[Ir-l] URGENT ACTION TODAY: UN SECURITY COUNCIL

karen banks karenb at gn.apc.org
Mon Oct 1 08:32:58 BST 2001


hi everyone

URGENT ACTION REQUEST - by 10AM New York Time - Monday October 1st : UN 
SECURITY COUNCIL RESOLUTION 28/09/01

Monday October 1st 2001

Dear Friends,

This is an URGENT request for you to endorse a letter circulated today by 
the Women's Caucus for Gender Justice for the International Criminal Court 
(ICC), New York.

The UN Security Council passed on Friday September 29th, 2001 (pm) 
Resolution no. 1373 (2001) which requires all states to take sweeping 
measures to 'combat' terrorism and opens the door to the use of force as 
one means of doing so. A matter of concern, among others, is that terrorism 
is not defined for the purposes of the resolution.

See below:
==========
1) Background information on UN Security Council resolution no 1373 (2001)

2) **ACTION** Requested - with format letter you can endorse by emailing 
the <caucus at iccwomen.org by **TODAY** (Monday October 1st, 10 am New York 
time) or by fax (on Monday and Tuesday, October 1st/2nd, 2001)

3) List of relevant contacts, emails and faxes for Security Council Members


Please react as a matter of urgency.

In solidarity
Women Living Under Muslim Laws - international solidarity network (WLUML)


From: caucus at iccwomen.org
Date: Sat, 29 Sep 2001 23:35:44 EDT
Subject: urgent action re: General Assembly meeting

----------------------------------------------
BACKGROUND INFORMATION ON UN SECURITY COUNCIL RESOLUTION no. 1373
----------------------------------------------

Dear friends,

We would like to inform you of a matter of extreme importance and 
urgency.  As many of you know by now, the Security Council of the United 
Nations quickly adopted a resolution no. 1373 (2001) which requires all 
states to take sweeping measures to 'combat' terrorism and opens the door 
to the use of force as one means of doing so. The text of this resolution 
can be found at

http://www.un.org/News/Press/docs/2001/sc7158.doc.htm

While passing resolutions aimed at maintaining or restoring international 
peace and security is the primary responsibility of the Security Council, 
it is a responsibility that must be discharged with utmost care and 
diligence ensuring that such actions do not pose a further threat to the 
international community.

While some aspects of the current Security Council resolution are commendable
and will go a long way in dealing with terrorism, there are other aspects 
which have the potential to cause further threats to international peace.

One alarming aspect of the resolution is that terrorism is not defined for
purposes of the resolution which mandates sweeping measures to combat 
terrorism. On the issue of the lack of a consensus about what terrorism is, 
Britain's UN Ambassador Jeremy Greenstock simply said: ``for most of the 
time, if something looks like a terrorist and makes a noise like a 
terrorist, it's a terrorist - and we now know what to do about it in terms 
of what we set out in this resolution.''

Another matter of concern is the manner in which this resolution was 
passed.  Since the September 11, 2001 attack on the WTC and the Pentagon, 
the United Nations has heightened security around its building.  NGO access 
to the building is restricted.  As such there was no presence of civil 
society to know what was going on and intervene in the process.  Some who 
had information on the impending resolution understood the resolution would 
be passed on Monday Oct.1, 2001.

However, the resolution was hurriedly passed on Friday evening.   Clearly, 
the US wanted the full support and backing of the United Nations to any 
actions or use of force against any states they claim to be responsible for 
the September 11, 2001.

A high-level debate on terrorism is scheduled IN the General Assembly on 
Monday and Tuesday October 1-2, 2001. In light of this rushed resolution by 
the Security Council, it is now even more important that states hear from 
people from their respective countries of the danger some of the language 
of the Security Council poses to international peace and security and of 
its potential interpretation to seriously curtail civil, political and 
human rights of asylum seekers, refugees and other members of minority 
groups internationally.

