[Ir-l] "Open Sources" - Free Range Training Day July 7th

Paul Mobbs mobbsey at gn.apc.org
Mon Jun 25 20:00:24 BST 2001


The 12th Pantglas Free Range Weekend

"Open Sources": the battle of intellectual property and open information


A day workshop on the new international intellectual property framework, the 
'open source' documentation and software movements, and their potential 
impacts on civil society

1pm to 5pm (please arrive around 12.30pm for the 1pm start).
Saturday 7th July, 2001 -- Pantglas, Llanwrda, West Wales



The 'open source' vs. 'proprietary control of information' issue - an overview

In the archetypal communal utopia, everyone lives in a society where all 
goods are held in common. This aspect, more than any other, has been one of 
the points of ridicule of the communalist perspective. But today this utopian 
ideal is becoming reality in the realms of information and ideas. People are 
giving their work away to be shared by the community. And this idea is not 
driven by fringe groups - it has become, paradoxically, a multi-million pound 
mainstream industry. More importantly this new movement challenges the very 
basis of the new global economy - intellectual property rights.

The 'open source' movement (a generic name for this new group) does not 
abolish the notion of 'intellectual property'. Under the various opensoftware 
and documentation agreements the source or ownership of information is 
acknowledged. But for the majority of uses the access to or use of 
information does not incur a charge. If the information is put to a 
commercial (i.e. money making) use, then charges must be paid. But the 
stipulation that any information or products that incorporate open source 
information must themselves be open source perpetuates the open nature of the 
information ad infinitum.

The 'open source' movement began in the 1980s as a reaction against the 
increasingly 'closed' world of computer software. A large part of the 
computer industry grew out of academia - where the idea that knowledge should 
be 'open' is cherished. Likewise, the development of the personal computer 
(PC) by academics and techie radicals in 1970s California also held the 
sharing of knowledge and information between collaborating groups as a 
priority to assist the development of new tools. The availability of 
computers outside of business and university premises challenged the notion 
that all information must be 'paid for'. This was the tension from which the 
'free software movement' grew.

In turn, the development of the Internet as a mass media through its use in 
the home has challenged the traditional notion of 'copyright'. As information 
becomes ever easier to obtain via the Internet a new global system of 
intellectual property laws (called TRIPS - the Trade Related Aspects of 
Intellectual Property Rights agreement) is seeking to tighten the use of all 
information by awarding people ownership of it; from the genes in your body 
through to the use of names in public places. As with the world of software, 
the increasing controls over information has led to the growth of the the 
'open documentation' movement. Pamphlets, books and music are being shared, 
and new works are being communcally written (such as 'public' 
encyclopaedias), via the Internet, creating a new mass-outlet for personal 
creativity never before available in human society.

Today the battle between proprietary versus open software is being won by the 
open source movement. Much of the Internet is now run by open source 
software, and now the world of desktop computing is seeing new open source 
software becoming available. Recently Microsoft set up a special group to 
fight the open source developers because they now perceive free software as a 
threat to their market dominance. In terms of other 'open information', the 
development of peer-to-peer file sharing over the Internet, such as Napster 
or Gnutella that allow music to be shared freely over the 'Net, or the 
development of open libraries where people can publish their written works, 
has begun to challenge the intellectual property orthodoxies in the 
publishing world.

As the mass media converge into single channels of communication, and 
globalisation encourages corporations to acquire smaller companies to enter 
new markets, branding and control over information becomes more important to 
the economic system. Proprietary control is limited at the moment - mainly 
over the computer software, and audio/video entertainment markets. But as the 
tools to access information themselves become proprietary, such as the new 
'information appliances' to use the Internet, or pay-per-view television, 
then payments will be required to access information irrespective of the 
nature of the information itself. Both the open software and the open 
documentation movements challenge this, not only because open information 
does not need to be paid for, but because the open software movement provides 
the open tools to access information free of licensing fees. For example, the 
recent legalbattles over the control of the format for digital video disks 
(DVDs), and the development of far cheaper computer-based alternatives to 
proprietary DVD players.

The workshop will look at the new intellectual property framework, its 
importance to globalisation, and how the open software/documentation 
movements challenge this new system. It will also look at the ways ordinary 
people and groups can get involved in this new movement.



Logistics

Pantglas is situated off the A482, near Llanwrda (see map). It's most easily 
reached via the A40/A483 (from the Midlands and the north) or via the 
M4/A483/A40 from South Wales and Southern England. If travelling south on the 
A482, turn right at the cross roads by the chapel that is after the left turn 
to Porthyrhyd. If travelling north on the A482 from Llanwrda, turn left at 
crossroads by the chapel following the narrow, winding section of road (just 
before the turn you pass along a long right-hand bend with a crash barrier on 
the right side of the road).

Llanwrda can also be reached by train on the Heart of Wales line. From the 
north you have to change/take the train from Shrewsbury or Craven Arms. From 
the south, Swansea or Llanelli. The trains are infrequent  only 4 per day, 
roughly every three hours) and if you come by train you'll have to leave 
early to get there, stay overnight and leave the next day. For information on 
trains call the National Rail Enquiry Service on 08457 484950.

Space inside at Pantglas is limited. If you wish to stop the night and need 
some space you're advised to bring a tent (for which there is plenty of room 
in the meadow). If you wish to stop at Pantglas contact Tim Shaw (01558 
685353). Otherwise Tim can give you the numbers of some local B&Bs.

Finally, for lunch please bring some food to share - likewise for dinner in 
the evening if you're stopping. Also, if you're stopping Saturday night 
there's a small party around the camp fire in the meadow with some star 
gazing, so perhaps bring a bottle too.

To reserve a place in the workshop, or to get details on stopping over 
Saturday night, call Tim Shaw on 01558 685353.




More information about the Ir-l mailing list