[Ir-l] Deathblow to U.S cryptography regulations?

tony at gaia.org tony at gaia.org
Tue Oct 22 14:31:56 BST 2002


Professor's Case: Unlock Crypto  

By Brad King 

http://www.wired.com/news/technology/0,1282,55884,00.html

02:00 AM Oct. 19, 2002 PDT

Daniel Bernstein seems intent on striking the deathblow to U.S.
government regulations on cryptography. 

The latest chapter in his decade-long battle began to unfold on
Friday, when lawyers representing both the Department of Commerce and
Bernstein, a University of Illinois associate professor of
mathematics, statistics and computer science, prepared to ask federal
district court judge Marilyn Hall Patel to grant a summary judgment.
At stake: the last remnants of a system that once prevented U.S.
citizens from releasing software code that creates secure, electronic
communications. 

Bernstein is trying to eradicate the last of the export laws that
previously kept Americans from distributing any work related to
cryptography. 

It's a bit confusing to some in the cryptography arena who feel that
the current laws allow anyone to distribute their programs without
fear of reprimand. Bruce Schneier, security expert and author of
Applied Cryptography, said the future battle over encryption won't be
trying to free software code, but rather preventing corporations from
using it to limit rights. 

"We always thought about cryptography as being a tool to protect the
little guy versus the big guy," said Schneier. "It never occurred to
us that the Digital Millennium Copyright Act would get passed." 

Even with the looming fight over the DMCA, many are still
uncomfortable with the court battle Bernstein continues to wage. 

"When you empower people to do things, we empower them to do bad
things," said Mike Godwin, staff council at the Center for Democracy
and Technology. "It's a hard problem: What do you allow people to do
in a free society? This is the hard part of democracy. You have to
end up trusting people." 

The problem, the government claims, occurs when the technology falls
into the hands of people outside democracies. Earlier this year, for
example, The Wall Street Journal bought a computer in Kabul,
Afghanistan, that held encrypted files. The news organization broke
the security -- with the help of the government -- revealing a wealth
of information about al-Qaida activities. 

The security was relatively easy to break, since the al-Qaida
operatives who owned the computer used an off-the-shelf, 40-bit
encryption program. However, if they had used one of the newer, more
powerful encryption programs, those messages would likely have been
lost forever. 

That has been the heart of the government's fight to limit general
access to cryptography for the last 30 years. It does this by
requiring people to apply for a license called a commodities
jurisdiction. Without this license, nobody can export any
cryptography product, which includes publishing it on the Web -- and,
for good reason, according to Stewart Baker, an affable Washington
lawyer with Steptoe &amp Johnson. 

Baker, who was general counsel for the National Security Agency from
1992 until 1994, said there is strong evidence, for example, that
World War II was won because we had better cryptographers than
Germany and Japan. Behind tight security at Fort Meade, Maryland, the
NSA has teams of mathematicians and programmers working on the some
of the world's most powerful supercomputers, making and cracking
codes. 

Making the knowledge freely accessible to everyone, Baker said, takes
away one of the United States' strategic advantages. 

Bernstein has repeatedly beaten back the government's attempt to
restrict cryptographic technology. But, Baker said, much of that
battle was waged during a different political climate. 

"If it had come up 10 years later, this battle probably could have
been won," Baker said. "But even then it would have been a very hard
battle because there are so many valuable uses for encryption.... My
guess is that at the end of the day, we would have ended up here." 

Here is a place where very strong public encryption technology is
available to the public, thanks to a handful of people, working in a
loose collective led by Dr. Whitfield Diffie. The group developed
their own system for secure communication that was so strong the NSA
deemed it a threat to national security to sell it commercially. That
started an epic battle between the government and the technology
community, which is chronicled in Steven Levy's book Crypto. 

The legal flare-up began in 1995 when Bernstein filed suit against
the State Department, claiming the export laws that limited where
academics could publish their research were unconstitutional. 

With the help of Cindy Cohn, now a staff attorney with the Electronic
Frontier Foundation, Bernstein successfully challenged the
government's ability to restrict publishing code. In 1999, Patel
agreed with Cohn. Three years later, the 9th Circuit Court of Appeals
upheld Patel's ruling. 

Since then, the government has eased restrictions on export
technology, although the government still maintains the right to
limit certain exports. 



More information about the Ir-l mailing list