[Ir-l] FLASH: new EU Presidency position on traffic data retention (not good)

Caspar Bowden cb at fipr.org
Fri May 17 17:10:06 BST 2002


The following document, dated yesterday, is published on the EU Council
website. They are propoals from the Presidency to the member state
governments for revised positions on negotiating the new Comms Data
Protection Directive.

The sections dealing with data retention are below. In essence they
attempt to legitimise blanket retention of traffic data on entire
populations, and pass the buck to ECHR jurisprudence.

This is in stark contrast to the position taken by Stefano Rodota, Chair
of the official EU Watchdog on data protection :

"Systematic and preventive storage of EU citizens communications and
related traffic data would undermine the fundamental
rights to privacy, data protection, freedom of expression, liberty and
presumption of innocence. Could the Information Society still claim to
be a democratic society under such circumstances ?"

ARTICLE 29 - DATA PROTECTION WORKING PARTY 7th June 2001
http://www.statewatch.org/news/2001/jun/07Rodota.pdf

--
Caspar Bowden
Director, Foundation for Information Policy Research
Tel: +44(0)20 7354 2333                 www.fipr.org

(see orginal : for changes with regard to the common position are
indicated in bold, whilst changes to the amendments submitted are in
bold italics.)
http://register.consilium.eu.int/pdf/en/02/st08/08657en2.pdf

Recital 11

(11) Like Directive 95/46/EC, this Directive does not address issues of
protection of
fundamental rights and freedoms related to activities which are not
governed by
Community law.

Therefore it does not alter the existing balance between the
individual's right to privacy
and the possibility for Member States to take the measures [.] referred
to in Article
15(1) of this Directive, necessary for the protection of public
security, defence, State
security (including the economic well-being of the State when the
activities relate to
State security matters) and the enforcement of criminal law, such as
those which allow
Member States to require the provider of a public communications network
or
publicly available electronic communications service to retain traffic
and location
data in accordance with the law. [.]

Consequently, this Directive does not affect the ability of Member
States to carry out
lawful interception of electronic communications, or take other
measures, if necessary
for any of these purposes and in accordance with the European Convention
of Human
Rights and Fundamental Freedoms as interpreted by the rulings issued by
the
European Court of Human Rights. Such measures must be appropriate,
strictly
proportionate to the intended purpose and necessary within a democratic
society.

....
Article 15(1)

1. Member States may adopt legislative measures to restrict the scope of
the rights and
obligations provided for in Article 5, Article 6, Article 8(1)(2)(3) and
(4), and Article 9
of this Directive when such restriction constitutes a necessary,
appropriate and
proportionate measure within a democratic society to safeguard national
or State
security, defence, public security or the prevention, investigation,
detection and
prosecution of criminal offences or of unauthorised use of the
electronic communication
system, as referred to in Article 13(1) of Directive 95/46/EC. To this
end Member States
may inter alia adopt legislative measures providing for the retention of
data for a
limited period justified on the grounds laid down in this paragraph. All
the measures
referred to in this paragraph shall be in accordance with the general
principles of
Community law including those referred to in Article 6 paragraphs 1 and
2 of the
Treaty on European Union. [...]

(Amendment 32 acceptable with small modification)

Recital 11

(11) Like Directive 95/46/EC, this Directive does not address issues of
protection of
fundamental rights and freedoms related to activities which are not
governed by
Community law.

Therefore it does not alter the existing balance between the
individual's right to privacy
and the possibility for Member States to take the measures [.] referred
to in Article
15(1) of this Directive, necessary for the protection of public
security, defence, State
security (including the economic well-being of the State when the
activities relate to
State security matters) and the enforcement of criminal law, such as
those which allow
Member States to require the provider of a public communications network
or
publicly available electronic communications service to retain traffic
and location
data in accordance with the law. [.]

Consequently, this Directive does not affect the ability of Member
States to carry out
lawful interception of electronic communications, or take other
measures, if necessary
for any of these purposes and in accordance with the European Convention
of Human
Rights and Fundamental Freedoms as interpreted by the rulings issued by
the
European Court of Human Rights. Such measures must be appropriate,
strictly
proportionate to the intended purpose and necessary within a democratic
society.




More information about the Ir-l mailing list