[Ir-l] UK citizens become Microserfs? 1: WIRED
Paul Mobbs
mobbsey at gn.apc.org
Mon Jun 4 00:01:48 BST 2001
Hi,
I think this is really significant. I think we could mount an excellent
campaign around this issue post-election. Anyone interested? -- if so send an
email to <ehippies at gn.apc.org>
Paul.
http://www.wired.com/news/business/0,1367,44186,00.html?tw=wn20010601
MS Monopolizes U.K. Gov't Site
Wired, 2:00 a.m. June 1, 2001 PDT
By Michelle Delio
Britain's first step in the country's grand plan to move all
government-related services onto the Internet has resulted in a virtual
lockout for users who do not run Microsoft software.
The British Government Gateway site, developed by Microsoft, will eventually
be the main access point to 200 central government and nearly 500 local
government institutions.
But only those who are using Microsoft Internet Explorer 5.1 can access all
of the site's services at the present time, a situation that some said is
proof that Microsoft cannot play well with others.
Microsoft denies the allegation that it has created a Microsoft-only site.
Barry Goffe, group manager of Microsoft's .NET enterprise solutions group,
said that the access problems are due to security protocols that had been
selected by the government long before Microsoft became involved in the
project.
Critics also claim that Microsoft technology also locks out other developers'
protocols and applications, and said that the British government is now
irrevocably bound to using only Microsoft products.
Scott McNealy, chairman of Sun Microsystems, said the Brits were bound to
find out what being a drug addict is like. According to McNealy, using one
Microsoft product always leads to the need for other and more Microsoft
products.
"The first hit of heroin is always free.... Microsoft is integrated -- it's
not integratable," McNealy said in a meeting with government officials,
according to the British publication Government Computing.
"McNealy's statements are utterly ridiculous," said Microsoft's Goffe.
"Many people like to accuse Microsoft of using non-standard standards, but in
reality XML, which the Gateway site implements, is an accepted standard that
allows different applications and operating platforms to communicate with
each other," Goffe said.
XML -- Extensible Markup Language -- is a vendor-neutral programming protocol
that is not a proprietary development of any company. It has been fully
supported by the World Wide Web Consortium (W3C), an organization that has
approved Web development standards since 1998, according to Andrew Antipass
of British technical support firm TecServ.
Goffe said that Microsoft had been brought into the project when another
vendor dropped out after seven months of negotiations, leaving the British
government scrambling to find a way to fulfill its promise to have selected
government services online by the end of 2001.
Microsoft developers managed to get the three selected departments online in
just under four months.
The company also developed an XML-based architecture that would allow 800
separate departments running "virtually every operating system in existence
and their 13,000 different pieces of software," to communicate with each
other and with U.K. citizens and businesses, a feat that Goffe said required
"many all-nighters."
Goffe also noted that XML's ability to integrate all of these various
applications proves that "XML and .NET is not a closed standard, despite
Scott McNealy's ravings."
Sun did not reply to requests for comment.
The Gateway site does restrict access to users running certain browsers or
operating systems.
"Mac users can enter the Gateway site but cannot do anything useful. Windows
users running any version of Mozilla or Opera are barred from entry. Anybody
else, including those running Linux or Unix of any flavor, is not welcome.
They are told that they are running an unsupported browser," according to an
investigative article in the June issue of the British publication LinuxUser.
But Goffe said this problem isn't one of Microsoft's development work. The
problem lies with the digital certificate system used on the Gateway site.
Digital certificates are a protocol intended to secure the electronic
transmission of information. Goffe said that the British government decided
which certificates they would use long before they began working with
Microsoft, and the certificates only function with the latest versions of IE
and Netscape.
"The government developers are in an unenviable position here. They can
choose security that will allow everyone full access, or they can choose
tools that make the site highly secure, and take the chance that some users
may not be able to access it," Goffe said.
"Equifax certificates can currently only be used with Internet Explorer (IE)
5.01 or later, they do not work on any version of the Netscape browser.
ChamberSign certificates can be used with both Netscape Navigator and
Internet Explorer, except they are not currently supported on version 6 of
the Netscape browser," according to the Gateway site's documentation.
The government-developers' statement on the site said "other browsers do not
give proper support for SSL and digital certificates."
But the LinuxUser article demolished the veracity of that statement with a
detailed explanation of how to provide strong security using other browsers
and older versions of IE.
Kierstan McDonald, press officer for the U.K.'s Cabinet Office, an agency
that coordinates government services, said election ministers and officials
would be unavailable for interviews. This is due to the forthcoming elections
in Britain -- pre-election guidelines restrict their ability to speak to the
press.
Government officials had previously told British tech site VNUnet that the
site was launched with limited access capacities in order to get it online as
soon as possible.
Officials promised that more digital certificates would be added so users
could navigate and use the Gateway via different combinations of Web browsers
and computer systems, a process that was expected to take a year or more.
The government has also been working with open-source and free-software
advocates to help correct the accessibility issues on the Gateway site, said
Jason KitCat, co-coordinator of the FREE e-democracy project, an organization
advocating the use of free software in government services and processes.
KitCat said government officials have been very willing to work with the FREE
e-democracy project.
"They were delighted to be able to hear voices like mine who could offer them
non-commercial alternatives to Microsoft, and EDS and Sema (outsourcing firms
that design technical solutions)."
END
More information about the Ir-l
mailing list