[Ir-l] Analysis: UN Security Council Resolution 28/09/01
karen banks
karenb at gn.apc.org
Mon Oct 1 08:33:49 BST 2001
hello again
some initial analysis provided by peacewomen.org
karen
=====
Initial observations
Resolution 1373 is wide-ranging in the scope of cooperation and information
sharing it expects from the international community. It explicitly and
implicitly claims Security Council powers that have never been considered
before, but it affirms consistence with UN Charter law and existing law,
including humanitarian and human rights. The resolution also has
implications for immigration law and practice, information communications,
and financial services, options, and activities.
Full Security Council enforcement powers are invoked. The preamble reaffirms
the right of individual and collective self-defence and the need to "combat
by all means . threats to international peace and security caused by
terrorist acts." The resolution reaffirms that international acts of
terrorism are a threat to international peace and security, a condition
authorizing Security Council enforcement measures under Chapter VII of the
UN Charter. These articles include measures like sanctions and the use of
force. The language and tone of the resolution rely on concepts of crime
rather than war, and it is in the financial context that Res. 1373
explicitly recalls Chapter VII of the UN Charter.
Action to both prevent and suppress terrorism are outlined. The resolution
includes a broad range of obligatory state-level measures to curtail and
identify terrorists. It expresses determination to take all necessary steps
for full implementation. The resolution refers to pre-existing and underused
UN mechanisms to address terrorism, and calls for their implementation.
The resolution "notes with concern the close connection between
international terrorism and transnational organized crime, illicit drugs,
money-laundering, illegal arms-trafficking, and illegal movement of nuclear,
chemical, biological and other potentially deadly materials." and relates
this to a global response through national, sub-regional, regional and
international cooperation. The resolution requires active information
sharing and the development and application of new national laws. It is in
the context of the financing of terrorist acts that Res. 1373 explicitly
invokes Chapter VII of the UN Charter.
The resolution establishes a committee to monitor implementation. The
committee, consisting of all Security Council members, is to submit a work
programme within 30 days, delineate its tasks, and consider what support it
needs. All states have 90 days to report to the committee on steps they have
taken to implement the resolution.
Refugee status arises in the context of calling on states to ensure that
asylum seekers have not planned, facilitated or participated in the
commission of terrorist acts.
Questions:
Is there a definition of international terrorism? Terrorist acts? Terrorist
attacks?
Is it unusual for SC resolutions to use the language of treaties, e.g.,
"All states shall."?
Why were existing mechanisms to prevent the financing of terrorism not being
used?
What Security Council mechanisms are available for enforcement, and how will
they be applied?
Has there been too much tolerance for the transfer and protection - even
investment and multiplication - of monies? How will implementation of this
demand affect stock markets and Swiss bank accounts, for example?
Is there any challenge here to prevailing concepts of international
security, national sovereignty, or self-defense?
===========================================================
GreenNet Limited/GreenNet Educational Trust
4th Floor, 74-77 White Lion Street, London, N1 9PF, England
e-mail: karenb at gn.apc.org
tel: +44/207-713-1941 fax: +44/207-837-5551
===========================================================
More information about the Ir-l
mailing list