[Ir-l] A response to criticism of 'distributed Denial of Service' (dDoS) protest actions online
Paul Mobbs
mobbsey at gn.apc.org
Wed Apr 2 22:11:44 BST 2003
-----BEGIN PGP SIGNED MESSAGE-----
Hash: SHA1
Hi all,
After consultation, the collective has issued the following.
I think the general feeling in the collective is that we'd love to be taken to
court in this (in Europe, of course) just to get these issues straightened
out.
P.
- - -----------
A response to criticism of 'distributed Denial of Service' (dDoS) protest
actions online
the electrohippie collective, 1st April 2003
Since launching our online protest action against the Downing Street and
Whitehouse web sites nearly two weeks ago, the electrohippie collective has
received lots of communications encouraging and supporting the online
campaign. We have also receive a far smaller number of communications
objecting to the protest as 'hacking', or as an 'infringement of free
speech'.
the collective has decided to respond, outlining our case for why the dDoS
actions against Blair and Bush's web sites are valid. We appreciate that this
is a VERY long text. But we urge all to read it before they respond.
What we have sought to do is address the terse 'it restricts freedom of
speech' argument by looking the issue from the position of the design of the
action, International law, and whether there is such as thing s freedom of
expression or communication online.
1. The design of the action
Neither the Whitehouse nor 10 Downing Street web site are essential services.
For the most part they merely distribute the fallacious justifications for
action in Iraq, as well as trying to promote the image of the two prime
movers behind war in Iraq; Messrs Bush and Blair.
At no point do the actions we are mounting prevent online communication with
Bush. Blair is a different matter because he refuses to get himself and email
address, which in our view is his problem. In any case, we have launched the
'free distribution' page, with contact details for Bush, Blair, and many of
the political organisations they are involved with. The purpose of this is to
help people navigate around any problems they might have contacting the two
leaders.
- - From the outset, the design of this action has sought to minimise disruption
to communication, whilst at the same time, highlighting and personalising the
role of Bush and Blair in this war by seeking to restrict access to their web
sites.
2. International law
The UN Universal Declaration of Human Rights provides for freedom of
expression and communication. But these are not 'fundamental' rights,
equivalent to the right to life, or the right to freedom from torture or
slavery. Rights which are not fundamental rights must be considered in
conjunction with other human rights, or legal statues based upon them.
Under International law, the obligation on all nation states is to resolve
disputes by peaceful means. This is enshrined in Article 2(3) of the UN
Charter which states:
"All Members shall settle their international disputes by peaceful means in
such a manner that international peace and security, and justice, shall not
be compromised."
The general use of force is prohibited by Article 2(4) of the UN Charter which
obliges all members of the UN to:
"refrain in their international relations from the threat or use of force
against the territorial integrity or political independence of any State or
in any other manner inconsistent with the Purposes of the United Nations."
This is a pre-emptory rule of international law from which States may not
derogate, and this obligation is said to be the cornerstone of modern
international law.
These general prohibitions are qualified by only two exceptions:
1. The use of force in necessary self-defence
2. A Security Council authorisation of force.
Clearly , there has been no UN mandate for action. This has been confirmed by
the UN Secretary General who stated that any military action in Iraq would be
outside the terms of the UN Convention.
The characteristics of self-defence include that this is defensive action as
opposed to responsive or retaliatory action. Justifiable self-defence
requires an assessment of the threat to the UK, which must be imminent, and
an identification of the source of the threat, to which defensive action must
be directed. The conditions of necessity and proportionality are universally
recognised as requirements of the law of self-defence. Thus any purported
justification by the UK of the use of force for self-defence must be based on
evidence of an imminent second attack or on a continuing attack that need to
be pre-empted. An appraisal must then be made, in the light of facts, of the
necessity and effectiveness of the measures proposed to counter that threat
and whether the measures are proportionate to it.
In terms of armed attack, the express language of Article 51 contemplates
self-defence only: "if an armed attack occurs against a Member of the United
Nations".
As such, according to the International Court of Justice, "States do not have
a right to armed response to acts which do not constitute an 'armed attack'".
So, on the one hand we have Bush and Blair, without the requisite approval
under International law, violating the fundamental right to life of Iraqi
civilians. On the other, we have the electrohippie collective, aided by
thousands of individual Internet users, restricting their right of expression
via the web. On this point we would refer you to Article 30 of the UN
Universal Declaration of Human Rights:
"Nothing in this Declaration may be interpreted as implying for any State,
group or person any right to engage in any activity or to perform any act
aimed at the destruction of any of the rights and freedoms set forth herein."
