[Ir-l] Smashing Down defenders of the wrongly accused.
Dave Bird
dave at xemu.demon.co.uk
Fri Mar 29 01:14:28 GMT 2002
Smashing Down defenders of the wrongly accused.
Dear Bennett, I have a couple of issues burning to circulate, but the
most important one is this material about Dr Bill Thompson. Can you
put this on the website and draw attention of Peacefire members to it:
the main person originating material and action on this is Avedon Carol
of Feminists Against Censorship. I'm not sure exactly what could be
done or who people could write to, initially I just want to get the
word out.
A QUICK PREFACE BY ME. Most people in England are now aware of
the Guildford Four, Birmingham Six, and other towns and numbers
of people we see now were falsely imprisoned. It was not an easy
cause to support in the early days. I remember as secretary of
a civil liberties group listening to one of our trade union contacts
put the case that perhaps the wrong people had been jailed. We were
uneasy about what we were getting into, but we realised it was the
falsity of the charges, not the horror of the crime charged, that
mattered. Much later I recall getting in touch with one of the six
(whom I'd never met until then), because an anti-censorship campaigner
called Bill Thompson sent me the case of a man called Nick Nicholls
who had been falsely convicted of murder over a death which was
by natural; causes, and the did lead to getting him out and helping
him rebuild his life. Later still I remember talking over my own
problems of serious depression with Bill, who had been left in a
pretty bad state by some people who were supposedly once his friends.
:::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::
That choice we made then was not an easy one. I often walked past
where the bombs went off, and sat round drinking with someone who
still had small bits of masonry in her from passing by at the wrong
time. It was the most horrible crime imaginable. It would be as
bad as now supporting someone falsely accused of, say, paedophile
attacks. Real paedophiles tend to want the same things from victim
to victim, and develop a regular method of seduction. Imagine you
find someone accused by different supposed victims of doing wildly
different things by wildly different ways of access, and of "turning
them into criminals" after they were in a home because they carried
out an armed robbery. That's the kind of work Bill Thompson did.
It was not popular with the local police. Who smashed their way into
his home and took obscene materials which he was an expert witness
upon, said they couldn't find his name as an expert witness when
it is on the Home Office (Interior Ministry) website as an expert
witness, had him suspended from his university job, and he will
probably never see or confront his accusers as would be his right
under American Law. Be aware of this case, and do anything you
can to protest it, for this is a very great injustice indeed;
who will defend the wrongly accused when the police smash down
their defenders; and where will people read the truth of it when
the police go round threatening ISPs out of carry dissenting websites
under no particular law just raw threat? Support Bill Thompson Now.
Dave Bird, dave at xemu.demon.co.uk . Main Text follows ---->
-----Original message-----
Subject: You make a lot of enemies
From: John O <mojuk at mojuk.org.uk>
Date: Mon, 25 Mar 2002 07:31:41 +0000
Message-ID: <p05100308b8c474041091@[213.122.204.76]>
==================
Miscarriages of JusticeUK (MOJUK)
Tele: 0121-554-6947 Fax: 0121-554-7891
mojuk at mojuk.org.uk
http://www.mojuk.org.uk
==================
You make a lot of enemies
"You make a lot of enemies when you point out that not
everyone accused of sexually assaulting children is guilty," "The
problem with the way cases are prosecuted at the moment is that it
is often not sex offenders who are being sent to prison, it is
innocent people."
Bill Thompson, a criminologist specializing in child abuse,
reckons that most of the care workers now in jail for sexual abuse,
should never have been convicted.
"The police went trawling for evidence, and an unholy alliance
of psychiatrists, social workers, judges and lawyers has allowed
evidence which is demonstrably flawed, if not worthless, to be used
to lock people up."
Thames Valley Police are hell bent on stopping the release of
people wrongfully convicted of sexual offences including child
abuse.
Over the past months increasing public concern over the way
convictions against 'care workers' and child abusers has greatly
increased.
Bill Thompson, a leading criminologist who has been leading in
exposing bad police practices of 'trawling for evidence ' and the
dangers of 'financial incentives for making allegations' has had his
home smashed up by police. His office at Reading University has also
been raided and all his records confiscated.
Questions are already being asked, as to why the police didn't
follow proper procedures, with action by Bill Thompson against
Thames Valley Police expected to take place in the High Court this
week.
================================
Silenced witness
by Alasdair Palmer, The Telegraph, (Filed: 24/03/2002)
The disturbing case of Bill Thompson, a criminologist
specializing in child abuse, and a police search for pornography.
