[Ir-l] Rotten US energy companies blame hackers
tony at gaia.org
tony at gaia.org
Thu Aug 21 11:04:47 BST 2003
>Sources: Sabotage Cannot Be Ruled Out in Blackout
>
http://www.foxnews.com/story/0%2C2933%2C95049%2C00.html
>
>
>Tuesday, August 19, 2003
>
>Although government and energy-industry officials have
>continued to state that Thursday's massive power blackout
>was not an act of terrorism, they are unable to rule out
>the possibility that a computer hacker plunged 50 million
>people into darkness, a source told Fox News Monday.
>
>
>
>There were also reports that Al Qaeda had claimed
>responsibility for the outage, although U.S. officials
>said Monday that those claims should be taken with "a
>giant grain of salt."
>
>A source in the midst of the investigation into the
>blackout told Fox News there were signs the power grid was
>becoming unstable as early as Thursday morning.
>
>The final power outage took place at 4:11 p.m. EDT,
>cascading across lower Michigan, northern Ohio, southern
>Ontario, most of New York and New Jersey and parts of New
>England and Pennsylvania in just 9 seconds.
>
>Several 345-kilowatt transmission lines were dropping out
>of service, for reasons that still are unclear, in the
>hours leading up to the blackout. A knowledgeable source
>told Fox News that turning off such a heavy-duty line
>would be "like shutting down I-95 on the East Coast."
>
>Anatomy of a Power Failure
>
>Around 2 p.m. EDT, a 680-kilowatt line at a coal plant in
>Eastlake, Ohio, went out of service.
>
>At 3:06, a 345-kilowatt line at FirstEnergy Corp. (search)
>in Ohio shut down, but the alarm system didn't notify
>technicians.
>
>At 3:32, pressure from the first downed power line caused
>another 345-kilowatt line to apparently fail.
>
>At 3:41, two more lines of the same wattage shut down
>within five minutes of each other.
>
>At 4:10, two more 345-kilowatt lines in Michigan shut
>down, knocking a coal-fired plant offline.
>
>And at 4:11, a coal-fired plant and a nuclear plant in
>Ohio shut down, sparking the lightning-quick process that
>finally turned out the lights on the rest of the eastern
>Great Lakes and the New York metropolitan area.
>
>By the time the blackout spread outside Ohio and Michigan,
>wildly fluctuating voltages were overwhelming systems left
>and right.
>
>Investigators have been increasingly focusing on
>FirstEnergy, the nation's fourth-largest investor-owned
>utility. The Akron-based company has 16 power plants, an
>annual revenue of more than $12 billion and a service area
>that stretches from Ohio to New Jersey.
>
>FirstEnergy started noticing unusual voltage fluctuations
>in the Midwest power grid more than three hours before its
>transmission lines failed. The company said three of its
>transmission lines in the Cleveland area and the fourth it
>co-owns failed an hour before the blackout.
>
>The Midwest Independent System Operator (search) is also
>looking at four lines that went down, while the NERC, the
>utility oversight group, says three lines failed in
>northern Ohio.
>
>But FirstEnergy said these failures alone couldn't have
>triggered such a huge outage.
>
>Evidence of that, FirstEnergy said, is that its customers
>never lost power during earlier failures. Instead, last
>week's meltdown was indicative, the company said, of a
>series of breakdowns in the electric grid nationwide.
>
>In the entire history of FirstEnergy, FirstEnergy
>spokesman Todd Schneider said there hasn't been an outage
>of any system due to hackers, and that that the weather in
>northeastern Ohio did more damage.
>
>When asked if the random outages could have been the work
>of a computer hacker, a source told Fox News: "I'd be
>lying to you if I told you it was not possible." He added
>that a hack attack was something he had "been worried
>about."
>
>Schneider vowed his company would leave no stone unturned
>in its investigation. He admitted a computer hack was a
>possibility, but not the leading theory.
