[Ir-l] Observer: Why we should chuck XP out the Windows

Paul Mobbs mobbsey at gn.apc.org
Tue Oct 23 21:54:42 BST 2001


http://www.observer.co.uk/business/story/0,6903,577675,00.html


Why we should chuck XP out the Windows 
 
John Naughton
The Networker 
The Observer, Sunday October 21, 2001
 
 
Those whom the Gods wish to destroy, they first make loopy. In computer 
stores up and down the country you will find managers and salespersons 
eagerly looking forward to Thursday. Why? Because on that day Microsoft 
officially launches Windows XP, the latest version of Bill Gates's licence to 
print money. 

The software has a fancy new interface, with snazzier colours and all kinds 
of ingenious shortcuts and bundled software for playing movies, MP3 files and 
streaming audio and video - in a flagrant repetition of the aggressive 
software-bundling behaviour that landed the company with an anti-trust suit. 

XP is also a Trojan horse that enables Mr Gates and a horde of even less 
welcome folks to invade your privacy, exploit your computer and empty your 
wallet. 

So why are all these idiots in computer stores drooling at the prospect? 
Answer: because Windows XP is a monstrous, bloated brute that requires a 
state-of-the- art PC and two gigabytes of hard disk space before it will even 
say 'hello'. This means any consumer foolish enough to want to run XP will 
probably have to buy a new PC. 

At a time when sales have stagnated, this is great news for the hard-pressed 
computer industry. So trebles all round for the suits in PC World, Currys and 
the like? 

Er, possibly not. For one thing, XP is being launched into a world now 
sinking into recession, which means corporate IT managers may not take kindly 
to the notion of having to order hundreds of new PCs simply to run a version 
of Excel with cooler graphics when their users are perfectly happy with the 
old, uncool version. 

Second, XP has some nasty surprises in store for its hapless purchasers. 
Chief among these is a fiendish new feature called 'product activation'. What 
this means is that even after you've purchased and installed the software, 
you have to contact Microsoft for permission to 'activate' it. 

How come? Well, during installation, XP surveys the PC's hardware and creates 
a 44-key code, which is a unique 'fingerprint' of your system. This 
effectively locks the copy of XP to your hardware and has a number of 
interesting implications. 

If you upgrade your hardware, for example, XP may 'deactivate' and require 
you to call Mr Gates for permission to reinstall. The same applies if you buy 
a new machine and desire to move your copy of XP to it. And so on. 

XP also comes with ingenious licensing options, all of which have the effect 
of locking you into upgrading not when you want to but when Microsoft decides 
you ought to. 

This is bad news, of course, for small companies; but it also scares the 
pants off industry giants such as BP, Argos, Cadbury Schweppes, Dixons, Marks 
& Spencer, GlaxoSmithKline and Shell. They have collectively written to DTI 
Minister Patricia Hewitt complaining that Microsoft's new tariff will 
generate a 94 per cent increase in the cost of software licences. They 
estimate that their licensing costs will rise by £880 million a year as a 
result, and want Hewitt to refer Microsoft to the Office of Fair Trading. 

Fat chance. New Labour is hooked on Microsoft. Last Thursday, trade journal 
Computer Weekly reported that hospital IT managers were appalled to discover 
that the NHS had signed a three-year licence with Microsoft without 
consulting them. And where the NHS goes, so too will the DfEE, the MoD, the 
DSS and even Hewitt's Department of Torpor and Indolence. 

In the end, of course, even New Labour will realise that XP is a step too 
far. In the meantime, taxpayers seeking alternatives to paying the Gates 
tithe may find something useful at www.livingwithoutmicrosoft.org. 


John.naughton at observer.co.uk 

www.briefhistory.com/footnotes/ 
   
  



More information about the Ir-l mailing list