[Ir-l] RIAA seeks rights in US law to hack your PC

Paul Mobbs mobbsey at gn.apc.org
Mon Oct 15 22:36:47 BST 2001


http://www.wired.com/news/conflict/0,2100,47552,00.html?tw=wn20011015

RIAA Wants to Hack Your PC 

By Declan McCullagh 
2:00 a.m. Oct. 15, 2001 PDT


WASHINGTON -- Look out, music pirates: The recording industry wants the right 
to hack into your computer and delete your stolen MP3s.

It's no joke. Lobbyists for the Recording Industry Association of America 
(RIAA) tried to glue this hacking-authorization amendment onto a mammoth 
anti-terrorism bill that Congress approved last week.

An RIAA-drafted amendment according to a draft obtained by Wired News would 
immunize all copyright holders -- including the movie and e-book industry -- 
for any data losses caused by their hacking efforts or other computer 
intrusions "that are reasonably intended to impede or prevent" electronic 
piracy. 

In an interview Friday, RIAA lobbyist Mitch Glazier said that his association 
has abandoned plans to insert that amendment into anti-terrorism bills -- and 
instead is supporting a revised amendment that takes a more modest approach.

"It will not be some special exception for copyright owners," Glazier said. 
"It will be a general fix to bring back current law." Glazier is the RIAA's 
senior vice president of government relations and a former House aide.

The RIAA's interest in the USA Act, an anti-terrorism bill that the Senate 
and the House approved last week, grew out of an obscure part of it called 
section 815. Called the "Deterrence and Prevention of Cyberterrorism" 
section, it says that anyone who breaks into computers and causes damage 
"aggregating at least $5,000 in value" in a one-year period would be 
committing a crime.

If the current version of the USA Act becomes law, the RIAA believes, it 
could outlaw attempts by copyright holders to break into and disable pirate 
FTP or websites or peer-to-peer networks. Because the bill covers aggregate 
damage, it could bar anti-piracy efforts that cause little harm to individual 
users, but meet the $5,000 threshold when combined.

"We might try and block somebody," Glazier said. "If we know someone is 
operating a server, a pirated music facility, we could try to take measures 
to try and prevent them from uploading or transmitting pirated documents."

The RIAA believes that this kind of technological "self-help" against online 
pirates, if done carefully, is legal under current federal law. But the RIAA 
is worried about the USA Act banning that practice -- and neither the Senate 
nor the House versions of that bill include the RIAA's suggested changes.

Glazier said that the RIAA was no longer lobbying for the language provided 
to Wired News -- "that's completely out" -- but instead wanted to ensure that 
current law remains the same. But Glazier said he could not provide a copy of 
the revised amendment he hopes to include.

Legal scholars say that the original amendment the RIAA had been shopping 
around to members of Congress raises privacy and security concerns.

"It could lead to some really bad outcomes, like a program purposefully 
intended to delete MP3s that misfunctions and erases everything on a disk -- 
ooops," says Marc Rotenberg, director of the Electronic Privacy Information 
Center. "Think a repo man smashing windows and knocking down doors to pull 
out the 27-inch color TV when you've missed a couple of payments."

Peter Swire, a former top privacy official under President Clinton and now a 
professor at Ohio State University, says he hopes there would be public 
debate on any such proposal.

"On its face, this language would allow a deliberate hack attack by a 
copyright owner against the system of someone who is infringing the 
copyright," Swire said.

The draft amendment is overly broad and poorly-written, says Orin Kerr, a 
former Justice Department lawyer now at George Washington University. Says 
Kerr: "It would deny victims their right to sue copyright owners and their 
agents if they engaged in vigilante justice by hacking or other means in an 
effort to block online music distribution."

"Another troubling thing is that they appear to be trying to limit their 
liability for consequential damages," says R. Polk Wagner, an assistant 
professor at the University of Pennsylvania's law school. "What if their 
efforts caused your hard disk to become fatally corrupted?"

An aide on Capitol Hill who had been contacted by the RIAA was even more 
blunt, dubbing the amendment the "RIAA's License to Virus" proposal.

For its part, the RIAA is still trying to get a copy of its revised amendment 
-- that it would not provide a copy of -- included in the anti-terrorism bill 
called the USA Act.

"It didn't make it into the Senate bill," says the RIAA's Glazier. "So the 
great work of the Senate staff to fix this unintentional problem didn't get 
through. Now we're in the House with the base language that could have these 
unintended consequences."

On Friday, the House voted 339-79 for the USA Act, which eases limits on 
wiretapping and Internet monitoring. The Senate approved the bill on Thursday.

Because neither the House nor the Senate versions of the USA Act include 
either variant of the RIAA's amendment, the association's lobbyists will 
focus on a possible conference committee, which would be appointed to work 
out differences with the Senate. Another possibility is that the Senate could 
enact the USA Act when senators return this week, automatically sending the 
bill to President Bush for his signature.

Bush has asked Congress for the additional surveillance and detention powers 
as a response to the deadly Sept. 11 terrorist attacks on the World Trade 
Center and the Pentagon.

The text of the original RIAA amendment says that "no action may be brought 
under this subsection arising out of any impairment of the availability of 
data, a program, a system or information, resulting from measures taken by an 
owner of copyright in a work of authorship, or any person authorized by such 
owner to act on its behalf, that are intended to impede or prevent the 
infringement of copyright in such work by wire or electronic communication."

It also immunizes from liability actions that "are reasonably intended to 
impede or prevent the unauthorized transmission" of pirated materials.


END



More information about the Ir-l mailing list