[Ir-l] Tony's Microsoft spot for Bill leaves rest of us out in the cold

Paul Mobbs mobbsey at gn.apc.org
Tue Jun 12 13:42:56 BST 2001



http://www.observer.co.uk/business/story/0,6903,504363,00.html

The Networker

Tony's Microsoft spot for Bill leaves rest of us out in the cold

More internet news

John Naughton

The Observer - Sunday June 10, 2001

It would be nice to be able to attribute Microsoft's capture of the
Government's flagship web site to political corruption. Like most elected
and unelected dictators, Tony Blair has developed a penchant for being
photographed with Bill Gates.

The Microsoft boss is accorded virtual head-of-state status whenever he
drops in on Downing Street and is ostentatiously 'consulted' by the
Government about computers in education.

And when New Labour was looking for a hi-tech location for one of the Prime
Minister's campaign press conferences they turned up in Microsoft UK's
headquarters near Reading. What's going on between Tony and Bill?

Alas for conspiracy theorists, this dog won't hunt. The real story is much
more depressing. For it turns out that the Government handed over the
design and implementation of its prime website to an aggressive foreign
monopolist not because Tony and Bill are buddies or because Microsoft gave
donations to Labour (it didn't), but because of the technological ignorance
and commercial bias of officials in the Cabinet Office responsible for
implementing the government's online strategy.

The origins of the fiasco go back to Blair's early infatuation with the
net, which he thinks of as a kind of pipe. After much hooey about making
the UK the most 'e-friendly' country in Europe, the Prime Minister
appointed an 'e-envoy' in the Cabinet Office and charged him with using the
internet to link UK citizens to their government.

The strategy included putting all government departments online by 2002 and
enabling people to conduct a wide variety of routine transactions - from
paying taxes to obtaining driving licences - via the internet. The Gateway
site (www.gateway.gov.uk) was to be the vehicle for this.

Work on the £18 million project began in June 2000 but the original
contractor - believed to be Compaq - withdrew from the project after four
months for reasons that are still unclear. At this point there seems to
have been near panic in the Cabinet Office, where officials were only too
aware of the succession of mismanaged government computing projects that
have attracted the wrath of the National Audit Office in the last few
years. The possibility that the Government's flagship site might be added
to this list of embarrassing cock-ups was unthinkable.

After some feverish discussion, e-envoy officials appointed Microsoft as
the lead developer last October and gave the company what one observer
described as 'a clean slate' to create a technical solution by January 2001
that would meet requirements.

Microsoft then teamed up with Dell Computer Corporation, the Texas-based
manufacturer of PCs. The deal was that Microsoft would supply the software
and Dell the necessary hardware. The site and its infrastructure were put
together in 15 weeks, culminating in what Dell executives described as 'a
blistering three-week rollout schedule'.

Even if anyone involved in the project had been minded to ponder the public
policy implications of the design, such a schedule left no time for
reflection - not to mention for testing the accessibility of the site to
non-Microsoft software.

In fact, what the Cabinet Office has obtained for its £18m is a relatively
standard commercial-type system comprising Microsoft Dot-Net software
running on 118 clustered Dell PowerEdge servers and eight of Dell's storage
area network systems. It's the kind of system Microsoft might have
delivered to any large industrial client that was concerned about getting
an e-commerce operation up and running quickly.

Successful completion of the project was announced with great fanfare - at
a Microsoft meeting in Seattle in which the e-envoy was accorded a walk-on
part and sang a short hymn to the company under the banner 'Microsoft helps
turn Britain's e-government vision into reality'.

For a supposedly impartial civil servant to allow himself to be manipulated
in this way is remarkable, but observers close to the e-envoy's office are
not surprised. Two years ago, the Gateway would have been implemented by
the CCTA, a group of computing professionals who were committed to open -
ie non-proprietary - standards, and who created a series of highly
acclaimed sites running on Linux servers for the Queen, MI5 and others.

But last April the CCTA was folded into the new Office of Government
Commerce and effectively disappeared from the Whitehall scene, leaving the
e-envoy's officials bereft of dispassionate technological guidance when
tackling the Gateway project.

Which goes a long way to explaining why they were such easy meat for the
boys from Redmond when the first contractor pulled out and panic struck.
The old corporate adage that 'nobody ever got fired for buying IBM' has
come back to haunt us - except that now it says that nobody in the
Government will get fired for buying Microsoft.

But the public interest is poorly served by this mindset. It means that the
cornerstone of the Government's internet infrastructure is totally
dependent on the closed, proprietary software of a foreign monopolist. And,
by endorsing a system that effectively shuts out users running
non-Microsoft software, the Government is endorsing a single vendor of key
products, thereby strengthening Microsoft's monopolistic hold on the market
for software.

As the journalists who broke the Gateway story put it: 'Does the Government
really intend to force UK companies to run Microsoft operating systems on
all of their devices in order to do business with agencies, departments and
local authorities?'

Well, Tony: does it?

John.Naughton at observer.co.uk

www.briefhistory.com/footnotes/



More information about the Ir-l mailing list