[Ir-l] Saudi cyber censorship foiled

Tony Gosling tony at gaia.org
Mon May 20 20:24:26 BST 2002


http://www.al-bab.com/media/docs/saudi.htm

http://www.guardian.co.uk/elsewhere/journalist/story/0,7792,443261,00.html


Losing the Saudi cyberwar 

The Saudi government's attempts to filter the internet for 
its citizens are narrow-minded, unrealistic and, it seems, 
doomed to failure, says Brian Whitaker


Monday February 26, 2001 

The authorities in Saudi Arabia, who recently boasted that 
they had found a way to censor the internet, are now 
licking their wounds in a cyberwar against an opposition 
group based in London. 
It is only two years since the authorities decided - 
nervously - to connect their country to the internet. They 
were worried, right from the start, that internet users 
could not be trusted to stay away from pornographic, 
gambling and other "undesirable" websites. 

So they spent vast sums on a computer system at King 
Abdulaziz City of Science and Technology in Riyadh, which 
has Saudi Arabia's only recognised link to the internet, 
to filter out offending material. In May last year, Dr 
Fahd al-Hoymany, director of the monitoring system, 
announced triumphantly that his team had succeeded in 
blocking all major pornographic sites. 

But that was not the whole story. They were quietly using 
the same technology to block politically sensitive sites 
which criticised the Saudi government. 

The Saudis' internet censorship works in two ways. First, 
it caches approved web pages in a 500-gigabyte storage 
system. This allows the most popular pages to be accessed 
quickly without the system having to check their 
suitability each time. It also means that what users in 
Saudi Arabia see is not the original page on a server 
outside the country, but a copy on the computer in Riyadh. 

Requests for pages that are not stored in the cache are 
passed to the second stage of the system, supplied by a 
US-based company, Websense, which lists and can filter out 
30 categories of potentially unsuitable sites. Maintaining 
the list of banned sites is a mammoth task for the team in 
Riyadh, because of the need for regular updating. 

Among those they tried to ban was a website belonging to 
the London-based Movement for Islamic Reform in Arabia 
(MIRA). As its name suggests, the site is certainly not 
pornographic, though it does contain some highly 
unflattering profiles of Saudi princes. 

For a while, MIRA and the Saudi authorities played a 
cat-and-mouse game. Each time the site was blocked, MIRA 
moved to a new web address. It usually took the 
authorities a week to find the new address and block it. 
In the meantime, MIRA's problem was how to communicate its 
new address to web users in Saudi Arabia. 

That, according to Dr Saad Fagih of MIRA, has now been 
solved - and it's the opposition's turn to claim victory. 
MIRA's solution - like the Saudis' censoring system - 
consists of two stages. The first is some technical 
tweaking of port numbers which allows MIRA to switch its 
website almost instantly to any one of 64,000 addresses 
without having to register a new domain name. 

The second is a smart way of telling people where to find 
the site. Users simply send a blank email to 
islah at islah.org and within 60 seconds or so they get an 
automated reply giving the current address. Provided that 
users send their message by webmail - Hotmail, Yahoo, etc 
- there is no way the authorities can stop it, Dr Fagih 
says (if you try this, bear in mind that MIRA's site is in 
Arabic, so you may see a lot of question marks or weird 
symbols if your web browser doesn't support Arabic 
script). 

As proof of his victory over Big Brother in Riyadh, Dr 
Fagih says the number of hits on the site has leapt from 
20,000 a day to 75,000. What is more, he claims that Big 
Brother has finally abandoned its efforts to block the 
site (he knows this, he says, because MIRA's technicians 
are able to hack into the computer in Riyadh and check). 

Belatedly, the Saudi authorities have also recognised that 
their expensive censoring system may not be as effective 
as they thought. But their response has been bizarre. On 
February 12, the Council of Ministers laid down new 
internet rules for the kingdom. Among other things, these 
ordered internet users to refrain from accessing data 
containing the following: 

? Anything contrary to the state or its system
? News damaging to the Saudi Arabian armed forces
? Anything damaging to the dignity of heads of states
? Any false information ascribed to state officials
? Subversive ideas
? Slanderous or libellous material 

At one level, this is almost a self-parody, providing 
abundant ammunition for all those who decry Saudi Arabia 
as a backward, medieval country with more money than 
sense. It smacks of the attitude found in Britain a few 
hundred years ago among those who believed the masses 
should not be taught to read in case they got some 
unsuitable ideas into their heads. 

At another level, it demonstrates that the Saudi 
government is living in a fantasy world where internet 
users are endowed with magical powers which allow them to 
determine whether a web page contains false information, 
subversive ideas or libellous material even before they 
have looked at it.

http://www.guardian.co.uk/elsewhere/journalist/story/0,7792,443261,00.html

-------------- next part --------------

---
Outgoing mail is certified Virus Free.
Checked by AVG anti-virus system (http://www.grisoft.com).
Version: 6.0.332 / Virus Database: 186 - Release Date: 06/03/02


More information about the Ir-l mailing list