[Ir-l] Court decision challenges Microsoft's claim to "Windows" trademark
Paul Mobbs
mobbsey at gn.apc.org
Fri Mar 22 13:42:03 GMT 2002
-----BEGIN PGP SIGNED MESSAGE-----
Hash: SHA1
http://newsforge.com/article.pl?sid=02/03/20/1516232
Anyone want to trademark "Linux for Windows?"
Wednesday March 20, 2002 - [ 04:48 PM GMT ]
- By Jack Bryar -
Not long ago Microsoft generated some new guidelines for how third parties
were to refer to its trademarked products. One change was that the company's
lawyers were insisting that "Windows" should never appear in any document,
even once, without an accompanying trademark registration mark right beside
it.
It may be a little late for that. Michael Robertson and Lindows.com won a
shocking preliminary victory in court Friday that threatens to turn a prized
Microsoft trademark into a generic term for software that doesn't work very
well. Even more surprising is how many experts say they predicted this would
happen.
Last December, when Microsoft filed suit against Lindows and its founder
Robertson, experts cautioned that Microsoft might be on dangerous ground.
Several intellectual property lawyers suggested that Microsoft had committed
several critical errors that might put its trademark at risk.
One problem was the company was using a generic term as a trademark. In their
short online primer on trademark law, Larry Lessig, David Post, and Eugene
Volokh suggest avoiding individual words and short phrases, and to
strenuously avoid generic words if possible. More than one U.S. court has
ruled that "a generic term ... even if it has acquired distinctiveness or a
secondary meaning" may not fall under the full control of any one company.
This is particularly important if a company is trying to avoid "dilution" of
the value of a trademark by preventing others from using similar words. The
more distinctive the word or phrase, the more likely a business can win a
court battle claiming that another firm's use of a similar word devalues the
goodwill associated with its trademark. Thus, a word like Coca-Cola is easier
to protect than a word like Windows. Sources suggest that, by continuing to
pick common names for products, including Sidewalk (U.S. Patent Office serial
#75976719), Slate, (serial#75114433) and Bob (#74603156), Microsoft has set
itself up for a continuing series of challenges.
Another trap for a would-be trademark holder is trying to overextend the
trademark to the point that it no longer identifies any distinctive set of
products or services. My examination of the U.S. Patent Office's TESS
database shows that Microsoft has filed more than 100 trademark applications
to broaden and extend its rights to the Windows trade name. Currently it has
registered Windows as a trademark for trade shows (#75371267) , smart cards
(#75573286), mail order (#75868853), tech support (#75868854) information
services and entertainment (#75879977), CDs and joysticks (#75702468), sound
systems (#74413669), printer cartridges (#74274174), even "computer programs
for use in automobiles" (#75980682). This over-extension risks confusion over
just what it is that Microsoft has been trying to trademark.
Oddly enough, the company never explicitly extended its Windows trademark to
cover software past its original claim, which was restricted to the
"graphical operating environment" for "microcomputers" (#74090419). There
appears to be no separate filing to cover such software for items as servers,
or for enterprise software. In addition, Microsoft originally treated its
trademark very narrowly. It filed a separate "Windows for Data" (#73636382)
trademark in 1987, for its software products, seven years before first
registering the word "Windows" by itself.
Even more damaging, Microsoft committed a cardinal sin for a would-be
trademark holder; it enforced its trademark inconsistently, litigating some
firms while allowing others to use the word Windows without any apparent
penalty. For example, in various applications to the Patent Office, most
notably #74716365 Microsoft filed to extend Windows as its exclusive
trademark for magazines. However, it allowed both Penton and CMP to publish
magazines with Windows in the title.
Dohring Online initially applied for a trademark for "Datacomp for Windows."
Although the trademark did not get registered, the company had used it
without challenge for six years. Delta Systems originally applied for a
trademark for Quickcheck for Windows. While that name was never formally
registered, the product has resurfaced as EZ Check for Windows. Northeast
Monitoring still uses the phrase Holter for Windows for its instrumentation
package. Geologic Systems applied for a trademark for GeoScout for Windows,
and , although the company abandoned its registration effort, Geologic still
uses Windows as a part of its product name. The product name "Wise for
Windows" was used for years by Microsoft partner Wise Inc. at the same time.
