[Ir-l] Spammer must pay $98,000

tony at gaia.org tony at gaia.org
Sun Oct 20 12:02:54 BST 2002


Spammer must pay $98,000
Oregon man violated state law on unsolicited e-mails
http://seattlepi.nwsource.com/local/91993_spam19.shtml

By CANDACE HECKMAN
SEATTLE POST-INTELLIGENCER REPORTER

A prolific e-mailer was ordered yesterday to pay more than $98,000
for flooding Washington computers several years ago with dubious
offers to make money through the Internet.

A King County Superior Court judge last month found that Jason Heckel
of Salem, Ore., violated the state's law against sending misleading
and unsolicited commercial e-mail that could not be traced. 

Yesterday, Judge Douglass North fined the 28-year-old Heckel the
maximum penalty, $2,000, for one violation of the rule. The rest of
the penalty is for state's attorneys' fees and court costs. The total
is $98,197.74.

The case, originally filed in 1998 after the state's anti-spam law
took effect, was the first of its kind in the country. Similarly,
yesterday's fine, the first of its kind, may set a standard for other
cases pending against senders of unsolicited commercial e-mail. 

Heckel was found liable last month through a summary judgment, which
meant that the state's evidence was so overwhelming that the case
didn't have to go to trial.

But because state attorneys did not have the opportunity to present
their entire case to a jury, the judge ruled that Heckel violated the
law based on one e-mail. The $2,000 penalty was for that one e-mail.

Regardless, Heckel lawyer Dale Crandall said he plans to appeal. He
argued that individual state laws against Internet spam violate the
U.S. Constitution's protection of interstate commerce.

"It would create a patchwork of laws that would be impossible to keep
up with," Crandall said.

Since Washington passed its anti-spam law four years ago, 26 states
have followed suit.

Washington's law does not make all spam illegal. Only e-mails that
use a deceptive subject line, misrepresent the e-mail's origin or use
someone else's domain name without permission are prohibited.

Heckel's messages began with the subject lines, "Did I get the right
e-mail address?" and "For your review-HANDS OFF!" And when consumers
tried to reply to the e-mail, the message came back as undeliverable. 

The Heckel case developed a national profile as states and federal
government tried to regulate activities over the Internet without
restricting constitutional rights, such as free speech.

In 2000, another King County Superior Court judge found the law
unconstitutional, but the next year the Washington State Supreme
Court upheld the law. The U.S. Supreme Court declined to hear
Heckel's case on appeal.

The protracted legal battle has increased costs on both sides of the
issue. The state yesterday was awarded two-thirds of the fees it
asked for.

It's unclear whether Heckel made enough from his Internet enterprise
to pay the fees and fine. His business involved selling pamphlets on
making money through the Internet.

His attorneys will not comment on whether he can pay the court
judgment. But the Washington Attorney General's Office maintained in
its lawsuit that Heckel sold an average of 30 to 50 pamphlets a month
at $39.95. State lawyers say Heckel sent 100,000 to 1 million e-mails
a week for about a year.

Attorneys argued that Heckel sent as many as 20,000 e-mails to
Washington residents in 1998. The state asked for $20,000 in fines
for multiple violations.

Still, the state is not expecting someone to cut a check soon, said
Cheryl Reid, spokeswoman for the Attorney General's Office.

"The most significant victory is that the law has been upheld," Reid
said. "The law allows people themselves to take spam cases to court."

This report includes information from The Associated Press. P-I
reporter Candace Heckman can be reached at 206-448-8348 or
candaceheckman at seattlepi.com



More information about the Ir-l mailing list