[Ir-l] Microsoft opposes full disclosure
Paul Mobbs
mobbsey at gn.apc.org
Wed Oct 17 19:25:10 BST 2001
http://www.newsbytes.com/cgi-bin/udt/im.display.printable?client.id=newsbytes
&story.id=171173
Microsoft opposes full disclosure
By Brian McWilliams, Newsbytes
REDMOND, WASHINGTON, U.S.A.,
16 Oct 2001, 1:37 PM CST
Pushed to the brink by recent Internet worm
outbreaks, Microsoft hopes to rally the computer industry against those who
improperly publish information about security vulnerabilities.
In an editorial at Microsoft's site, Scott Culp, head of the company's
Security Response Center, announced the initiative against what he called
"information anarchy."
According to Culp, the damage caused by worms such as Code Red and Nimda can
be blamed in part on computer security professionals who discovered the
software flaws exploited by the malicious, self-propagating programs.
"The people who wrote (the worms) have been rightly condemned as criminals.
But they needed help to devastate our networks ... It's high time the
security community stopped providing blueprints for building these weapons,"
he said.
According to Culp, recent worms have relied on techniques and even specific
software instructions published by security firms in their advisories about
software bugs.
"Clearly, the publication of exploit details about the vulnerabilities
contributed to their use as weapons ... It's simply indefensible for the
security community to continue arming cybercriminals," he said.
Microsoft's editorial is the latest salvo in the debate between security
experts and software vendors over what is called "full disclosure."
In Microsoft's view, the only prudent policy is to work with vendors and not
disclose vulnerability information to the public until a patch is available
- and then only to disclose enough information so that administrators can
decide whether to apply the fix without being at risk if they don't.
"This is not a call to stop discussing vulnerabilities. Instead, it is a call
for security professionals to draw a line beyond which we recognize that we
are simply putting other people at risk," said Culp.
To exert economic pressure on security consultants to adopt this approach,
Microsoft recommends that customers ask consultants for their policy on
disclosing information about security bugs they discover.
<snip>
More information about the Ir-l
mailing list