[Ir-l] circumventing copyright protection is okay

Tony Gosling tony at gaia.org
Tue Dec 17 21:33:01 GMT 2002



http://www.reuters.co.uk/newsArticle.jhtml?type=internetNews&storyID=1923666
Firm cleared in digital copyright trial

SAN JOSE, Calif (Reuters) - A Federal Court jury has found a Russian 
company not guilty of criminal charges that it violated U.S. copyright law 
by selling a software program that can crack the digital locks used to 
secure electronic books.

Moscow-based ElcomSoft Co. was charged in federal court of violating the 
1998 U.S. Digital Millennium Copyright Act by selling a program that 
circumvents the digital copyright protections on Adobe Systems Inc. software.

The two-week trial in San Jose, California was the first criminal 
prosecution under the controversial DMCA, which prohibits the sale of 
technology used to break the digital locks on digitally formatted movies, 
music and other software.

The jury of eight men and four women deliberated for about two days before 
reaching the verdict on Tuesday. The trial had hinged on whether ElcomSoft 
had "willfully" violated the U.S. law, lawyers for the defence said.

"They never intended to violate the law," said defence attorney Joseph 
Burton of the San Francisco law firm of Duane Morris.

"We accept the jury's verdict," Kevin Ryan, U.S. Attorney for Northern 
California, said in a statement. "While disappointed, we are also pleased 
that the judge upheld the constitutionality of the Digital Millennium 
Copyright Act and the jurisdiction of the United States to bring these cases."

ElcomSoft's program, which sold online for about a month in mid-2001 for 
$99 before Adobe complained, allows users to make copies of electronic 
books, transfer them to laptops and have the computer read them aloud to 
the blind.

Prosecutors contended the program was akin to a burglar tool that could be 
used to make illegal copies of electronic books.

LEGAL IN RUSSIA

ElcomSoft President Alexander Katalov testified that he did not think the 
program, which was legal in Russia, was illegal in the United States. He 
said the program was not meant to be used for electronic books that had not 
been legally purchased.

Observers on both sides of the DMCA debate said they were pleased that the 
case was finally resolved.

"Today's jury verdict sends a strong message to federal prosecutors who 
believe that tool makers should be thrown in jail just because a copyright 
owner doesn't like the tools," said Fred von Lohmann, an attorney at San 
Francisco-based Electronic Frontier Foundation, which works to protect 
civil liberties in cyberspace.

"Although the jury decided the Digital Millennium Copyright Act had not in 
this case been violated, we are glad that prosecutors do believe that such 
cases have an appropriate place in our criminal justice system," said 
Robert Holleyman, chief executive of the Business Software Alliance trade 
group.

The case caused an international uproar after ElcomSoft programmer Dmitry 
Sklyarov was arrested in July 2001 following a talk he gave about the 
program at the DefCon hacker conference in Las Vegas.

Prosecutors agreed to drop charges against him in exchange for his 
testimony. His videotaped deposition was played in court by the prosecution 
and he was questioned in person in court by the defence.

Copyright holders pushed for the DMCA, arguing that they need it to prevent 
easy piracy in the digital age. Opponents say the law gives copyright 
owners more rights in cyberspace than they have elsewhere.



Bristol branch - National Union of Journalists
10-12 Picton Street
Montpelier
BRISTOL
BS6 5QA
http://lists.southspace.net/listinfo/nuj_bristol/
http://www.gn.apc.org/media/nuj.html
http://www.nuj.org.uk
0117 944 6219


---
Incoming mail is certified Virus Free.
Checked by AVG anti-virus system (http://www.grisoft.com).
Version: 6.0.427 / Virus Database: 240 - Release Date: 06/12/02

--
Tony Gosling
10-12 Picton Street
Bristol
BS6 5QA
England
+44 (0)117 944 6219
fax +44 117 942 0164

All emails are 'cleartext' to the NSA - "Capitalism is institutionalised
bribery" [TG]

"Tony Gosling" <tony at gaia.org>
http://www.tlio.org.uk
http://www.bilderberg.org
http://www.cultureshop.org
http://www.videonetwork.org
http://www.public-interest.co.uk/bbc/
http://www.ecovillages.org/uk/network/
-------------- next part --------------

---
Outgoing mail is certified Virus Free.
Unless you're using Norton Antivirus.
Checked by AVG anti-virus system (http://www.grisoft.com).
Version: 6.0.427 / Virus Database: 240 - Release Date: 06/12/02


More information about the Ir-l mailing list