Why was his home raided when he has legal protection? Alasdair
Palmer reports.
Bill Thompson is a lecturer at Reading University. He's a
criminologist and has built up an international reputation as an
expert on sexual assaults on children.
He testifies as an expert witness - analysing the evidence
presented by the prosecution and assessing whether it proves what
the prosecutors claim it does.
His expertise has been accepted by the courts and appears to
have convinced juries and appeal court judges: in every one of the
20 cases he has been involved in over the past two years, the side
on whose behalf he has given evidence - and it is almost invariably
the defence - has won.
Two weeks ago, Dr Thompson found that the door to his home had
been smashed in, his house searched, and his computer and many of
his files seized. The same happened in his office at Reading
University.
The raids were organised by Thames Valley Police.
Officers asserted they had information that Dr Thompson was in
possession of child pornography and obtained a search warrant from a
local magistrate before entering his premises.
Unfortunately, the police did not tell the magistrate that Dr
Thompson was an expert witness in a myriad of child sex cases.
Detective Sergeant Kate Ford, of the Marlow Child Protection
Group, who supervised the raid, explained that omission to Dr
Thompson's solicitor by saying that: "Dr Thompson claims to be an
expert witness, but he is not on any expert witness list we
checked."
Dr Thompson is baffled by that claim. "I am on the Home Office
website as an expert who has been consulted on the sentencing of
paedophiles. I am a practising associate of the British Academy of
Experts, which is recognised by the courts as an authenticating
body.
Experts employed within the criminal justice system and
academics conducting research are two of the six categories of
people specifically singled out by the Child Protection Act of 1978
(and its amendment of 1988) as having a statutory defence against
any criminal charge of possessing child pornography.
Dr Thompson and his lawyers will argue in the High Court next
week that it is extremely doubtful that the search warrant should
not have been authorised because Dr Thompson is an expert.
"You can't be an expert witness without having to evaluate this
sort of material. It is part of my job," Dr Thompson continued.
"I am frequently asked for an opinion of whether pictures
constitute child pornography: often the relevant pictures clearly
are obscene, and I will advise them that the pictures cannot be
defended. Clients often change their pleas as a consequence."
Dr Thompson has given lectures to police officers in which he
has explained the anomalous position that he and other experts such
as him occupy in relation to the Child Protection Act.
"We have a statutory defence against any prosecution," Dr
Thompson explained. "But it does not stop a prosecution from taking
place. Under the law as it stands, people like me can be charged and
prosecuted, even though no prosecution should succeed.
"Cork University has a multi-million-pound grant from the EU to
study child pornography on the internet. That research couldn't
happen at a British university because of the anomalous legal
position.
"I have pointed out that it would make sense if the police and
Home Office put together a list of experts who were allowed to look
at this stuff. The experts could be vetted to ensure that they were
not secret paedophiles. I would be quite happy for such a procedure
to be in place."
The police say that, in raiding Dr Thompson, they were simply
responding to "several" claims that Dr Thompson was downloading
"massive amounts" of child pornography from the internet.
"That claim is demonstrably false," insists Dr Thompson. "And
its falsity will be demonstrated the moment they go through my
computers."
Dr Thompson has no doubt that he can dispose of the allegation
that has been made against him. He doubts that he will even be
charged. Still, it will not be so easy for him to restore his
reputation: mud sticks.
He has been suspended form his university post while the
allegations are investigated. And merely being the subject of a
police raid has meant that Dr Thompson has been dropped as an expert
witness by the lawyers for several defendants on whose behalf he was
due to appear.
"You make a lot of enemies when you point out that not everyone
accused of sexually assaulting children is guilty," Dr Thompson
notes wearily.
"People say you are an apologist for paedophiles, that you are
trying to make the world safe for them. Of course it's nonsense. I
want people who are guilty of sexual assaults against children put
in prison.
"The problem with the way cases are prosecuted at the moment is
that it is often not sex offenders who are being sent to prison, it
is innocent people."
As an example, Dr Thompson cites the dozens of men who are now
serving terms of between 10 and 15 years for sexually assaulting
children in care homes.
The assaults are alleged to have taken place between 20 and 30
years ago. There have been financial incentives for making
allegations: the Criminal Injuries Compensation Board will pay out
up to £32,000 for sexual assault, and more is forthcoming if a suit
can be mounted against the care homes' insurers. Sums of as much as
£100,000 have been paid to those who claim to have been victims.
The men who made the accusations that they had been abused are
nearly all convicted criminals.