We reproduce below a statement that we plan to send by email and/or fax to 
member states of the United Nations by evening of September 30, 2001.   We 
ask you to either sign on to this letter or draft your own with a few 
points as bottom line i.e. danger of Security Council sanction of use of 
force to combat terrorism, urge primacy of rule of law and resolution of 
international
issues through justice and courts of law.  We ask that you send the letter to
your government mission at the United Nations and to all  fifteen members 
of  the Security Council.

The contact information of the members of the Security Council is 
reproduced below.  You will find the email address of your government 
missions at New
York and Geneva at

http://www.reachingcriticalwill.org/govcontacts/govindex.html

We further ask that you send this urgent action alert to networks in your 
own countries to generate as many individuals and organizations to send 
emails to your respective missions.

Through these actions we hope to get governments to qualify the Security 
Council resolution so as not to interpret the resolution as a sanction for 
any states to use force unilaterally to combat terrorism.

*WE WILL TAKE SIGNATURES TO THE LETTER BELOW UNTIL SUNDAY, SEPTEMBER 30,
2001 AT 10 P.M. NEW YORK TIME. PLEASE EMAIL YOUR SIGNATURE TO
<CAUCUS at ICCWOMEN.ORG.*

** note  this has been amended to 10AM NY time, Octobert 1st **
----------------------------------------------------------------
ACTION REQUESTED - ENDORSE THE LETTER BELOW

1) EITHER ADD YOUR ORGANIZATION'S NAME BY MONDAY OCTOBER 1st, 10 am NEW
YORK TIME, BY REPLYING DIRECTLY TO <caucus at iccwomen.org

2) OR SEND FAXES OF THE SAME LETTER OR A LETTER HIGHLITING YOUR CONCERNS ON
MONDAY  and TUESDAY, OCTOBER 1st/2nd, 2001 (LIST OF FAXES INCLUDED BELOW)
--------------------------------------------

Letter to all member states of the United Nations

While some aspects of Security Council resolution 1373 (2001), which was 
hurriedly debated and passed on September 28, 2001, are necessary and 
appropriate to address terrorist acts, certain aspects of the resolution
give cause for concern.

First among those concerns is that the resolution details sweeping measures 
to combat terrorism without defining what terrorism is. In light of the 
differing opinions among the international community as to what constitutes 
terrorism, we are extremely concerned that the open-endedness of the 
resolution is vulnerable to abuse. Further, we are concerned that parts of 
the resolution could be used to justify:

· Independent actions by states, acting singly or in concert but outside 
the direction and command of the United Nations, against alleged 
perpetrators of terrorism and/or states allegedly supporting such acts 
(Preamble para 5 and
para 3 ( c ));

· Serious curtailment of civil, political and human rights of citizens and
persons, in particular, refugees, immigrants and other individuals presumed
to have such status or be from targeted minority groups (para 3 (f & g)).

A critical question -- for which history will hold the United Nations 
accountable and judge the efficacy of its mission--is whether the world 
community will endorse the use of force rather than the processes of justice
and the rule of law. The world community is poised to usher into being, for 
the first time in history, an International Criminal Court.  The ultimate 
goal of such Court is to try the perpetrators of crimes against humanity 
and other international crimes.  The approval of the Rome Treaty and the 
speed with which states are ratifying that treaty attests to the importance 
of substituting justice for force as a primary means to ensure peace and 
security.

History has demonstrated that to meet violence with violence rather than 
the rule of law perpetuates the cycle of violence.  By contrast, the hope 
of this
new millennium is that justice can substitute for violence and thus break 
that deadly cycle.  To those who committed the September 11 attack, the 
authorization of a violent response is precisely the victory they seek.  By 
contrast, those who condemn this barbarous act must defy those expectations 
and stand for justice, and through justice, the restoration of peace and 
respect for the rule of law.

