[Ir-l] US Digital Millennium Copyright Act Restricts Freedoms in UK

Paul Mobbs mobbsey at gn.apc.org
Tue Oct 30 11:44:08 GMT 2001


http://www.securityfocus.com/news/274

Linux Update withholds Security Details --
American coders will be kept in the dark about some Linux security updates, 
amid DMCA fears.

By Kevin Poulsen
Oct 25 2001 1:33PM PT

Citing a controversial U.S. copyright law, a top Linux developer announced 
this week that Americans would not be given details about the security fixes 
in an update to the open source operating system, a first for a software 
development community that prides itself on transparency.

An update to version 2.2 of the Linux kernel, an older version of Linux 
that's still in wide use, was released Monday, conspicuously shorn of 
information about a number of security holes patched in the software. 

In an email to a Linux developer's mailing list, U.K.-based Linux guru Alan 
Cox wrote that the self-censorship was necessary to avoid running afoul of 
the U.S. Digital Millennium Copyright Act (DMCA), a law that makes it a crime 
to create or distribute software "primarily designed" to circumvent a copy 
protection scheme. 

Cox controls the 2.2 release, and is generally considered Linux's 
second-in-command after creator Linus Torvalds. 

The DMCA has been under fire from computer programmers and electronic civil 
libertarians who argue that it is an unconstitutional impingement on speech, 
and interferes with consumers' traditional right to make personal copies of 
books, movies and music that they've purchased.

In July, the first criminal prosecution under the Act kicked-off with FBI 
agents arresting Dmitry Sklyarov, a Russian computer programmer who was 
visiting the U.S. to give a talk at a security conference. Sklyarov is the 
author of a computer program that cracks the copy protection scheme used by 
Adobe Systems' eBook software.
 'U.S. citizens will have to guess about security issues.' 
-- Alan Cox
"With luck, the Sklyarov case will see that overturned on constitutional 
grounds," Cox wrote on the list. "Until then U.S. citizens will have to guess 
about security issues."

America Boycotted
But U.S. Linux developers and users suspect Cox of using them to carry a 
political message.

"My personal belief is that certain people are using this as an excuse to 
draw attention to the dangers inherent in the DMCA," says Birmingham system 
administrator Wayne Brown. "I'm sympathetic to their efforts, but not at all 
happy that people who need access to this information will be denied just to 
make a point... It seems to me to be contrary to the whole spirit of free 
software development."

"I still think this is an extremist view of the DMCA," wrote U.S. Linux 
developer Tom Sightler, in a post to the developer's list. "I don't see where 
it keeps you from posting information about security fixes to your own code."

Cox didn't respond to a reporter's inquiry, but on the mailing list, he wrote 
that the new closed policy was necessary because Linux's standard security 
features may be used for "rights management" of copyrighted work. He declined 
to elaborate further "on a list that reaches U.S. citizens."

The programmer plans to post Linux security information exclusively on a Web 
site that will block access from the U.S.

Despite Cox's fears, describing security holes or patches in Linux doesn't 
violate the DMCA, because the information isn't primarily designed for the 
purpose of circumvention, says attorney Jennifer Granick, director of the 
Stanford Law School's Law and Technology Clinic. 

"He seems to be assuming that the DMCA prohibits discussion about any kind of 
security, and that's not what it does," says Granick. "The DMCA is bad, but 
it's not that bad." 

"Part of the problem with the DMCA is it doesn't make intuitive sense to 
people who are practicing in this field, so even after reading the statute, 
people don't understand exactly what they are or aren't allowed to do," says 
Granick.




More information about the Ir-l mailing list