[Ir-l] New study on what lack of privacy in the US costs business and consumers

Paul Mobbs mobbsey at gn.apc.org
Wed Mar 27 09:43:46 GMT 2002


-----BEGIN PGP SIGNED MESSAGE-----
Hash: SHA1

Hi all,

An American study, but really interwsting in the context of the debate 
between EU and US on privacy.

Also, funded by the Ford Foundation, which is pretty mainstream.



http://www.epic.org/reports/dmfprivacy.html

"How The Lack of Privacy Costs Consumers and Why Business Studies of Privacy 
Costs are Biased and Incomplete"



Executive Summary

Privacy is an elusive, value-laden concept, and it is hard to reach consensus 
on a definition.  In recent, self-serving studies, the business community 
seized upon this lack of clarity to distort debates about the true costs of 
privacy ? costs to individuals, society and to the business community itself. 
 These studies have led to a mainly one-sided public discussion of privacy, 
overstating the costs to businesses, ignoring the costs consumers incur to 
protect their privacy, and understating the benefits that privacy offers to 
commerce and to society.

The cost of privacy is a legitimate issue, but the studies and the 
conclusions drawn from them have serious flaws.  They suggest that: 
consumers? demands for privacy are irrational and that consumers do not know 
what is in their own interest,  unrestricted trafficking in personal 
information ? the very thing that business wants ? always benefits 
individuals and privacy can be evaluated only on the basis of monetary costs 
and benefits.  

In fact, the costs incurred by both business and individuals due to 
incomplete or insufficient privacy protections reach tens of billions of 
dollars every year.  



Shortcomings with Business Studies

The privacy cost studies sponsored by the business community suffer from a 
variety of defects.  Studies of the credit reporting system seek to prove 
that the free flow of credit records benefits consumers while ignoring the 
benefits of legislation that gives consumers a wide range of privacy 
protections and legal remedies.  These policies demonstrate how privacy can 
be compatible with business success in the marketplace.

Some studies, offered as objective but written by trade association 
employees, rely on old business models that assume that past 
information-intensive marketing methods are the only way to do business in 
the future.  New ways to find consumers are ignored, as is the amount of 
business lost under current practices because of privacy concerns.

Calculating consumer benefits is the basis for some cost/benefit estimates.  
However, the definition of consumer benefits is so broad as to include the 
nonconsensual sale and exploitation of consumer information that most, if not 
all, consumers would reject, if given an informed choice.  



Costs to Business of Not Protecting Privacy

The absence of privacy rules imposes expenses on businesses that many 
industry-sponsored studies ignore when calculating the costs of privacy.  For 
example, consumers routinely abandon shopping carts on websites because of 
demands for too much personal information.  Analysts estimate that Internet 
retail sales lost due to privacy concerns may be as much as $18 billion.

Attempts by business to show losses from privacy protections often reflect 
only traditional models of marketing that may be less effective than 
privacy-friendly approaches.  Relationship marketing ? based on the use of 
large amounts of personal information ? may not be as effective as permission 
marketing, where consumers select what advertising they want to see.

Because many other countries have comprehensive privacy laws, the United 
States is significantly behind international privacy standards.  The European 
Union limits the export of data to organizations in countries that do not 
have adequate privacy protections.  The result is lost opportunities for U.S. 
businesses and higher costs when providing privacy protections for imported 
personal data.  Better U.S. privacy protections could expand international 
business opportunities and reduce costs.

Accumulated personal data is increasingly attractive to law enforcement 
agencies, other businesses, and private litigants.  Businesses are spending 
more and more time and money responding to subpoenas for their compilations 
of personal data.

Investors lost hundreds of billions of dollars in companies with business 
models based on exploiting personal information obtained from Internet users. 
 The lack of privacy protections led many to believe wrongly that personal 
data could be exploited without limit.  



