[Ir-l] Microsoft Goes McCarthy in War Against Linux

Paul Mobbs mobbsey at gn.apc.org
Thu Sep 6 13:03:03 BST 2001


Article from http://www.alternet.org/story.html?StoryID=11321

Microsoft Goes McCarthy in War Against Linux

Omar J. Pahati, AlterNet, August 14, 2001


Microsoft Windows is the single most widely used computer program in
the world. Chances are, it's running right now on your computer at home,
in your office, at your kids' school, you name it. Millions of people see
the flying Windows logo every day, as it waves across 90 percent of all
computer screens on the planet.

Windows and its related programs have become so dominant that, as
anyone who has ever heard of Bill Gates knows, the Justice Department
is fighting a protracted legal war to break Microsoft's monopoly power.
Over a year ago, Microsoft was ordered to split into three different
companies. Lately, Justice has threatened to block the release of
Windows XP, the latest version of the program, until the courts have
decided on a remedy for Microsoft's misbehavior.

But considering how handily Microsoft lawyers have dealt with the
overnment in the past, that may not be Bill Gates' biggest worry these
days. Instead, he's probably looking over his shoulder at a program that
is equal to (if not better than) Windows, one that's steadily eating away
at Microsoft's market share, is constantly being upgraded, and is
completely free: Linux.

Known in the geek world as "open source" software (its source code can
be used or tweaked for free), Linux has become Microsoft's #1
competitor. According to market researcher International Data Corp.,
Linux garnered a 27 percent share of operating system software for
computer servers sold last year. That's up from 24 percent in 1999 and
17 percent in 1998 -- a surprisingly high growth rate that positions Linux
as the prime contender to knock Microsoft Windows (41 percent) from
the top spot.

That has the folks in Redmond worried. So worried, in fact, that Microsoft
bigwigs are calling Linux "un-American" and a threat to innovation. At a
congressional hearing on intellectual property earlier this year, Microsoft
operating system chief Jim Allchin said, "Open source is an
intellectual-property destroyer. I'm an American, I believe in the
American Way. I worry if the government encourages open source, and I
don't think we've done enough education of policymakers to understand
the threat."

Microsoft CEO Steve Ballmer called open source software a "cancer that
attaches itself in an intellectual property sense to everything it
touches."

Even founder Bill Gates weighed in with his own rhetoric saying that
open source was created with the belief that the business of software
should not even exist.

Microsoft's gripe is that once a company develops software using open
source code, it must forfeit its right to charge for the intellectual
property that is the product of that development. It's largely viewed as a
bogus argument, since there is nothing illegal about Linux or the General
Public License that guarantees its open development and use; it may even be
protected as free speech. In reality, Linux is less a threat to the
intellectual property business than to Microsoft's business.

Linux developers, known as penguin-heads (in reference to their
penguin mascot), are naturally a bit upset at Microsoft's attack. Posting
on the popular Linux hangout Slashdot, a programmer going by the
name of "herk" remarked, "Well if they can't destroy Linux through
corporate stronghold tactics and intimidation, they may as well resort to
convincing the general public it should be illegal."

Of course, many in the Linux community view the Microsoft offensive as
confirmation that Linux has arrived. "It is telling when an unethical
company who engages in various illegal practices descends into nothing
short of crass nationalism to defend its case," added another open
source programmer.

In a statement released in response to Microsoft's charge, several open
source leaders -- including Linux's creator, Linus Torvalds, Red Hat
co-founder Bob Young, VA Linux Systems CEO Larry Augustin,
publisher Tim O'Reilly and Free Software Foundation guru Richard
Stallman -- defended their movement, saying, "We have become so
serious a competitor to Microsoft that their executives publicly announce
their fear. However, the only threat that we present to Microsoft is the
end of monopoly practices."

Ironically, Microsoft's accusations were made before a government that
has already adopted Linux's for its own computers. Several federal
agencies have chosen to use Linux over Microsoft on their machines.
Even the National Security Agency (NSA) has developed its own
security-enhanced version of Linux. Jeffery Hunker, Senior Director for
Critical Infrastructure at the White House National Security Council says,
"Open source software plays an increasingly important role in federal IT
systems. I'm delighted the NSA's security experts are making this
valuable contribution to the open source community."

The federal government isn't the only powerful friend Linux has made.
Carly Fiorina, CEO of Hewlett-Packard, has said that "the open source
movement is natural, inevitable and creates huge benefits." And last
year, computer maker Compaq sold 24 percent of all servers that ran
Linux, making it the best selling platform for Linux and an important piece
of the puzzle for open source's future.

But IBM has emerged as the biggest player in the race to get Linux to
the top. They alone have pledged to spend $1 billion in 2001 to develop
and promote a line of Linux servers. With that kind of backing, Linux
could become a household name by next summer.

"We see Linux as a major force in IT and moving IT to the next
generation in the Internet business," says Irving Wladawsky Berger,
IBM's vice president of technology and strategy. "So we are supporting
Linux across all of our hardware platforms, our middleware and our
services business." Specifically, mid-sized businesses will be able to
adopt robust Linux technologies once reserved for larger enterprises.
This trend of running Linux on smaller and smaller platforms should
eventually reach the desktop of the average user, bringing Linux to the
largest possible audience.

The open-source community's reaction to IBM's commitment has been
largely positive. "For the Linux community, this means a long-term solid
name to rely on for support," posted one penguin-head. "That's
wonderful, as international companies will be able to get support
anywhere, and smaller companies that really want a reliable solution will
look at the IBM label as a plus."

Another Slashdot member added, "IBM might not be the biggest name in
the PC world, but they are still one of the (if not the one) biggest
companies when it comes to corporate mindshare. It's good to have
them on this side and not paired up with Microsoft."

Needless to say, Microsoft won't be going down without a fight. This
summer Bill Gates announced the Microsoft .NET initiative, which aims to
move Microsoft's existing software onto the Web, where it will be
available for use through a subscription service. Gates hopes that in the
future all electronic devices -- from computers and televisions, to
palm-helds and cell phones -- will connect to .NET's web of services. The
success of this plan depends a great deal on achieving "vertical
integration" -- in other words, Windows running on servers, on individual
computers, and everything in between. Many believe that Microsoft's
future depends on .NET, making it all the more important that they clear
Linux from the path.

Since its congressional hearings, however, Microsoft's approach towards
Linux has gotten softer and more subtle. "There's no attempt on our part
to characterize open source as bad, or bad from a policy point of view,"
said Craig Mundie, senior vice president of advanced strategies at
Microsoft. Instead, they've co-opted open source strategies by creating
what they call "shared source." Through shared source, Microsoft has
made available a fraction of their program code. But unlike open source,
a developer is severely limited in the ability to modify and reuse that
code.

The open source community is not buying it. Boston-based Linux
developers Ximian recently announced plans for a software project they
hope will compete with .NET. The project will help .NET-type services
become popular by opening its doors to Linux users, but will undermine
Microsoft's control of it.

Linus Torvalds, who launched Linux a decade ago, has joked in the past
about achieving world domination. As his program celebrates its 10th
anniversary this month (at a BYOB event) Torvalds' once-laughable
dream seems more realistic than ever before. If Linux does become the
next Microsoft Windows, it will probably owe its success to a mixed
maelstrom of corporate forces, rather than the ambition of it creators.
After all, as the penguin-heads will tell you, their real goal is "not
world domination, but world liberation."




More information about the Ir-l mailing list