"They usually say that, had it not been for the abuse, they
would not have drifted into crime," Dr Thompson explains. "That
claim can often be shown to be false: in one case, for example, the
individual was in the care home because, even before he was in his
teens, he had committed an armed robbery."
What has convinced Dr Thompson of the bogus nature of many of
the allegations, however, is his analysis of the evidence that was
used to convict the men.
"In 1991," he says, "the Law Lords ruled that allegations could
be corroborated by volume - that is, the fact that there were
several of them could help to show that they were all true. I can
show that this principle is utterly mistaken. Volume, in these
cases, does not corroborate anything."
The case of Roy Shuttleworth is a typical example, he says. Mr
Shuttleworth worked in Greystone Care Home in Cheshire in the 1970s.
He was convicted and sentenced to ten years imprisonment in 1996 for
sexually assaulting children in his care.
That was despite the fact that one of those who accused him had
a conviction for attempting to obtain money from the Criminal
Injuries Compensation Board by deception, and that another was
exposed as a liar in a subsequent trial.
"When I went through the witness statements, each one
contradicted every other one. They all described Roy Shuttleworth as
assaulting them - but each one described a different method of
assault. This is, in my experience, quite unprecedented for genuine
paedophiles.
"A real paedophile almost always has a single modus operandi
which he develops and refines over time, and you find that reflected
in statements by their victims: they bribe, they buy their victims
something. They don't just suddenly assault, which is what Mr
Shuttleworth was described as doing.
"That is not the only anomaly. When you draw up plans of
Greystone, you find that what Mr Shuttleworth was alleged to have
done was logistically impossible: you couldn't get out of the
windows which one 'victim' said he had escaped from, and you
couldn't walk naked across the school - as another claimed - in
broad daylight without being noticed.
Furthermore, when the surviving duty rosters are compared with
some of the dates on which Shuttleworth was supposed to have
committed assaults, it became clear that he wasn't even in the care
home at the time."
Dr Thompson cites Derek Brushett, who was headmaster at
Bryn-y-Don Care Home in South Wales and was sentenced to 12 years
for sexually assaulting those in his care, as another example of a
case where "corroboration by volume is not corroboration.
"It is in fact contradiction. None of the statements support
each other. If you look at them closely, it becomes absolutely clear
that Mr Brushett should never have been convicted," he says.
At least 60 men are in prison as a result of the care home
investigations. Bill Thompson has no doubt that most of them should
never have been sent there.
"The police went trawling for evidence, and an unholy alliance
of psychiatrists, social workers, judges and lawyers has allowed
evidence which is demonstrably flawed, if not worthless, to be used
to lock people up.
"There is no doubt that there has been child abuse in care
homes. Sixty years ago it was rife, and those who made accusations
were not believed. But now we have gone to the opposite extreme:
guilt at past failures has produced an uncritical desire to believe
every allegation.
"That has produced a legal disaster. People are being sent down
for 10 or 15 years on evidence that wouldn't even be good enough to
produce a court hearing for an accusation of any other crime."
It is not only the care home cases where enthusiasm to secure
conviction in child abuse cases has produced serious injustice.
"There are dozens of them in `domestic' abuse cases," says Dr
Thompson.
"The police and social services techniques for interviewing
children are almost universally abysmal. They are as bad as they
were in the Cleveland case. Despite all the reports and criticism,
nothing has changed since that scandalous episode over a decade ago.
"In practically every case, they break the guidelines. They
make suggestions - in fact, they tell the child what to say. It is
appalling.
"To my knowledge, only one police force actually uses a safe
interview technique: Derbyshire. If all officers followed their
example, I would never be able to find anything wrong with interview
statements."
Dr Thompson's outspoken opposition to many of the techniques
that have become standard in child abuse cases has created a great
deal of opposition. If he is right, however, there are scores,
perhaps hundreds, of men now in prison for offences against children
which they did not commit.
It is a genuinely "appalling vista" - and one which, as yet,
neither the judiciary nor the Home Office seems willing to confront.
Meanwhile Dr Thompson, who has been willing to confront that
possibility, finds himself facing the allegation that he is a
paedophile.
-----End of original message from John O-----
-- . ___ .
'-|:::|@\-[x]/__/| .-|:::|@\
||--|"" . |__|/ ||--|"" .
'-|:::|@\ (")"""-. .-|:::|@\ --+--.(")"""-'
|| |"" ||""| || |"" ' ' |""|
DEMOCRACY: two wolves & a lamb LIBERTY: a lamb with a kalashnikov
voting what's for lunch contesting the vote
More information about the Ir-l
mailing list