[Ir-l] FT Analysis - 'Anti-globalisation movement stalled'

Paul Mobbs mobbsey at gn.apc.org
Thu Oct 11 21:02:50 BST 2001


Is the Internet rights movement to follow?



P.

----



http://globalarchive.ft.com/globalarchive/article.html?id=011010001107

FT ANALYSIS THE ANTI-GLOBALISATION MOVEMENT: 

Clamour against capitalism stilled

"A month ago the anti-globalisation movement was preparing its biggest 
protest ever. Robbed of momentum on September 11, it must now reinvent 
itself."

James Harding concludes his analysis: 

Financial Times; Oct 10, 2001

By JAMES HARDING


Four weeks ago, Kevin Danaher was one of a group of activists preparing for a 
march on Wall Street. 

Danaher and other anti-globalisation protesters across the US were emailing 
each other that Monday morning with ideas for a mass demonstration in New 
York's financial centre. 

Using the now well-honed tactics of human blockades, banner hangs and street 
theatre, while also turning a blind eye to a spot of strategically placed 
vandalism, they were preparing for a global day of action aimed at the 
bastions of capitalism to coincide with the World Trade Organisation meeting 
in Doha, Qatar, on November 9. 

The protests, they hoped, would be larger, more ambitious and more widespread 
than anything anti-globalisation activists had tried before. They would 
involve people across the world in what Danaher liked to call "a dress 
rehearsal for the world's first general strike". On the US east coast, the 
target was to be the New York stock exchange. 

Less than a month later, such plans seem to hail from another, more innocent, 
age. After the deadly events of Tuesday September 11, the new protest 
movement has gone quiet. It has dropped the language of confrontation, 
replacing it with condemnation and condolence. Grand plans, such as the Wall 
Street march, have been abandoned. 

Danaher, one of the founders of Global Exchange and a rapid-fire, deep 
baritone voice of American anti-globalisation, says: "The movement is 
shifting into educational mode. The activists in New York are going to change 
their entire tactical approach. There are not going to be militant street 
protests. There are going to be teach-ins and candlelit vigils." 

On the morning the hijackers launched their attack on New York, 
anti-globalisation activism was riding high. The demonstrations planned for 
the last weekend in September were set to attract well over 50,000 people and 
disrupt, if not derail, the annual meeting of the World Bank and 
International Monetary Fund. Organisers were expecting so many people 
flocking to Washington they confidently predicted that they would encircle 
the White House, besieging the Bush administration with a ring of human 
protest. 

Immediately after the attacks, such activism was silenced. The demonstrations 
planned for Washington were abandoned. True, a smaller, but still sizeable, 
number gathered for a global peace march. But Robert Weissman, a tall, gaunt 
disciple of Ralph Nader, was one of the team at the Mobilisation for Global 
Justice who had been co-ordinating the protests over the summer and then saw 
things come to a sudden halt. The frenzy of press briefings and logistics 
meetings in Washington church basements and suburban Virginia homes gave way 
to a quiet bewilderment. He explains: "We are all a footnote right now." 

The movement has come to a stop. In public, activists say this is just a 
respectful pause. In private, however, some campaigners are asking whether 
the anti-globalisation movement itself will prove to be a victim of the 
attacks on America. 

On the morning of the hijackings, the FT had just begun a four-part series, 
titled The Children of Globalisation Strike Back. The following three 
instalments were held over. Originally, the FT had concluded that the 
movement was a Fifth Estate. It was a movement of movements, an unruly, 
unregulated and unaccountable check on corporations, politicians and the 
institutions of democracy. It was powerful but, in its existing form, would 
never be in power. 

The movement's momentum disguised a diversity of interests. It covered over 
cracks in the coalition. And it allowed for the absence of both leadership 
and a cogent philosophy to inspire followship. Hypothetically, the original 
series had suggested in a throwaway line that the movement could be derailed 
by a global recession or a war. But the one certainty, it said, was that 
anti-globalisation protest was not going away. 

Today, nothing is quite so certain. Resuming contact with counter-capitalist 
protesters in the wake of the hijackings, the FT has sought to answer the 
simple question: What now for anti-globalisation? Already, parts of the 
counter-capitalist network are gathering around an anti-war message. Dissent 
in America and Europe has shown itself, even in these extraordinary times, to 
be remarkably robust. Counter-capitalism was anyway an international 
business. America's pain will not silence the critics of global capitalism in 
Africa, Asia, Latin America and Europe. Activism will survive. 

And yet, the movement, like so much else, will never be the same again. 

