[Ir-l] Are users losing control of the Net? (ICANN)
Paul Mobbs
mobbsey at gn.apc.org
Mon Dec 9 14:39:35 GMT 2002
-----BEGIN PGP SIGNED MESSAGE-----
Hash: SHA1
http://www.observer.co.uk/business/story/0,6903,855767,00.html
Are users losing control of the Net?
Web's ruling body attacked for scrapping democratic vision
Conal Walsh
Sunday December 8, 2002
The Observer
It has always had its critics, but this time the internet may really have lost
its innocence. Many readers will never have heard of the Internet Corporation
for Assigned Names and Numbers (Icann), but it is the nearest thing the world
wide web has to a 'government'. And it has just decided to get rid of
representatives voted in by internet users.
For some, the move is a betrayal of the democratic, liberating, inclusive
traditions of the web. Critics fear it will put the internet into the hands
of big business and governments.
One such critic is Karl Auerbach, one of Icann's outgoing directors, who told
The Observer that the Los Angeles-based body 'has repudiated the concept of
public participation in the internet.'
Icann disagrees. 'You can't have a global democracy without a globally
informed electorate,' says Esther Dyson, its founding chairman. Besides,
Icann argues, the reform will streamline its decision-making and make it more
responsive to internet users, thus answering the persistent complaint that it
has not provided web addresses quickly enough to cope with demand.
All this is to be thrashed out at Icann's annual meeting in Amsterdam his
month. The summit is likely to be a milestone for the internet body, which
has spent the first four years of its life in a state of constant evolution.
Icann's powers are strictly circumscribed, but it does control the huge
central registry that operates the internet's worldwide addressing system. It
sets up and oversees the allocation of the most importantdomain names, such
as dotcom and dotorg, as well as country codes, such as dotuk and dotfr.
Established to replace a plethora of American government and academic bodies,
and run by a motley collection of geeks and entrepreneurs, it operates as a
private, not-for-profit company.
One of its earliest tasks was to set up an effective arbitration system to
tackle 'cybersquatters' - such as the pornographer formerly behind
'madonna.com' - who attempt to profit from company or celebrity trademarks.
Auerbach dismisses this achievement, accusing Icann of 'acting as a handmaiden
to the trademark industry'. He claims the agency is siding with business
interests who fear that the creation of large numbers of internet domains
could jeopardise their brands.
Icann, he says, has created an artificial scarcity of domain names. 'It could
be adding hundreds or thousands of new domains every year, with no technical
problems,' he says. 'By not doing so, it is making a major social policy
decision that goes well beyond any scope ever assigned to it. It is creating
rules that dictate who may or may not use the internet.'
Icann's directors certainly include representatives and alumni from industrial
powerhouses, such as Fujitsu, Siemens and MCI. Nor are intellectual property
lawyers under-represented on the 18-man executive board. On the other hand,
and for all its undoubted intimacy with the US Department of Commerce, Icann
has been scrupulous about keeping government representatives out.
Instead, it makes policy via a decentralised structure of advisory committees,
working groups and task forces, peopled by representatives of all continents.
Yet this system has been attacked as inefficient and, ironically,
undemocratic. Edward Markey, a member of the Congressional telecoms and
internet subcommittee, recently complained: 'Events at the Vatican are
shrouded in less mystery than how Icann chooses new domain names.'
Icann's mandate will be reviewed by the US government next year. To ensure its
legitimacy, if not its survival, it will probably have to give lawmakers a
greater say. This dismays Michael Froomkin, a critic of the agency and a law
professor at Miami University.
'Icann was created to save the internet from governments, but is now turning
to governments to save it from the internet,' Froomkin said.
Icann is also having trouble outside the US, not least in Britain. Nominet,
appointed by the UK Government to run the registry of dotuk domain names,
resents the large fees it has to pay Icann for running the 'root server'
computers that handle worldwide internet traffic.
It also claims Icann is using this controlling position as leverage to meddle
in policy decisions affecting the internet in this country.
Then there is China, with its 50 million internet users. Discussions in
Amsterdam will probably focus on the peculiar operational needs of this
fast-growing online community. However, the world's most populous country is
also likely to be given several seats on Icann's board.
The new directors will be industry, rather than government, figures, but
critics claim this is a meaningless distinction in China. Internet user
representatives claim they are being stood down from Icann in favour of a
regime with a history of internet censorship.
But Icann is probably going to have to listen to unsavoury governments if it
is to be a 'United Nations of the internet'. What this will mean for the web
- - which, so far, has been remarkably ungoverned and unregulated - is another
matter.
- --
- -------------------
"We are not for names, nor men, nor titles of Government, nor are we for
this party nor against the other but we are for justice and mercy and
truth and peace and true freedom, that these may be exalted in our nation,
and that goodness, righteousness, meekness, temperance, peace and unity
with God, and with one another, that these things may abound."
(Edward Burroughs, 1659 - from 'Quaker Faith and Practice')
Paul Mobbs, Mobbs' Environmental Investigations,
3 Grosvenor Road, Banbury OX16 5HN, England
tel./fax (+44/0)1295 261864
email - mobbsey at gn.apc.org
website - http://www.fraw.org.uk/mobbsey.html
public key - http://www.fraw.org.uk/keylist.html
-----BEGIN PGP SIGNATURE-----
Version: GnuPG v1.0.6 (GNU/Linux)
Comment: For info see http://www.gnupg.org
iD8DBQE99KsotEaNwM05jx0RAqPUAJ42MJU/J/nNcIci3WPqePTNi17UagCgihQG
k78AICUwRRqkQ2BbX9k5+3o=
=jIsn
-----END PGP SIGNATURE-----
More information about the Ir-l
mailing list