[Ir-l] US DROPS COURT ORDER against IndyMedia

MichaelP papadop at peak.org
Thu Jun 14 15:02:21 BST 2001


PRESS RELEASE

Seattle Independent Media Center
1415 Third Avenue
Seattle, WA  98101 
206.262.0721 

http://seattle.indymedia.org

GOVERNMENT DROPS COURT ORDER AS IMC PREPARES LEGAL CHALLENGE

JUNE 14, 2001

CONTACT: Jonathan Lawson, 206.709.0558

FOR IMMEDIATE RELEASE

Today, in a case involving internet press freedom, the US Government
withdrew a previously-issued court order directing the Independent Media
Center in Seattle to hand over computer server logs. The April 21 order
instructed the IMC, a not-for-profit internet-based news organization, to
hand over logs and other records pertaining to the IMC's coverage of
anti-globalization protests in Quebec City. The government's retreat
represents a victory for the IMC, where volunteers and a national legal
team had been preparing to challenge the order in court.

The IMC is undecided about further legal action. IMC counsel Nancy Chang
of the Center for Constitutional Rights comments: "Although the court
order has been withdrawn, the IMC's concerns over the government's ability
to use internet technology for surveillance of political activists
continue to linger."

At the time of the order's issuance, FBI and Secret Service agents claimed
that they needed the server logs to assist in an investigation related to
sensitive documents which had been stolen from Canadian police, then
posted to the IMC website by an anonymous journalist. The agents also
falsely claimed that posted documents contained details of George Bush's
travel itinerary. Bush was at the time attending the Summit of the
Americas in Quebec City.

IMC volunteers learned several weeks ago that police in Quebec identified
and arrested three suspects in the stolen documents case, without any
information provided by the IMC. Still, the U.S. government neither
amended nor withdrew its order against the IMC until today, instead
allowing the order to continue absorbing the volunteer organization's
personnel and legal resources. The timing of the original order, issued
while mass protests were still underway in Quebec City, suggests that the
government intended to produce a chilling effect among IMC journalists
covering those protests - a suggestion then strengthened by the
government's failure to withdraw its order, even weeks after the Canadian
arrests.

The IMC did not comply with the order, which would have involved handing
over the individual internet protocol (IP) addresses of over 1.25 million
journalists, readers and technical volunteers who accessed the IMC website
on April 20 and 21, a much broader sweep than the stated focus of the
government's investigation. According to IMC counsel Lee Tien of the
Electronic Frontier Foundation, "This kind of fishing expedition is
another in a long line of overbroad and onerous attempts to chill
political speech and activism. Back in 1956, Alabama tried to force the
NAACP to give up its membership lists -- but the Supreme Court stopped
them. This order to IMC, even without the 'gag,' is a threat to free
speech, free association, and privacy."

The case drew immediate interest from some of the nation's top first
amendment advocacy organizations. With help from the Electronic Frontier

Foundation, the Electronic Privacy Information Center, the Center for
Constitutional Rights and others, the IMC prepared to challenge the
invasive order in court. However, on the eve of the IMC's planned court
filing, the government suddenly withdrew the order. IMC volunteers
speculate that government lawyers realized the likelihood that the order
would be struck down on constitutional grounds, and decided to retreat
rather than face a court defeat.

Tien comments, "The government owes the IMC, its many users, and the
general public an explanation. Maybe that will prevent this sort of thing
from happening again." With the court order withdrawn, the IMC is denied
the immediate opportunity to have the courts rule on several serious
constitutional rights concerns, including:

* Under US law, freedom of speech guarantees the right to speak
anonymously. This principle has been established repeatedly in the federal
courts, and has been found recently to apply to internet speech as well. On
April 19, District Judge Thomas Zilly ruled in Seattle that internet firm
2TheMart.com could not compel an internet chat room host to identify
anonymous users who had criticized the firm online.

* Freedom of association, particularly anonymous association, is afforded
very strong protections under the law. Anonymity in public discourse has
been a central theme in the history of American democracy; even the
Federalist Papers were published under fictitious names. On the internet,
anonymity is particularly important because it enables individuals to
disguise their race, gender, class or other indicators which might lead to
their marginalization in public space.

* Journalists hold a qualified privilege from compelled disclosure of
sources and other work product. The Constitution requires this protection
because court-compelled disclosure of newsgathering materials poses a
serious threat to the vitality of the newsgathering process and a free
press. The government's order falsely described the IMC as an internet
service provider, rather than as a news organization. Independent
journalists posting stories or photographs to IMC websites are entitled to
the same protections as any other member of the news media.

The IMC was launched in Fall 1999 to provide immediate, authentic,
grassroots coverage of protests against the WTO. Just a year and a half
later, the IMC network has reached around the world, with dozens of sites
scattered across six continents. Each IMC's news coverage centers upon its
open-publishing newswire, an innovative and democratizing system allowing
anyone with access to an internet connection to become a journalist. Open
publishing enables the IMC to present local and national issues from
diverse perspectives, independent of many filters and biases affecting
mainstream media coverage.

The IMC's mission statement reads: "The Independent Media Center is a
grassroots organization committed to using media production and
distribution as tools promoting social and economic justice. It is our
goal to further the self-determination of people under-represented in
media production and content, and to illuminate and analyze local and

global issues that impact ecosystems, communities and individuals. We seek
to generate alternatives to the biases inherent in the corporate media
controlled by profit, and to identify and create positive models for a
sustainable and equitable society."

CONTACT:

Jonathan Lawson, volunteer
Seattle Independent Media Center
jl at u.washington.edu
206.709.0558

Jason Reep, volunteer
Seattle Independent Media Center
jasonr at speakeasy.net
206.545.2872

David Burman, Attorney for the Seattle IMC
Perkins Coie LLP
1201 Third Ave. Ste. 4800
Seattle, WA 98101-3099
206.583.8888    Lee Tien, Senior Staff Attorney
Electronic Frontier Foundation
454 Shotwell Street
San Francisco, CA  94110
415.436.9333 

Nancy Chang, Senior Litigation Attorney
Center for Constitutional Rights
666 Broadway, 7th Floor
New York, NY 10012
212.614.6420




More information about the Ir-l mailing list