[Ir-l] Will US Security Systems Standards and Certification Act restrict open source?

Paul Mobbs mobbsey at gn.apc.org
Sun Oct 7 23:55:12 BST 2001


Hi all,

I've been following this for a copule of weeks and people may be interested. 
Really bad news - a badder and meaner version of the Digital Millennium 
Copyright Act.

Is this Bill Gate's backup plan to defeat open source software? Fix the 
computer hardware in the US - and hence probably the whole computer market, 
so that open source can't function unless it complies with authentication 
standards?


P.



http://www.observer.co.uk/business/story/0,6903,564449,00.html

The Networker 

Hardware laws hard on liberty 
 
John Naughton 
The Observer , Sunday October 7, 2001

 
Suddenly, everything is black and white. As the Prime Minister auditions for 
his Churchill-Lite role and Jack Straw struts his impersonation of a 
lobotomised Castlereagh, it has become bad form to discuss issues that before 
11 September rendered many of us less than ecstatic about a world order based 
on the economic power of American corporations. 

The attacks on the World Trade Centre have unleashed an emotional tyranny 
under which anything less than unqualified admiration for US institutions is 
interpreted as callous indifference to the sufferings of the victims. 

This is ludicrous: the 'values' for which Winston Blair is going to war 
include the divergences of opinion that characterise an open society. The 
fact that the US has suffered a terrible trauma, or that it is itself an open 
society, should not blind it to the deficiencies of its institutions. Chief 
among these is Congress, a legislative body which, if not exactly ridden with 
stupidity or corruption, often behaves as if it were. 

Regular readers of this column will be wearily familiar with how US 
legislators have enacted every whim of the recording and movie industries in 
recent years - in everything from ludicrous extensions of the copyright 
period to accommodate Disney, to the Digital Millennium Copyright Act, which 
not only criminalises the circumvention of copy-protection schemes on 
multimedia products, but also outlaws scientific research into 
copy-protection technology. 

The DMCA is a pestilential statute that embalms in law the business plans of 
brain-dead corporations and preserves technological innovation in the aspic 
of legislators' ignorance. Given the sweeping scope of the DMCA, you might 
have thought that the multimedia industries would have counted their 
blessings. But no. The Disneys, Warner Brothers and Universals of this world 
will not rest until they have nailed down every aspect of digital technology. 

What's bothering them now is the fact that the personal computer is a 
general-purpose machine controlled entirely by software. This enables the 
laptop on which I am writing this to compress tracks on a music CD and 'burn' 
them onto a blank CD. 

The problem, as they see it is that software is ultimately, uncontrollable 
because it is 'thought-stuff'. Hardware is more easily controlled. The 
manufacturer sets its operating parameters and after that there's little the 
consumer can do. Well, then, mused the strategists of the US recording 
industry, why don't we do the same with PCs - ie make it illegal to 
manufacture computers that are not crippled by the kind of hardwired 
restrictions that prevent DVD players from playing disks from different 
regions of the world? 

It sounds like a crazy megalomaniacal idea - but guess what? While bin Laden 
and his boys were making their last-minute preparations, aides of Senator 
Fritz Hollings, the powerful chairman of the Senate Commerce committee, were 
putting the finishing touches to the Security Systems Standards and 
Certification Act - a Bill to embed copy-protection controls in nearly all 
consumer electronic devices and PCs. 

If the World Trade Centre attacks hadn't happened, this Bill would already be 
wending its way onto the US statute book - and into European law (as the DMCA 
already has) - and anyone wanting to buy a general purpose PC would one day 
have to get a licence from the Government. Now there's a security measure 
after Jack 'Castlereagh' Straw's heart. 

John.Naughton at observer.co.uk, www.briefhistory.com/footnotes/ 
   



More information about the Ir-l mailing list