>
>The main question is why multiple safeguarding systems
>failed in their main task to "isolate the failure to one
>neighborhood," something the mid-Atlantic and New England
>grids were successful in doing.
>
>Allen Schreiber, chairman of the Ohio Public Utilities
>Commission (search), told Fox News that the fluctuations
>were the result of tree contact with the lines in two of
>the cases, but he stressed that the trees were at heights
>that meet utility standards. Plus, tree contact wouldn't
>cause such a catastrophic meltdown.
>
>"I think that when a power line touches a tree, which it
>does all the time, those power lines go out ? every day,"
>Schreiber said. "There's enough back up in the system,
>enough redundancy, that it should have made no difference
>at all."
>
>The North American Electric Reliability Council (search),
>an industry monitoring group, recently passed mandatory
>cybersecurity regulations for all utilities, but they had
>not been implemented.
>
>FBI officials said there was no reason to believe that the
>blackout was the result of a terrorist act, sabotage,
>hacker, or anything along those lines. While it was
>"monitoring the situation," it had not launched an
>investigation.
>
>Possible Al Qaeda Claim
>
>On Monday, the Arabic-language newspaper Al-Hayat ran a
>story saying a communiqué attributed to Al Qaeda claimed
>responsibility for the blackout, saying that "the brigades
>of Abu Fahes Al Masri" had hit two main power plants
>supplying the eastern region of the United States and
>major U.S. and Canadian industrial cities.
>
>The communiqué, reportedly posted on the Web site of the
>International Islamic Media Center (search) and translated
>by the Middle East Media Research Institute (search),
>assured that the operation "was carried out on the orders
>of Usama bin Laden to hit the pillars of the U.S.
>economy," as "a realization of bin Laden's promise to
>offer the Iraqi people a present."
>
>The communiqué also said: "Let the criminal Bush and his
>gang know that the punishment is the result of the action
>? the Americans lived a black day they will never forget.
>
>"They lived a day of terror and fear ... a state of chaos
>and confusion where looting and pillaging rampaged the
>cities, just like the capital of the caliphate Baghdad,
>and Afghanistan and Palestine were. Let the American
>people take a sip from the same glass."
>
>The statement outlined certain conditions Al Qaeda
>purportedly wanted met, including the release of all
>detainees held by the U.S. and for non-Muslim powers to
>leave the "land of the Muslims, including Jerusalem and
>Kashmir."
>
>It noted that the event shut down nine nuclear reactors in
>New York, New Jersey, Ohio and Michigan and brought public
>transportation and banking transactions to a halt.
>
>"We tell the people of Afghanistan and Kashmir that the
>gift of Sheikh Usama bin Laden is on its way to the White
>House."
>
>High-ranking U.S. officials basically laughed at the idea
>Al Qaeda could be behind the blackout.
>
>"I would take that one with a huge grain of salt," one
>official told Fox News.
>
>The source added that there had been no indication,
>domestically or internationally, that Al Qaeda or anyone
>else intentionally triggered the power-grid collapse.
>
>"It's probably a good PR stunt to put the idea out there
>that [Al Qaeda] could do that," terrorism expert Harvey
>Kushner told Fox News. "Certainly they're interested in
>having this type of capability, but they prefer, most
>certainly, a low-tech type of truck bombs, flying planes
>into buildings. They don't have this type of
>sophistication."
>
>"Quite frankly," Kushner added, "I wouldn't lose any sleep
>from the possibility they could take down power grids and
>things like that."
>
>Fox News' Bret Baier, Jeff Goldblatt, Ian McCaleb, Brian
>Wilson, Liza Porteus and Anna Stolley contributed to this
>report.
>
>http://www.foxnews.com/story/0%2C2933%2C95049%2C00.html
>--
>Visit Things From Another World for the best
>comics, movies, toys, collectibles and more.
>http://www.tfaw.com/?qt=wmf
More information about the Ir-l
mailing list