As an organization that represents the rights and needs of women, we must 
insist upon the fact that the most numerous victims of war are the women 
and children.  They represent the overwhelming majority of those amassed 
now at the borders of Afghanistan; it is the women and children who are the 
majority of the civilian population murdered, raped and otherwise 
brutalized in time of war.

The response to such threats as represented by September 11 must give primacy
to the rule of law and be vested in an international body such as the 
United Nations and not in individual nations or collectivities of 
nations.  We therefore call on the members of the General Assembly to set 
precedents in
the interpretation of the Security Council resolution 1373 (2001) and pass a
declaration qualifying the interpretation of the Security Council resolution
as follows:

·   it does not sanction the use of force and repressive measures to combat
terrorism

·   it primarily seeks justice in international and domestic courts for acts
of international terrorism

·   it calls upon states to be guided by principles and processes of 
international law in their pursuit of justice, including the detailing of
charges, the issuance of international warrants and requests for 
extradition, the arrest of the accused and the provision of due process

·   it lays emphasis on states becoming parties to, implementing and using
the international conventions on prevention and combating of terrorism

.   emphasizes the need to ensure that all actions taken to identify, 
prevent and punish terrorism are consistent with the protection of 
political and civil rights, including the prevention of discrimination and 
protection of minorities.

While passing resolutions aimed at maintaining or restoring international 
peace and security is the primary responsibility of the Security Council, 
it is a responsibility that must be discharged with utmost care and 
diligence ensuring that such actions do not pose a further threat to the 
international community.

The United Nations was founded to save succeeding generations from the 
'scourge of war.' In carrying out its responsibilities to maintain or 
restore international peace and security at this moment in time, the 
Security Council
must find the appropriate balance between measures which will truly address
this heinous form of violence and those which will exacerbate and perpetuate
the breach of international peace and security.

The General Assembly at crucial moments in the history of the United 
Nations has take important steps in the absence of Security Council action 
or clarify
counsel action.   We urge all member states to take the above into 
consideration during the debates on terrorism taking place Monday and 
Tuesday, October 1-2. At this critical moment, it is necessary that the 
General Assembly carefully reflect on its own important role in the 
maintenance of international peace and security.


Signed,

-International Women's Human Rights Law Clinic, New York
-Women's Caucus for Gender Justice, New York
-Women Living Under Muslim Laws, international solidarity network, UK
-Shirgat Gah, Women's resource Center, Pakistan
-Center for Women's Global Leadership, New York
-MADRE, New York
-APC Women’s Networking Support Programme

# # #

-------------------------------------------
RELEVANT CONTACTS AND FAXES LISTED BELOW
--------------------------------------------
Contact Information for Security Council Members (email addresses listed
when available)

Singapore  <http://www.mfa.gov.sg/unsc/presidency/
tel:212-826-0840/0841 fax: 212-826-2964

Tunisia  - tel: 212-751-7503/7534 fax: 212-751-0569 tunisia at un.int

Ukraine -  <http://www.uamission.org -tel 212-759-7003 fax:212-355-9455
ukrun at undp.org

United Kingdom  - <http://www.ukun.org tel: 212-745-9200 fax:
212-745-9316 uk at un.int

United States - <http://www.un.int/usa/scus.htm tel:212-415-4000 fax:
212-415-4443 usaun at undp.org

Bangladesh- <http://www.un.int/bangladesh/sc/index.htm
tel: 212-867-3434/212-972-1267 fax: 212-972-4038 bangladesh at un.int

China- <http://www.china-un.org/eng/c5486.html tel: 212-655-6100
fax:212-634-7626

Colombia- <http://www.un.int/colombia/english/scpresidency.htm
tel: 212-335-7776 fax: 212-371-2813 columbia at un.int

France-
<http://www.un.int/france/sc2001/frame_anglais/accueil/page_accueil.htm
tel: 212-308-5700 fax: 212-421-6889 france at un.int