From his small terraced home in Oxford, George Monbiot has emerged over the 
past few years as one of the celebrities of the counter-capitalist circuit in 
Europe. 

Having started out writing about the indigenous peoples of Papua New Guinea 
and the environmental degradation of the Amazon, he has developed a wish-list 
of global change. He would like to see, among other things, the government 
regain the right to shut down anti-social companies, a directly elected world 
parliament and a maximum size limit for corporations. 

But, in the last few weeks, Monbiot knows he cannot do very much about it. 
"Toes are very sensitive right now. We should not be going about treading on 
them," he says. 

"We were massively gaining in influence and now we are having to go into 
abeyance." 

Activists, who used to relish the rhetoric of revolution and confrontation, 
are now holding their tongues. After the destruction of the Twin Towers, 
icons of American capitalism, something anti-capitalist can so easily smack 
of something anti-American. Talk of "mass mobilisations", "besieging the 
White House" and an "assault on Wall Street" is sooner forgotten now that a 
real battle has begun. 

Campaigners have known over the last month that their critique of 
corporate-led globalisation - a world in which companies fuelled by the 
demands of hungry shareholders exploit people, pillage resources and capture 
democratic institutions - will find little sympathy at a time when reopening 
the New York Stock Exchange has been seen as an act of national defiance and 
buying shares an act of patriotism. 

Danaher at Global Exchange, who describes himself as a man with "enough anger 
for 10 men", is one of the few sticking with the kind of analysis that was 
commonplace at the beginning of last month. 

"Money values got us into this mess," he says. "It is the oil profits in the 
Middle East which meant the US and Russia were prepared to fund these people 
and train these people." 

Many others interviewed in the weeks since the attacks on America, though, 
were uncharacteristically mealy-mouthed. Linking globalisation with fanatical 
Islamic terrorism could both cause offence and blur the issues. 

Anti-globalisation has essentially been a movement of self-doubt in the 
globalising, capitalist west. With America on the offensive, the 
counter-capitalist movement is in retreat. 

But the movement, by its nature, cannot tread water for long. It has neither 
the discipline nor the resources to do nothing and hold itself together. 

Unlike a political party or a trade union, the anti-globalisation movement 
has no membership to fall back on. It does not have monthly meetings or 
constituency offices to keep its followers on board. It does not have a clear 
leadership to agree or impse a strategy. Nor does it have a political 
programme or politicians to follow. 

The anti-globalisation network has been sustained by activism itself. Since 
Seattle in 1999, it has been defined by mass street protests. With each 
mobilisation, activists have had a greater sense of their own power. The 
lists of e-mail addresses of sympathisers have lengthened. The web of 
campaign organisers has spread, gaining more experience and support. The 
ambitions of the movement have increased. And the appetite within the media, 
policy-making circles and the public for their message has grown. 

The critics of the World Bank and the International Monetary Fund had secured 
the right to debate with the leaders of the Bretton Woods institutions over 
the future of the world's financial architecture. European leaders were 
saying it was time to give a fair hearing to the Tobin tax, a proposed levy 
on foreign exchange transactions to help the poor. 

Trade negotiators were fretting about the possibility that they would fail to 
launch a new round of liberalisation, as the World Trade Organisation was 
increasingly demonised by unions, environmentalists and human rights 
campaigners. Anti-globalisation activists felt they were winning - or, at 
least, beginning to win. 

Those "wins", which were taken for granted at the beginning of last month, 
will have to be fought for all over again. With America and Europe looking 
set for engagement in what could be a lengthy conflict, the mainstream 
appetite and the state's tolerance for street protest is likely to shrink. As 
Kretzman sees it: "The attacks will alter the landscape of organising in the 
foreseeable future." 

And without mobilisations, counter-capitalists will struggle to keep their 
critique of companies, politicians and political institutions at the top of 
the public agenda. 

These days, corporate-led globalisation is not even at the top of the 
activists' agenda. Anti-war is the priority. 

The Mobilization for Global Justice, which had been planning the World Bank 
demos, morphed quietly into the Mobilization for Global Peace last month. 
Along the west coast of the US, the well-worn electronic network of 
anti-globalisation activists centred in Berkeley, Portland and Seattle is 
being revived for peace and justice rallies. Over the past few weeks, peace 
rallies in Portland, San Francisco and San Diego alone have drawn thousands. 

