[Ir-l] G8 Interior Ministers call for rollback of data protection laws & blanket traffic data retention
Caspar Bowden
cb at fipr.org
Thu May 16 14:12:23 BST 2002
If you would like to receive periodic bulletins from FIPR
subscribe by sending an email (subject line and body are not relevant)
to: bulletin-request at admin.fipr.org
----------------------------------------------------------------------
The G8 Justice and Interior Ministers meeting (Canada May 13-14) have
issued a number of documents relating to data protection and retention
of Internet traffic data (http://www.g8j-i.ca/english/pubs.html)
The issue is whether blanket retention of traffic data on the entire
population should be permitted (effectively making every Internet user
susceptible to continuous surveillance of their online activity), or
whether data should only be recorded on specifically designated targets
or groups. Although the G8 refers to Sep 11 and terrorism as
justification, there is no proposal to limit the use of data to
terrorist cases.
It contains the following statement which parallels the current
controversy on the new EU Communications Privacy Directive
(http://www.statewatch.org/news/2002/may/05surv.htm).
"...To the extent that data protection legislation continues to permit
the retention of data only for billing purposes, such a position would
overlook crucial legitimate societal interests - particularly when
applied to the Internet service provider area, where flat rate pricing
and free Internet and E-mail services foreclose the need to retain
traffic data for billing purposes - and thereby seriously hamper public
safety. The G8 also believes that when data protection legislation
allows specific derogation to the general regime on specific grounds,
this should not be the exclusive means for recognizing these other
interests, since the default rule would continue to require
destruction." http://www.g8j-i.ca/english/doc5.html
There is also a schedule of the types of traffic data that may be of
interest http://www.g8j-i.ca/english/doc3.html
A call for governments to permit blanket traffic data retention, roughly
corresponding to the CoE Cybercrime treaty
http://www.g8j-i.ca/english/doc3.html
A checklist of legal issues http://www.g8j-i.ca/english/doc3.html
[FIPR's position paper on data retention can be found at
http://www.law.duke.edu/journals/dltr/]
--
Caspar Bowden
Director, Foundation for Information Policy Research
Tel: +44(0)20 7354 2333 www.fipr.org
More information about the Ir-l
mailing list