Ireland-tel: 212-421-6934 fax: 212-752-4726 irlun at undp.org

Jamaica-tel:212-935-7509 fax: 212-935-7607 jamun at undp.org

Mali-tel: 212-737-4150/794-1311 fax: 212-472-3778

Mauritius-tel: 212-949-0190/0191 fax: 212-697-3829

Norway-tel: 212-421-0280/0281 fax: 212-688-0554 norun at undp.org

Russian Federation-tel: 212-861-4900/4901 fax: 212-628-0252/517-7427



1) Background information on UN Security Council resolution no 1373 (2001)

2) **ACTION** Requested - with format letter you can endorse by emailing 
the <caucus at iccwomen.org by **TODAY** (Monday October 1st, 10 am New York 
time) or by fax (on Monday and Tuesday, October 1st/2nd, 2001)

3) List of relevant contacts, emails and faxes for Security Council Members


Please react as a matter of urgency.

In solidarity

Women Living Under Muslim Laws - international solidarity network (WLUML)

-------------------

From: caucus at iccwomen.org
Date: Sat, 29 Sep 2001 23:35:44 EDT
Subject: urgent action re: General Assembly meeting

----------------------------------------------
BACKGROUND INFORMATION ON UN SECURITY COUNCIL RESOLUTION no. 1373
----------------------------------------------

Dear friends,

We would like to inform you of a matter of extreme importance and 
urgency.  As many of you know by now, the Security Council of the United 
Nations quickly adopted a resolution no. 1373 (2001) which requires all 
states to take sweeping measures to 'combat' terrorism and opens the door 
to the use of force as one means of doing so. The text of this resolution 
can be found at

http://www.un.org/News/Press/docs/2001/sc7158.doc.htm

While passing resolutions aimed at maintaining or restoring international 
peace and security is the primary responsibility of the Security Council, 
it is a responsibility that must be discharged with utmost care and 
diligence ensuring that such actions do not pose a further threat to the 
international community.

While some aspects of the current Security Council resolution are commendable
and will go a long way in dealing with terrorism, there are other aspects 
which have the potential to cause further threats to international peace.

One alarming aspect of the resolution is that terrorism is not defined for
purposes of the resolution which mandates sweeping measures to combat 
terrorism. On the issue of the lack of a consensus about what terrorism is, 
Britain's UN Ambassador Jeremy Greenstock simply said: ``for most of the 
time, if something looks like a terrorist and makes a noise like a 
terrorist, it's a terrorist - and we now know what to do about it in terms 
of what we set out in this resolution.''

Another matter of concern is the manner in which this resolution was 
passed.  Since the September 11, 2001 attack on the WTC and the Pentagon, 
the United Nations has heightened security around its building.  NGO access 
to the building is restricted.  As such there was no presence of civil 
society to know what was going on and intervene in the process.  Some who 
had information on the impending resolution understood the resolution would 
be passed on Monday Oct.1, 2001.

However, the resolution was hurriedly passed on Friday evening.   Clearly, 
the US wanted the full support and backing of the United Nations to any 
actions or use of force against any states they claim to be responsible for 
the September 11, 2001.

A high-level debate on terrorism is scheduled IN the General Assembly on 
Monday and Tuesday October 1-2, 2001. In light of this rushed resolution by 
the Security Council, it is now even more important that states hear from 
people from their respective countries of the danger some of the language 
of the Security Council poses to international peace and security and of 
its potential interpretation to seriously curtail civil, political and 
human rights of asylum seekers, refugees and other members of minority 
groups internationally.

We reproduce below a statement that we plan to send by email and/or fax to 
member states of the United Nations by evening of September 30, 2001.   We 
ask you to either sign on to this letter or draft your own with a few 
points as bottom line i.e. danger of Security Council sanction of use of 
force to combat terrorism, urge primacy of rule of law and resolution of 
international
issues through justice and courts of law.  We ask that you send the letter to
your government mission at the United Nations and to all  fifteen members 
of  the Security Council.

