[Ir-l] Anti-abortion site among latest banned by Google
Tony Gosling
tony at gaia.org
Sat Oct 26 14:56:41 BST 2002
You might like to see some of the evidence of Google's connections with the
US Department of Defense I've been collecting at
http://www.bilderberg.org/legal.htm#NSA
They've also pulled their anti-Scientology links - full marks to CNET news
keeping track of this.
If you have a minute check out http://www.Jesus-is-lord.com/ and see if you
think there's any justification for banning it.
Tony
Google excluding controversial sites
http://news.com.com/2100-1023-963132.html?tag=fd_top
By Declan McCullagh Staff Writer, CNET News.com October 23, 2002, 8:55 PM PT
Google, the world's most popular search engine, has quietly deleted more
than 100 controversial sites from some search result listings.
Absent from Google's French and German listings are Web sites that are
anti-Semitic, pro-Nazi or related to white supremacy, according to a new
report from Harvard University's Berkman Center. Also banned is
Jesus-is-lord.com, a fundamentalist Christian site that is adamantly
opposed to abortion.
Google confirmed on Wednesday that the sites had been removed from listings
available at Google.fr and Google.de. The removed sites continue to appear
in listings on the main Google.com site.
The Harvard report, prepared by law student Ben Edelman and assistant
professor Jonathan Zittrain, and scheduled to be released Thursday, is the
result of automated testing of Google's massive 2.5 billion-page index and
a comparison of the results returned by different foreign-language
versions. The duo found 113 excluded sites, most with racial overtones.
"To avoid legal liability, we remove sites from Google.de search results
pages that may conflict with German law," said Google spokesman Nate Tyler.
He indicated that each site that was delisted came after a specific
complaint from a foreign government.
German law considers the publication of Holocaust denials and similar
material as an incitement of racial and ethnic hatred, and therefore
illegal. In the past, Germany has ordered Internet providers to block
access to U.S. Web sites that post revisionist literature.
France has similar laws that allowed a students' antiracism group to
successfully sue Yahoo in a Paris court for allowing Third Reich
memorabilia and Adolf Hitler's "Mein Kampf" to be sold on the company's
auction sites. In November 2001, a U.S. judge ruled that the First
Amendment's guarantee of free speech protects Yahoo from liability.
Google's battles The Harvard report comes as Google is becoming
increasingly embroiled in international political disputes over copyright
and censorship. China blocked access to Google last month.
Google was criticized in March for bowing to a demand from the Church of
Scientology to delete critical sites from its index. In a response that won
praise, Google replied by pledging to report future legal threats to the
ChillingEffects.org site run by law school clinics.
As Google has become the way more and more people find information on the
Internet, it has also become an increasingly visible target for copyright
complaints about cached information and allegedly infringing links.
ChillingEffect.org's Google section lists 16 requests or legal threats the
company has received in the past three months. One Google competitor and
critic even suggested that the wildly popular search engine be transformed
into a government-controlled "public utility."
Edelman, who created the program that tested URLs against Google's index,
said he was investigating a tip about Google's German-language version.
"One concern that I've had for some time vis-a-vis filtering is that
filtering is almost always secretive," Edelman said. "In the (library
filtering) case, that meant you can't look at the list of blocked sites. In
the Chinese government case, you can't see what sites are being blocked."
Edelman, who is a first-year law student, testified as an expert witness
for the American Civil Liberties Union (ACLU) in a court challenge to a law
requiring libraries to install filtering software if they accept federal
funds. He is also a plaintiff in a second lawsuit filed in June to
eviscerate key portions of the Digital Millennium Copyright Act.
Google's response Google refused to reply to a list of questions that CNET
News.com sent via e-mail, including which sites have been delisted, how
many sites have been delisted, what standards are used, and what other
Google-operated sites have less-than-complete listings.
In an e-mail response, Google's Tyler said: "As a matter of company policy
we do not provide specific details about why or when we removed any one
particular site from our index. We occasionally receive notices from
partners, users, government agencies and the like about sites in our index.
We carefully consider any credible complaint on a case-by-case basis and
take necessary action when needed. This is not pre-emptive--we only react
to requests that come to us...to avoid legal liability, we remove sites
from Google search results pages that may conflict with local laws."
Tyler said an internal team involving lawyers, management and engineers
makes the final decision on what to remove. "At Google we take these types
of decisions very seriously," he said. "The objective is to limit legal
exposure while continuing to deliver high quality search results that
enable our users to find the information they need quickly and easily."
Tyler pointed to Google's terms of service agreement, which says Google
will "consider on a case-by-case basis requests" to remove links from its
index.
A moving target Because Google has to keep track of a constantly moving
target--new sites arguably illegal under French or German law appear every
day--the search engine is encountering the same problems of
overinclusiveness that traditional filtering software has experienced.
According to the Harvard report, some sites that Google does not list
include 1488.com, a "Chinese legal consultation network," and 14words.com,
a discount Web-hosting service and some conservative, anti-abortion
religious sites. Those sites do not appear to violate either German or
French laws.
Banned from Google.de and Google.fr listings is Stormfront.org, one of the
Internet's most popular "white pride" sites. Stormfront features discussion
areas, a library of white nationalist articles and essays by David Duke, a
former Ku Klux Klan leader.
"We've been dealing with this for quite a few years," said Don Black, who
runs the site. "The German police agencies seem obsessed with Stormfront
even though we're not focused on any German language material."
Black, who learned a few months ago that Google.de delisted Stormfront,
says he doesn't hold it against the Mountain View, Calif.-based company.
"Google is trying to conform to their outrageous laws," Black said. "So
there's really nothing we can do about it. It's really a French and German
issue rather than a Google issue."
The First Amendment Because Google is a company and not a government
agency, it has the right in general to delete listings from its service or
alter the way they appear. (On Tuesday, however, CNET News.com reported
that an Oklahoma advertising company has sued Google over its position in
search results.)
"Google may not only have the legal right to (delete listings), they may
have the legal obligation to do it," said Barry Steinhardt, director of the
ACLU's technology and liberty program, and a co-founder of the Global
Internet Liberty Campaign.
"Over the long term, this will become a significant issue on the Net,"
Steinhardt said. "There's a wide variety of laws around the world
prohibiting different forms of speech. You can imagine what the Chinese
government prohibits versus what the French government prohibits versus
what the U.S. government prohibits."
Edelman, of Harvard's Berkman Center, suggests that Google find a way to
alert users that information is missing from their search results.
"If Google is prohibited from linking to Stormfront, they could include a
listing but no link," Edelman said. "And if they can't even include a
listing for Stormfront, they could at least report the fact that they've
hidden results from the user. The core idea here is that there's no need to
be secretive."
--
Tony Gosling
10-12 Picton Street
Bristol
BS6 5QA
England
+44 (0)117 944 6219
Encrypt messages to me using PGP
http://www.bilderberg.org/tonyhom.htm#encrypt
"Tony Gosling" <tony at gaia.org>
http://www.tlio.org.uk
http://www.bilderberg.org
http://www.cultureshop.org
http://www.videonetwork.org
http://www.public-interest.co.uk/bbc/
http://www.ecovillages.org/uk/network/
-------------- next part --------------
---
Outgoing mail is certified Virus Free.
Unless you're using Norton Antivirus.
Checked by AVG anti-virus system (http://www.grisoft.com).
Version: 6.0.404 / Virus Database: 228 - Release Date: 15/10/02
More information about the Ir-l
mailing list