The Costs Consumers Incur When Privacy Is Not Protected

When laws and practices do not provide adequate protections for personal 
information, individuals act to protect themselves and their privacy.  The 
costs incurred by individuals to protect themselves from unwanted view or 
intrusion constitute a privacy toll paid in both dollars and time.  The 
privacy toll includes costs associated with higher prices, stopping junk mail 
and telemarketing calls, avoiding identity theft and protecting privacy on 
the Internet.  A privacy sensitive family could spend between $200 and $300 
and many hours annually to protect their privacy.  

Supermarket frequent shopper cards and other registration and monitoring 
programs coerce consumers to sell their personal information for lower prices 
at the cash register.  Customers unaware of or unwilling to sign up for these 
programs often pay more. 

Traditional junk mail is a longstanding consequence of the inability of 
individuals to control the collection, compilation, and sale of their 
personal information.  The average person receives more than ten pieces of 
junk mail each week, of which nearly half is discarded unopened and unread.  
Opting out of junk mail often requires writing multiple letters, which is a 
small expense, but still a significant barrier for most individuals.

About 80% of Americans strongly object to receiving unsolicited sales calls 
and, to prevent or deter these telemarketing calls, many households buy 
services such as Caller ID, call waiting, answering machines or voice mail, 
and unlisted or unpublished numbers.  Some estimate that 25% of households 
pay an average of $1.50/ month to be unlisted.  The total price that 
telephone subscribers pay for privacy-protecting services is more than $400 
million/year.

Identity theft is a growing threat that creates financial and other hardships 
for hundreds of thousands of individuals each year.  Identity theft results 
in part from the ready availability of personal information and the lack of 
protections that would give individuals more control over that information.  
It can take years of hard work and hundreds or thousands of dollars in 
out-of-pocket expense before all vestiges of identify theft are removed from 
a victim?s record.  In the interim, a victim of identity theft may be unable 
to obtain a job, purchase a car, or qualify for a mortgage.  Government 
agencies advise individuals seeking protection against identity theft to 
purchase copies of credit reports annually or to subscribe to credit watch 
services.  Annual costs for a family can easily exceed one hundred dollars 
annually while estimates of losses for financial institutions appear to be in 
the hundreds of millions.  Identity theft undermines consumer confidence, 
deters the growth of electronic commerce, and increases costs that may be 
passed on to consumers.

Unwanted commercial electronic mail, often called spam, imposes costs on 
Internet users who cannot control the collection and sale of their email 
addresses.  Users spend hours each year downloading and deleting spam.  Spam 
also raises costs for Internet providers, delays service to users, and 
undermines the vitality of the Internet as a means of open communications.  
Estimates are that worldwide costs of spam range from $8-10 billion.

Broader effects of the lack of privacy cannot be measured in dollars.  The 
effects on individuals and institutions due to the evolving ?dossier society? 
are significant and often unwelcome.  Non-economic interests protected by 
privacy policy and laws include avoiding solicitations, the exercise of First 
Amendment rights, and protection of children.



- -- 
- -------------------

"We are not for names, nor men, nor titles of Government, nor are we for
this party nor against the other but we are for justice and mercy and
truth and peace and true freedom, that these may be exalted in our nation,
and that goodness, righteousness, meekness, temperance, peace and unity
with God, and with one another, that these things may abound."
(Edward Burroughs, 1659 - from 'Quaker Faith and Practice')


Paul Mobbs, Mobbs' Environmental Investigations,
3 Grosvenor Road, Banbury OX16 5HN, England
tel./fax (+44/0)1295 261864

email - mobbsey at gn.apc.org
website - http://www.fraw.org.uk/mobbsey.html
public key - http://www.fraw.org.uk/keylist.html

-----BEGIN PGP SIGNATURE-----
Version: GnuPG v1.0.4 (GNU/Linux)
Comment: For info see http://www.gnupg.org

iD8DBQE8oZRatEaNwM05jx0RAt5hAJ99MxiKKx/b4RLy3J46tDzpJh4j4gCgmycy
X2O/cxBtVjdAZFlGl6drQ+M=
=VwAY
-----END PGP SIGNATURE-----



More information about the Ir-l mailing list