The contact information of the members of the Security Council is 
reproduced below.  You will find the email address of your government 
missions at New
York and Geneva at

http://www.reachingcriticalwill.org/govcontacts/govindex.html

We further ask that you send this urgent action alert to networks in your 
own countries to generate as many individuals and organizations to send 
emails to your respective missions.

Through these actions we hope to get governments to qualify the Security 
Council resolution so as not to interpret the resolution as a sanction for 
any states to use force unilaterally to combat terrorism.

*WE WILL TAKE SIGNATURES TO THE LETTER BELOW UNTIL SUNDAY, SEPTEMBER 30,
2001 AT 10 P.M. NEW YORK TIME. PLEASE EMAIL YOUR SIGNATURE TO
<CAUCUS at ICCWOMEN.ORG.*

** note  this has been amended to 10AM NY time, Octobert 1st **
----------------------------------------------------------------
ACTION REQUESTED - ENDORSE THE LETTER BELOW

1) EITHER ADD YOUR ORGANIZATION'S NAME BY MONDAY OCTOBER 1st, 10 am NEW
YORK TIME, BY REPLYING DIRECTLY TO <caucus at iccwomen.org

2) OR SEND FAXES OF THE SAME LETTER OR A LETTER HIGHLITING YOUR CONCERNS ON
MONDAY  and TUESDAY, OCTOBER 1st/2nd, 2001 (LIST OF FAXES INCLUDED BELOW)
--------------------------------------------

Letter to all member states of the United Nations

While some aspects of Security Council resolution 1373 (2001), which was 
hurriedly debated and passed on September 28, 2001, are necessary and 
appropriate to address terrorist acts, certain aspects of the resolution
give cause for concern.

First among those concerns is that the resolution details sweeping measures 
to combat terrorism without defining what terrorism is. In light of the 
differing opinions among the international community as to what constitutes 
terrorism, we are extremely concerned that the open-endedness of the 
resolution is vulnerable to abuse. Further, we are concerned that parts of 
the resolution could be used to justify:

· Independent actions by states, acting singly or in concert but outside 
the direction and command of the United Nations, against alleged 
perpetrators of terrorism and/or states allegedly supporting such acts 
(Preamble para 5 and
para 3 ( c ));

· Serious curtailment of civil, political and human rights of citizens and
persons, in particular, refugees, immigrants and other individuals presumed
to have such status or be from targeted minority groups (para 3 (f & g)).

A critical question -- for which history will hold the United Nations 
accountable and judge the efficacy of its mission--is whether the world 
community will endorse the use of force rather than the processes of justice
and the rule of law. The world community is poised to usher into being, for 
the first time in history, an International Criminal Court.  The ultimate 
goal of such Court is to try the perpetrators of crimes against humanity 
and other international crimes.  The approval of the Rome Treaty and the 
speed with which states are ratifying that treaty attests to the importance 
of substituting justice for force as a primary means to ensure peace and 
security.

History has demonstrated that to meet violence with violence rather than 
the rule of law perpetuates the cycle of violence.  By contrast, the hope 
of this
new millennium is that justice can substitute for violence and thus break 
that deadly cycle.  To those who committed the September 11 attack, the 
authorization of a violent response is precisely the victory they seek.  By 
contrast, those who condemn this barbarous act must defy those expectations 
and stand for justice, and through justice, the restoration of peace and 
respect for the rule of law.

As an organization that represents the rights and needs of women, we must 
insist upon the fact that the most numerous victims of war are the women 
and children.  They represent the overwhelming majority of those amassed 
now at the borders of Afghanistan; it is the women and children who are the 
majority of the civilian population murdered, raped and otherwise 
brutalized in time of war.