In the UK, counter-capitalists such as Monbiot are in the frontline of a 
peace movement that is struggling, so far, to gain mass appeal. Globalise 
Resistance, the group backed by the Socialist Workers party that organised 
transport for hundreds of protesters travelling to Genoa in the summer, 
gathered about 1,500 people just over a fortnight ago to the first anti-war 
rally at Friends Meeting House in London. Since then, plans for peace 
demonstrations each Tuesday in front of Downing Street have attracted small 
numbers. 

Some who count themselves as Wombles - the White Overalls Movement Building 
Libertarian Effective Struggle - are planning a protest at Menwith Hill, the 
UK base for US surveillance equipment. 

In many parts of the US and Europe, the anti-globalisation movement looks as 
though it is changing into an anti-war movement. 

This is, perhaps, inevitable. Activists need to be active. Critics of the 
system do not like to be silent. And, for many, it is a matter of conscience: 
war is against their pacificist principles or their most pragmatic assessment 
of the situation - a wave of violence in response to the attacks on America 
can only create a new generation of martyrs and swell the ranks of willing 
suicide bombers, they say. Being anti-war, they tell you, is not an 
alternative to anti-globalisation, but a complement to it. It is born of the 
same compassion that prompted them to care about poverty, degradation and 
exploitation in the developing world in the first place. 

But, as a strategy, anti-war activism is risky. It further distracts public 
attention from complicated counter-capitalist issues. And it threatens to 
expose as a weakness the diversity that until now has been the movement's 
greatest strength. 

The rapidly gathering momentum of counter-capitalist protest over the last 
two years obscured the faultlines within the movement. The coalition of 
steelworkers and environmentalists, captured by the Teamsters and Turtles in 
Seattle, always looked odd. The World Bank and the IMF may not seem an 
obvious target for the AFL-CIO. But organised labour in America was 
determined to be astride the biggest wave of political activism in a 
generation and sponsored the planned demonstrations in Washington. 

American labour, though, is not likely to sign up for an anti-war movement. 
As one Green activist puts it: "There will be some of the same people who 
were into anti-globalisation and are now involved in anti-war. But labour 
will be nowhere to be seen. Labour will be rallying around the flag." 

The proponents of trade liberalisation, free markets and western liberalism 
have rallied in response to the assault on America. For them, capitalism no 
longer needs to be explained, it needs to be defended. 

Robert Zoellick, the US trade negotiator, has argued that America should 
combat terror with trade. Those who feared anti-globalisation activism could 
act as a brake on the WTO's efforts to launch a new trade round now feel the 
activists can be ignored. 

The coalition of counter-capitalists now faces a more energised and 
determined capitalist establishment than before. Keeping the coalition 
together while pursuing an anti-war agenda promises to be more difficult. 

This is not only true between Greens and Blues, environmentalists and labour. 
In the past couple of years, some say much like 1968, activists in Europe and 
America have had a sense that they have been marching side by side. The sense 
now is that this moment has passed. 

Across activist groups in Europe and the US, the message is the same: We are 
not sure exactly how things will go from here. But we are not going away. 
Over the months ahead, the calendar is full: the European Union summit in 
Belgium at the end of the year; the World Social Forum in Porto Allegre in 
January; the Rio-plus-10 environmental summit in Johannesburg in the middle 
of next year. 

"The spirit is not flagging," says Susan George, intellectual grandmother of 
the movement in Europe. "It may be harder, but our message is even more 
necessary now. It is one of greater equality and solidarity between north and 
south." 

Just as Ms George keeps burrowing away at the system, counter-capitalism 
remains doggedly what it was. It is still the Fifth Estate, a check on the 
excesses and inadequacies of global capitalism. Much like the media - the 
Fourth Estate - it is not always a force for good. It is riddled with egotism 
and petty politics. Its actions are sometimes misinformed, sometimes 
misjudged. It has an inflated sense of its own importance. Its targets keep 
changing and growing. 

And it has been robbed of its momentum. Counter-capitalism was not just a 
movement, it was a mood. Its main platform - the street - is not as open as 
it was. Its message, always complicated, is now much more loaded. Its 
audience - politicians, the press and the public - are seriously distracted. 
And its funding base, already tiny, threatens to shrivel as charitable 
foundations and philanthropists see their fortunes shrink with the stock 
market. 

As it has done before, it is going to have to reinvent itself. "The 
globalisation movement has been struck a blow, but not a mortal blow," says 
Danaher, the defiant activist who is still planning for a global day of 
action to protest against the WTO, even if it is not a march on Wall Street. 

"We were damaged, but not irreparably. The movement is getting back on its 
feet. For a while, we were drowned out, but we are finding our voice." 

Copyright: The Financial Times Limited




More information about the Ir-l mailing list