[Ir-l] PRESS RELEASE: ECHELON - Condemnation Justified

karen banks karenb at gn.apc.org
Sat Jun 23 11:52:08 BST 2001


PRESS RELEASE

June 23, 2001

THE ASSOCIATION FOR PROGRESSIVE COMMUNICATIONS EUROPE INTERNET RIGHTS 
INITIATIVE BELIEVES THE ECHELON COMMITTEE'S CONDEMNATION OF THE BRITISH 
GOVERNMENT'S INTERCEPTION OF COMMUNICATIONS POLICY IS JUSTIFIED

BRUSSELS, BELGIUM -- The empty seats said it all. At yesterday's meeting of 
the European Parliament's Temporary Committee on Echelon, the only UK 
representative attending was Vice-Chairman Neil MacCormick from the 
Scottish Nationalist Party.

When last seen at the Committee, representatives of the British Labour 
Party had still been trying to make the now completely discredited claim 
that Echelon does not exist. The US and British governments have 
continually tried to maintain this position against the overwhelming 
evidence to the contrary. Their complete isolation was shown by the fact 
that, from the multitude of European political parties, left, right, and 
centre, represented in the European Parliament, absolutely no one was 
prepared to support or even accept their denial.

Of the 160 amendments tabled to the resolution to go back to the European 
Parliament, not one attempts to challenge the Committee's view that Echelon 
exists and is a means by which the US and the UK spy on the private 
communications, including email, of European citizens. Nor do any attempt 
to weaken the strong condemnation of the UK's position on communication 
interception. In fact, the majority of amendments try to go further than 
the original resolution in condemning Echelon and the UK government's role. 
A number attempt to extend the concern about Echelon into taking action 
against all forms of interception of communication, including by the 
police. Although Gerhard Schmid, Rapporteur for the Committee, was not 
prepared to accept this extension, and defended "lawful" interception, as 
opposed to the "unlawful" Echelon interception, he made clear that, in his 
view, lawful interception should involve parliamentary oversight and 
"judicial" processes for obtaining an interception warrant, neither of 
which, in fact, exist in Britain.

The Committee's final resolution will now be voted on in Strasbourg on 3rd 
July. There is no question that it will be carried almost unanimously.  It 
has the support of all political groupings in the European Parliament with 
the only criticism from some groups being that it is not strong enough in 
its opposition to communication interception.

APC believes the Committee's condemnation of the British government's 
interception of communications policy is completely justified. The 
Committee is making an important stand that deserves widespread support 
from Internet users, Internet Service Providers and social NGOs. The 
resolution is a vindication of the position that APC member in Britain, 
GreenNet, has consistently taken in defence of its users' privacy against 
such measures as the British Regulation of Investigatory Powers Act.

ABOUT ECHELON

The Echelon system (reportedly run by the United States in cooperation with 
Britain, Canada, Australia and New Zealand) was set up at the beginning of 
the Cold War for intelligence gathering and has developed into a network of 
intercept stations around the world.  Its primary purpose, according to the 
Draft Report of the European Parliament's Temporary Committee on Echelon, 
is to intercept private and commercial communications, not military 
intelligence.  The committee concludes that "the existence of a global 
system for intercepting communications . . . is no longer in doubt."

A report on ECHELON written by Chris Bailey, APC Europe Internet Rights 
Project Coordinator, for the  1999 Labor Media Conference in Seoul is 
available at: http://lmedia.nodong.net/1999/archive/e25.htm

Also see, 'The APC Europe Internet Rights Initiative welcomes European 
Draft Report on Echelon', London, May 31, 2001:
http://www.apc.org/english/press/archive/apc_p016.htm


ABOUT APC

APC (founded 1990) was the first globally interconnected NGO network of 
groups working for peace, human rights, development and protection of the 
environment. APC has long been committed to campaigning for the Right to 
Communicate and the right of people and organisations to have free and 
affordable access to the Internet. It has provided resources and training 
to support strategic use of the Internet, and helped those who do not have 
ready access to traditional media to make themselves heard using the 
Internet. APC has played a vital role in expanding use of the Internet in 
less developed countries and its Women's Programme (APC-WNSP) has led the 
way in redressing gender inequalities in the design, implementation and use 
of electronic communications.

APC's Internet Rights initiative has been developed to address the needs of 
important sectors of civil society on the Internet, not just to defend the 
interests of Internet "users" as individuals. Our primary aim is to provide 
the resources, tools and assistance needed to defend and extend the space 
and opportunities for social campaigning activity on the Internet and to 
ensure a favourable legal situation for free expression on issues of public 
interest against the many threats to it that are emerging.

APC Internet Rights: http://www.apc.org/english/rights/
GreenNet: http://www.gn.apc.org

FOR FURTHER INFORMATION

Karen Banks
APC Europe Civil Society Internet Rights Initiative Project Manager
GreenNet
4th Floor
74-77 White Lion Street
London N1 9PF
U.K.
Email: karenb at gn.apc.org
Tel: +44 207 713 1941
Fax: +44 207 837 5551

===========================================================
          GreenNet Limited/GreenNet Educational Trust
4th Floor, 74-77 White Lion Street, London, N1 9PF, England
                  e-mail: karenb at gn.apc.org
       tel: +44/207-713-1941  fax: +44/207-837-5551
===========================================================




More information about the Ir-l mailing list