That applies to the electrohippies, but it also applies to Bush and Blair. We
would argue that their violation is materially greater (i.e., they're killing
people unjustifiably, we're just restricting politicians rights to justify
that murder), but more than that we argue that our response is made within
the terms of Article 30. Bush and Blair, via their web sites, are seeking to
sanitise their violation of the Iraqi civilians fundamental right to life. It
is, in our view, valid then for us to highlight their violation of
fundamental rights by a method which seeks to restrict their misuse of the
right to freedom of expression under the UN Universal Declaration.
3. Freedom of Expression
Does freedom of expression exist in the USA and UK? We say, theoretically yes,
practically, maybe, and online definitely not.
We've always had problems in Europe because US hacker groups like Hactivismo
(aka Cult of the Dead Cow) have criticised us because 'the US Constitution
guarantees free speech'. Our usual response is, "we're based in Europe - the
US constitution doesn't apply here (yet), and we're glad it doesn't". But
let's look at this argument.
Theoretically, in the US people may rely on the constitution to guarantee free
speech. In the UK people can rely on the European Convention on Human Rights
to provide a legal means to enforce the same. But we are talking about
'enforcement'. You have to go to court. And this hurdle restricts all but
those who have the ready cash to go to court to defend their rights.
For example, 300,000 people march in New York against the war, and no major
media outlet in the US covers it. A much lauded US TV correspondent gives and
interview to Iraqi TV saying he doesn't thing the war is going to plan and he
gets kicked out of his job. Someone prints 'peace' on a T-shirt in
Pennsylvania and goes shopping in the local mall, and is arrested. In the UK,
people camp on a roadside verge near Fairford air base and are systematically
harassed, arrested, and perhaps soon prosecuted, because the state does not
want them there.
In war, the first casualty is freedom of expression. But beyond this, on the
Internet, you don't even have the same rights you have in real life.
Just about every government regards Internet connections as a matter of
contract law, not public law. Therefore you have only the rights guaranteed
in the contract, or the 'fair use' conditions, and not your rights guaranteed
under the European convention or the US constitution.
So any claim that you have 'rights' of expression online is clearly wrong. You
have only what your service provider gives you. Beyond that, you'd have to
challenge them under contract law through the courts - and you'll more than
likely lose because in this arena it's contract law that has the primary
weight, not civil rights law.
In conclusion
the electrohippie collective, in designing this action, have sought to
restrict its impact to only those sites that it targets. It does not restrict
the ability of the public to contact their leaders, even if the web sites go
down, and we've provided ample additional contact information to enable
people to contact their leaders in many ways.
In legal terms, we see a clear legal basis for the action given the framework
of laws that are offended by the actions of the USA and UK in Iraq. Did you
support the women who smashed up the hawk jets going to Indonesia, or the
people who recently damaged B52 support equipment at Fairford? It's the same
legal principles involved, so what the problem with what the electrohippies
are doing?
In terms of free speech, it doesn't exist. If you thought you had freedom of
expression online, you're deluded. Sorry, but that's the case in law. And
what happens in every case I've come across it is not the law that is used to
restrict free speech online, it's economic pressure. Service providers, be
they companies or universities, take down material or remove access because
of the economic pressures of threatened legal action. They can do this
because there is no counter-acting pressure created by a legal right to
freedom of expression online.
All comments gratefully received.
the electrohippie collective
1st April, 2003
- - --
============
"We are not for names, nor men, nor titles of Government, nor are we for
this party nor against the other but we are for justice and mercy and
truth and peace and true freedom, that these may be exalted in our nation,
and that goodness, righteousness, meekness, temperance, peace and unity
with God, and with one another, that these things may abound."
(Edward Burroughs, 1659 - from 'Quaker Faith and Practice')
Paul Mobbs, Mobbs' Environmental Investigations,
3 Grosvenor Road, Banbury OX16 5HN, England
tel./fax (+44/0)1295 261864
-----BEGIN PGP SIGNATURE-----
Version: GnuPG v1.0.7 (GNU/Linux)
iD8DBQE+i1IRtEaNwM05jx0RAgYdAJ4xDYCpFZzJ880UIK0phdPKtYo74gCgtOtB
MBR2YTfJaNMo44xBMtFevWs=
=WU0a
-----END PGP SIGNATURE-----
More information about the Ir-l
mailing list