The response to such threats as represented by September 11 must give primacy
to the rule of law and be vested in an international body such as the 
United Nations and not in individual nations or collectivities of 
nations.  We therefore call on the members of the General Assembly to set 
precedents in
the interpretation of the Security Council resolution 1373 (2001) and pass a
declaration qualifying the interpretation of the Security Council resolution
as follows:

·   it does not sanction the use of force and repressive measures to combat
terrorism

·   it primarily seeks justice in international and domestic courts for acts
of international terrorism

·   it calls upon states to be guided by principles and processes of 
international law in their pursuit of justice, including the detailing of
charges, the issuance of international warrants and requests for 
extradition, the arrest of the accused and the provision of due process

·   it lays emphasis on states becoming parties to, implementing and using
the international conventions on prevention and combating of terrorism

.   emphasizes the need to ensure that all actions taken to identify, 
prevent and punish terrorism are consistent with the protection of 
political and civil rights, including the prevention of discrimination and 
protection of minorities.

While passing resolutions aimed at maintaining or restoring international 
peace and security is the primary responsibility of the Security Council, 
it is a responsibility that must be discharged with utmost care and 
diligence ensuring that such actions do not pose a further threat to the 
international community.

The United Nations was founded to save succeeding generations from the 
'scourge of war.' In carrying out its responsibilities to maintain or 
restore international peace and security at this moment in time, the 
Security Council
must find the appropriate balance between measures which will truly address
this heinous form of violence and those which will exacerbate and perpetuate
the breach of international peace and security.

The General Assembly at crucial moments in the history of the United 
Nations has take important steps in the absence of Security Council action 
or clarify
counsel action.   We urge all member states to take the above into 
consideration during the debates on terrorism taking place Monday and 
Tuesday, October 1-2. At this critical moment, it is necessary that the 
General Assembly carefully reflect on its own important role in the 
maintenance of international peace and security.


Signed,

-International Women's Human Rights Law Clinic, New York
-Women's Caucus for Gender Justice, New York
-Women Living Under Muslim Laws, international solidarity network, UK
-Shirgat Gah, Women's resource Center, Pakistan
-Center for Women's Global Leadership, New York
-MADRE, New York
-APC Women’s Networking Support Programme

# # #

-------------------------------------------
RELEVANT CONTACTS AND FAXES LISTED BELOW
--------------------------------------------
Contact Information for Security Council Members (email addresses listed
when available)

Singapore  <http://www.mfa.gov.sg/unsc/presidency/
tel:212-826-0840/0841 fax: 212-826-2964

Tunisia  - tel: 212-751-7503/7534 fax: 212-751-0569 tunisia at un.int

Ukraine -  <http://www.uamission.org -tel 212-759-7003 fax:212-355-9455
ukrun at undp.org

United Kingdom  - <http://www.ukun.org tel: 212-745-9200 fax:
212-745-9316 uk at un.int

United States - <http://www.un.int/usa/scus.htm tel:212-415-4000 fax:
212-415-4443 usaun at undp.org

Bangladesh- <http://www.un.int/bangladesh/sc/index.htm
tel: 212-867-3434/212-972-1267 fax: 212-972-4038 bangladesh at un.int

China- <http://www.china-un.org/eng/c5486.html tel: 212-655-6100
fax:212-634-7626

Colombia- <http://www.un.int/colombia/english/scpresidency.htm
tel: 212-335-7776 fax: 212-371-2813 columbia at un.int

France-
<http://www.un.int/france/sc2001/frame_anglais/accueil/page_accueil.htm
tel: 212-308-5700 fax: 212-421-6889 france at un.int

Ireland-tel: 212-421-6934 fax: 212-752-4726 irlun at undp.org

Jamaica-tel:212-935-7509 fax: 212-935-7607 jamun at undp.org

Mali-tel: 212-737-4150/794-1311 fax: 212-472-3778

Mauritius-tel: 212-949-0190/0191 fax: 212-697-3829

Norway-tel: 212-421-0280/0281 fax: 212-688-0554 norun at undp.org

Russian Federation-tel: 212-861-4900/4901 fax: 212-628-0252/517-7427





More information about the Ir-l mailing list