[Ir-l] Bush's plan to monitor Net raises stir
tony at gaia.org
tony at gaia.org
Sun Dec 22 22:28:33 GMT 2002
Apologies for the dire writing in this article but interesting
nevertheless.
Tony
http://www.msnbc.com/news/850160.asp?cp1=3D1
Bush plan to monitor Net raises stir
Administration official disputes New York Times report
By Bob Sullivan
MSNBC
Dec. 20 The White House wants Internet service providers to help
create a system to monitor Internet use, the New York Times reported
on Friday. But a high-ranking government official told MSNBC.com the
story was inaccurate. At the center of the confusion is the National
Strategy to Protect Cyberspace, which was released in draft form last
fall, and is now being revised in light of the new Department of
Homeland Defense.
AS PART OF the federal governments broader Homeland Defense
strategy, the Presidents Critical Infrastructure Protection Board
began work last year on the National Strategy to Protect Cyberspace.
From the moment the group began work, there was general
agreement that Internet service providers must work together and
quickly share information during cyberattacks and virus outbreaks.
Currently, each Internet service provider acts independently,
with its own network operations center that allows security
specialists to constantly monitor network traffic. Such centers allow
ISPs to spot outages, attacks and virus outbreaks quickly, but the
information is currently only informally shared, with the various
network operations centers contacting each other on an ad-hoc basis.
The Bush administration sought to formalize such data sharing
through the creation of a Cyberspace Network Operations Center,
which would serve as a central clearinghouse for such data. But in
last Septembers draft of the national strategy, it clearly stated
the center would not be a government entity and would be managed by
the private sector.
The New York Times reported Friday that the Bush
administration had changed its mind and was now pushing for direct
government involvement in the central operations center. ISPs and
others who have seen the plan fear direct government participation in
the center could turn it into a grand surveillance mechanism a Big
Brother for the Internet.
But an administration official who is familiar with the plan
disputed the Times report Friday, saying the Cyberspace Network
Operations Center is still slated to be a private industry effort. He
said as part of the new Homeland Defense department, various
government agencies concerned with cyberspace security, such as the
FBIs National Infrastructure Protection Center and the Computer
Emergency Response Team at Carnegie-Mellon University might be
consolidated. But he denied there has been a shift in the
administration which would put government in charge of a central
Internet monitoring facility.
The Bush administration plans to submit a revised proposal of
The National Strategy to Secure Cyberspace early next year.
SECURITY OR MASSIVE WIRETAP?
The mere suggestion of government involvement in such a
facility raises alarm bells among industry watchers and privacy
experts.
An unnamed source in the New York Times article suggested the
government-run network operations center would be 10 times worse
than Carnivore, the FBIs system for monitoring e-mail.
Stewart Baker, a Washington lawyer who represents several
large providers, said firms are under an awful lot of pressure to
participate in a new central Internet traffic monitoring facility.
(ISPs) do have the ability to look at whats coming out of an
individual users machine. ... If all that information goes into a
single NOC (network operations center) and government agents are
sitting there alongside ISP employees and you have government
officials seeing whats coming out of those machines, that sure
sounds like a wiretap to me.
But Baker said he wasnt sure how effective such a central
operations center could really be as a monitoring tool. Hunting for
terrorists by observing traffic coming and going from individual
computers would be a bit like finding a needle in a haystack, he said.
Instead, security specialists are much more likely to track
larger Internet traffic disruptions that could be precursors to
cyberattacks, such as the massive October attack on the Internets
key root nameservers.
This is not about finding al Qaida as they get ready to blow
up a bomb, Baker said. Theyre talking about cyberterrorism,
finding people who are attacking the Internet itself. Its not the
same as protecting people from physical attacks, Baker said.
Still, such a central observation point for Internet traffic
would raise the possibility of invasive government monitoring, and
Baker said ISPs are not convinced the potential security benefits are
worth the potential privacy risks.
There is a real question about how effective this NOC of NOCs
could be. And meanwhile, we are creating these risky tools, Baker
said. The people who run the (network operations centers) tend to be
skeptical.
http://www.msnbc.com/news/850160.asp?cp1=3D1&cp1=1
More information about the Ir-l
mailing list