Wise abandoned its attempt to secure a trademark, for the phrase but it still
uses the product name without interference from its partner. The product
called CQ for Windows still exists without any reference to Microsoft in
federal courseware programs.
In addition, the word "Windows" and a host of variants are used by a variety
of other companies for all sorts of products and services. Among them, the
owner of hardware store in Arkansas, who trademarked a phrase never heard in
Redmond, "Windows that Work," in 1997 (#75474275).
Microsoft may be in the media business, but the name Windows as a trademark
for entertainment services is owned by a couple of fellows on Route 4 in
Martin, Tennessee. Windows is also a trademark (#75174557) of the Randall
Products International for its line of cosmetics. Windows is a trademark
(serial # 76296937) of George M. Leader Family Corp. for its brand of
"healthcare services for patients afflicted with dementia." At one time,
Windows was a trademark of the Kimberly Clark for that company's brand of
urinal cleaner-deodorizers, a claim not abandoned until 1998. Window is the
trademark (#75886964) held by a Taiwanese medical hardware company best known
for its line of bone screws. Cyber Window is held (#75761099) by Japan's AVIX
Inc., for its line of electronic display devices. Windough is registered to
the Interactive Toaster Corp. for a game. Even the U.S. Patent Office itself
has been allowed to get sloppy with the Windows trademark. The Patent
Office's Web site features a text retrieval product it calls "Document
Delivery for Windows" (DocDW).
Before the trial began, the Lindows CEO had warned, "we are looking forward
to showing the court the widespread use of the term 'windows' or variations
thereof by literally hundreds of companies which are not endorsed or
sponsored by Microsoft." The court saw the same pattern and has now
threatened to deprive Microsoft of one of its most valuable assets.
It is worth noting that the company has had plenty of troubles with the
Windows trademark, almost from the beginning. The company's trademark was
originally turned down in the United States, and prompted a lawsuit threat by
Borland Corp. that was only settled with a payment of over a million dollars.
Sloppiness in defining its trademark and in filing led to unending troubles
in Europe. When Microsoft filed a complaint against AG Communications Systems
for using the brand Windowphone, it was slapped down by a French Court, which
overturned Microsoft's claims that it had been using Windows since 1983. The
court said said that Microsoft had no claim on the term until late 1992, if
not well afterwards. In Britain, Microsoft's trademark application languished
for years.
As late as 2000 the Korean Patent Court rejected Microsoft's attempt to
overturn the "Window" trademark held in Korea by Yangji Total Stationery Co.,
a producer of daybooks and diaries based in Seoul. The Microsoft suit was not
only turned down, it backfired. As a result Microsoft almost lost any rights
to use the name Windows in Korea. Today Microsoft's Web site in Korea
features the phrase "Microsoft Windows" with a registration mark but not
Microsoft® Windows® as it would in the United States.
While the judge's ruling in the Lindows case is only preliminary, several
intellectual property lawyers described it as "devastating." IP lawyers
suggest that it means that, for the time being, any software company could
use the word Windows if it wanted to. That prompted the comment by several
members of the hacker community, "But who would want to?"
- --
- -------------------
"We are not for names, nor men, nor titles of Government, nor are we for
this party nor against the other but we are for justice and mercy and
truth and peace and true freedom, that these may be exalted in our nation,
and that goodness, righteousness, meekness, temperance, peace and unity
with God, and with one another, that these things may abound."
(Edward Burroughs, 1659 - from 'Quaker Faith and Practice')
Paul Mobbs, Mobbs' Environmental Investigations,
3 Grosvenor Road, Banbury OX16 5HN, England
tel./fax (+44/0)1295 261864
email - mobbsey at gn.apc.org
website - http://www.fraw.org.uk/mobbsey.html
public key - http://www.fraw.org.uk/keylist.html
-----BEGIN PGP SIGNATURE-----
Version: GnuPG v1.0.4 (GNU/Linux)
Comment: For info see http://www.gnupg.org
iD8DBQE8mzSrtEaNwM05jx0RAvNXAKC+TxCEaJEoRu6ZmMzCQsGPYYLjgwCgt5Jf
4vVrki5hnFLdUksIYr/m2Qs=
=Gugd
-----END PGP SIGNATURE-----
More information about the Ir-l
mailing list