[Ir-l] The FBI Has Bugged Our Public Libraries

Tony Gosling tony at gaia.org
Wed Nov 6 19:47:05 GMT 2002


Bill Olds
The FBI Has Bugged Our Public Libraries
http://www.ctnow.com/features/lifestyle/hc-privacy1103.artnov03col.story

November 3, 2002
Some reports say the FBI is snooping in the libraries. Is that really
happening?
Yes. I have uncovered information that persuades me that the Federal Bureau
of Investigation has bugged the computers at the Hartford Public Library.
And it's probable that other libraries around the state have also been
bugged. It's an effort by the FBI to obtain leads that it believes may lead
them to terrorists.

Many members of the public regularly use computers in libraries to access
the Internet for research purposes or to locate information about
particular interests. It's also not uncommon for students and others to
communicate with friends and relatives through e-mail from there.

The FBI system apparently involves the installation of special software on
the computers that lets the FBI copy a person's use of the Internet and
their e-mail messages. (Don't ask me how I know about this because I can't
reveal how I was able to collect the information.) Members of the public
who use the library have not been informed that the government is watching
their activities. It's not just the computers. Circulation lists that show
which books someone borrowed are also accessible to the government.

What are the Hartford librarians saying?
"I can't disclose that we were presented with anything," said Louise
Blalock, Hartford's head librarian.

I asked Mary W. Billings, the library's technical services manager, if the
FBI had given her a subpoena or a court order for library information. Her
response: "I cannot answer that question."

She did confirm that in recent months the FBI made two separate visits to
the Hartford Library, and there were discussions about "computer-related
information." On one visit, an agent asked to speak to the library staff -
a request that was turned down.
Interestingly, Billings said, "The library is now working on a public
notice that it can't guarantee that there isn't third-party monitoring" for
people who use its computers. A library staffer also remarked, "You know
there is software that can grab everybody's Internet use."

I know my librarian, and I believe she would tell me if the government were
tracking my computer use at the library. Don't you agree?

No way. There's a gag order. When the FBI uses a court order or a subpoena
to gain access to library computers or a list of the names of people who
have borrowed certain books, librarians can't tell anyone - not even other
librarians or you. They face a stiff federal penalty if they do. It's
unfair that librarians should be placed in such a position.

Does this mean that when I use the library's computer to do research for
college papers on Saudi Arabia or Islam, the FBI could be following my
steps on the Internet?
Very possible. Of course, it may depend on which library you visit. And
there's no way you're going to be able to find out. The librarians can't
tell you, and you're not going to spot the special software in the
computers. Even if the software hasn't been installed, there's a back door
for the FBI to tap in through. The Internet service providers (businesses
located elsewhere) are required to cooperate with the authorities, and spy
software can be installed at that end.
But isn't this snooping only going to be used against people suspected of
being terrorists?

That's not how it works. It can check on everyone who uses the bugged
computers. The rules allow this kind of surveillance even if someone is not
suspected of being a terrorist or under any kind of suspicion.

Is there a state law that protects my privacy in the library?

Yes. Circulation records must be kept confidential. However, a new federal
law - the U.S. Patriot Act - takes priority over the state rule and allows
the FBI to have easy access to these records as well as to the computers.

What are the FBI and the Congress saying about all of this?

Mum's the word. The FBI has refused to discuss the issue, and Congress
wants to get more information. It has asked Attorney General John Ashcroft
to describe what the FBI has been doing in the libraries. But Ashcroft also
is not talking and has indicated he doesn't have to answer to Congress.

I've got nothing to hide when I go into a library, and I don't care if the
FBI sees what I'm doing at the computer. What's the big deal?

We all want to be safe, and I don't know anyone who opposes the prosecution
of terrorists. However, the way it is carried out is important. It comes
down to a key question: How does a democracy deal with serious threats from
terrorists and maintain its own freedoms?

Three points to consider:

1.) We have to be very careful that we don't fight terrorism in a way that
destroys democracy. Terrorists may want us to accept their methods and the
idea that our democracy should be tossed away. If that's what they achieve,
we will have walked into a trap, and we will have given them a major victory.

2.) Libraries exist to provide information and knowledge to the public.
When our own government places librarians in the position of participating,
possibly against their will, to "watch" the public, it runs counter to
vital principles that have guided us for much of our history.

3.) Protecting our freedom includes being able to openly communicate with
each other without worrying that the government is listening or looking
over our shoulders. The mere suspicion that we're being watched, even if
we're wrong, can intimidate us in expressing our views. If Americans are
only going to say and read what is "politically correct," our democracy
will be in deep trouble.

Questions can be sent to Bill Olds, in care of The Hartford Courant,
Features Department, 285 Broad St., Hartford, CT 06115 or by e-mail at
docbillo at yahoo.com.
E-mail:
	docbillo at yahoo.com
--
Tony Gosling
10-12 Picton Street
Bristol
BS6 5QA
England
+44 (0)117 944 6219

Encrypt messages to me using PGP 
http://www.bilderberg.org/tonyhom.htm#encrypt

"Tony Gosling" <tony at gaia.org>
http://www.tlio.org.uk
http://www.bilderberg.org
http://www.cultureshop.org
http://www.videonetwork.org
http://www.public-interest.co.uk/bbc/
http://www.ecovillages.org/uk/network/
-------------- next part --------------

---
Outgoing mail is certified Virus Free.
Unless you're using Norton Antivirus.
Checked by AVG anti-virus system (http://www.grisoft.com).
Version: 6.0.408 / Virus Database: 230 - Release Date: 24/10/02


More information about the Ir-l mailing list