publicly admitted (9),
his organisation has taken a great deal of criticism on account of the
Trips agreements (10) that it administers. These agreements powerfully
combine two areas which had previously been conceptually and juridically
separate: international trade and intellectual property.

The Trips agreements were set up by the world's most powerful countries,
and the idea was that by negotiating en bloc they could create a
"harmonised" global environment which was favourable to trade, but at
the same time limited the political and juridical possibilities of the
countries most exposed. Juridical globalisation imposed the law of the
strong. Take it or leave it. "You want to sell your bananas on the world
market? In that case you have to ban the manufacture of generic drugs."

It is this precisely this tie-up between international trade and
intellectual property that needs to be questioned - or at least
moderated - when problems of public order occur, or humanitarian
emergencies arise, and more generally when there is a conflict between
the requirements of development and those of the market. The proposed
Council of Europe convention has the same totalitarian logic: "You want
access to the world-wide web? Then you'll have to accept a particular
philosophy of intellectual property."

Another area of friction is the question of "copying for private use"
and legal exemptions from copyright. The convention's Article 10 seeks
to criminalise infringements of intellectual property rights "at the
commercial level". But this expression is open to ambiguity. For
instance will it include the use of software such as Napster, Gnutella
or Napigator, which enable files to be exchanged between individual
computers without passing through a central server? Such exchanges are
now happening all over the world, and in technical terms they are based
on the notionally legal principle of "copying for private use". If these
swaps are going to be viewed as commercial, it will effectively
criminalise entire sections of the population.

These practices are still legal in many countries; in large areas of the
world they enjoy broad consensus. Is there a risk of a fracture in the
international system of law? The intention of the convention is to work
towards "harmonisation", but might it not achieve precisely the
opposite? What we need is not a multilateral ghetto-law which benefits
only the rich, but a new world order on intellectual property that is
geared - in Kant's fine expression - to the "general interest of
humanity".

________________________________________________________________________


(1) "International Crime Threat Assessment", 15 December 2000, which can
be found at the site of the Federation of American Scientists.

(2) See the text of the project.

(3) Philippe Riviere, "Tous les EuropEens sur Ecoutes", in ManiEre de
voir no. 56, March-April 2001.

(4) A document adopted on 22 March 2001 by the Commission's Data
Protection working group.

(5) See EU remarks.

(6) See Philippe Queau, "Who owns knowledge?", Le Monde diplomatique
English edition, January 2000.

(7) See the site at Transfert.net, 3 May 2001.

(8) See Philippe QuEau, "Covert campaign against freedom of
information", Le Monde diplomatique English edition February 1997.

(9) Mike Moore, "Yes, Drugs for the Poor - and Patents as Well",
International Herald Tribune, Paris, 22 February 2001.

(10) The agreement on trade-related intellectual property rights
(Trips), signed in October 1994 as part of the Uruguay Round, is
designed to create a framework for harmonisation of national laws on
international property rights.



Translated by Ed Emery


________________________________________________________________________

ALL RIGHTS RESERVED © 1997-2001 Le Monde diplomatique

======================




More information about the Ir-l mailing list